What is with this guy? I reckon every time I watch the Giants, which is pretty often, he plays awfully. Makes so many mistakes and he's never a point of difference ever. I don't and never will understand the hype.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
What is with this guy? I reckon every time I watch the Giants, which is pretty often, he plays awfully. Makes so many mistakes and he's never a point of difference ever. I don't and never will understand the hype.
What is with this guy? I reckon every time I watch the Giants, which is pretty often, he plays awfully. Makes so many mistakes and he's never a point of difference ever. I don't and never will understand the hype.
Extremely average player, I'm in shock clubs actually rate him. Honestly not worth more than a third rounder.
Yeh I'm with you, its like he can do everything, but nothing well.What is with this guy? I reckon every time I watch the Giants, which is pretty often, he plays awfully. Makes so many mistakes and he's never a point of difference ever. I don't and never will understand the hype.
500k
That would really surprise me to be honest. I know the money is there but I don't see why we'd he offering a huge contract when there really isn't a huge need for that type of player.Rumours Saints are offering more and it's a two horse race, Saints or Giants
On he Giants podcast they were saying, and it seems most of us agree, that he is on a lot of money with his current contract.If I'm our list manager I couldn't offer him a cent over $400k. He's just that reliable team player, a decent ruck is worth a lot more to us right now.
Yep, and we have a few holes on the list too - plus Bevo loves versatility.That would really surprise me to be honest. I know the money is there but I don't see why we'd he offering a huge contract when there really isn't a huge need for that type of player.
I think he'd actually be more suited to the Dogs and you guys have plenty of cap space as we know.
On he Giants podcast they were saying, and it seems most of us agree, that he is on a lot of money with his current contract.
Problem is he is a utility that isn't being either taken advantage of or he just isn't performing at a capacity that is worth the money.
350k for him from us.
If he want a lot more I wish him the best and tell him to enjoy rebuilding again at Saints or Carlton.
I know we only have won 3 games since R5. But just give us a chance, (in fact give both teams a chance). Before you say we are
Rebuilding.
Probably more accurate to say that we are continuing our rebuild. Problem is that we need a Cogs/Whitfield/Taranto type and not a Tomlinson type who is only a so so player. We already have many so so players.
ie Would Tomlinson be any better than say Acres on the wing?
Kinda play that GWS should trade (or should have traded) before contracts are up.
Worth more to other clubs than them IMO.
I reckon with Westhoff at 33 next season Tomlinson should be aggressively targeted.Key position player who has elite endurance and can play either end is rare
What makes him extra appealing is that he is a free agent. Victorian boy who could come home, he’s one who I think GWS would be willing to let go to keep others
I reckon with Westhoff at 33 next season Tomlinson should be aggressively targeted.
I'm trying to find his numbers. There isn't an injury to justify the drop. I'd be keen to see his distance covered, so long as he hasnt'had a positional change.You could replace Westhoff with a statue of Gavin Wanganeen and it would offer more than he does currently.