Oppo Camp Adam Treloar (Traded to Bulldogs 2020)

[CasuallyDressed]

What about Sidebottom? Most overrated player in Collingwood history

Yep. He's only given us what, 11 years of good service?

Definitely the most overrated player in club history.

 

[BoxMatrix]

Thought he was ok in the first half. Sidebottom is the one that needs to go

 

[Frank Gallagher]

Have you seen our VFL side this year?

Not a lot going on there...

Just give me someone who has a crack.

 

[Maggie5]

I say who will you replace him with?

 

[Quicky]

I've seen enough of this downhill skier, his kicking is atrocious and can't get a clearance to save his life, he is a major part of our current issues.

Misguided criticism. Treloar was one of the few we had tonight that fired a shot. Adams (and Beams if we're lucky) can't come back soon enough to support his effort.

 

[Quicky]

I say who will you replace him with?

There isn't anyone.

 

[Chief Ten Beers]

I say who will you replace him with?

Kelly.

Oh wait. We already paid overs for Beams and Wells. Oh well, next time.

 

[DerekZoolander]

Please no more 2 x 1st rounders for players, its killing us. We are looking at a massive fall from the top in the next few years.

 

[Maggie5]

Kelly.

Oh wait. We already paid overs for Beams and Wells. Oh well, next time.

Kelly injured.

Easy to call out someone to be dropped but then what are the options? Pretty disappointed tonight but until we get back some players, think he has done more than enough to keep his spot. Others much worse than him.

 

[Leviathan Pie]

What about Sidebottom? Most overrated player in Collingwood history

This.

His effort stinks. He’s soft, and been fairly putrid in 2019.

I’d absolutely drop him.

 

[Leviathan Pie]

Yep. He's only given us what, 11 years of good service?

Definitely the most overrated player in club history.

You can give good service, and be over-rated.

 

[Chief Ten Beers]

Kelly injured.

Tongue in cheek..

The other Kelly....who is out of contract at Geelong. But good thing we picked up Beams and still have Wells on the list!

 

[Frank Gallagher]

Misguided criticism. Treloar was one of the few we had tonight that fired a shot. Adams (and Beams if we're lucky) can't come back soon enough to support his effort.

His kicking is beyond bad, struggles to hit a target beyond 15 metres, you don't want someone like that getting it 40 times.

 

[PIEWITHSAUCE]

I thought Treloar was up the top in terms of effort from the big names we have remaining. Sure his kicking reeks but he's no Robinson Crusoe there.

 

[Maggie5]

Tongue in cheek..

The other Kelly....who is out of contract at Geelong. But good thing we picked up Beams and still have Wells on the list!

Don't look at me, I wasn't in favour of either.
Sometimes, one really doesn't like to be right.

However for mine, Treloar stays and not the worst, posters seem to remember all the bad things he does in a game.

 

[grayza2018]

Gee the knives come out quickly! Let's not start eating our own after one shocker

 

[Kirby]

Treloar was ok.

Sidebottom though? Jeepers, mr invisible mostly, then crops up for a dinky short stopping turnover

 

[Quicky]

His kicking is beyond bad, struggles to hit a target beyond 15 metres, you don't want someone like that getting it 40 times.

Early on Treloar wasn't kicking it because he was doing the heavy lifting in and under. In the last quarter he got to play more outside because De Goey was on ball. Those two up and under kicks, which I think is in everyones minds, were poorly executed but I felt we were trying to push things too much as a team. Treloar in that play is an example of that. We had too much to claw back.

 

[CaptainHowdy87]

He hasn't had a good game all year. I'd seriously replace him with Wills at this point.

Gotta try him in a different role where he can have even a modicum of impact on a game. Maybe give him a run with role or half forward role.

 

[FAIRANDBALANCED]

Treloar needs to play less midfield time, so when he is in there he can be explosive. Arm tackles are quite poor and needs to be supported by hard in and under players, which we dont really have at the moment. Sier, Beams and Adams were envisaged to be these players, with DeGoey assisting when Stepehson or Elliott are playing out of the goalsquare, but...we have just been reamed by luck again. Too many very good players unavailable.

Howe, Elliott, Langdon, Adams, Stephenson, Aish, Beams, Wells and now Sier and Reid. Given how long these guys are out, or have been out, It is past the point of return, imo.

 

[CaptainHowdy87]

He had the ball 39 times and went at 79% DE, 2nd most clearances on the ground and most tackles.

I don’t know what more you’re expecting when no other midfielder besides Pendlebury were supporting him.

Give it a rest, far worse players out there tonight.

No greater example of how misleading stats can be than this.

 

[nahnah]

Just happy he didn’t ping both hammies on that death trap field

 

[loki04]

Have you seen our VFL side this year?

Not a lot going on there...

Paying the price for trading out of nearly every draft over 6 seasons.

 

[Maggie5]

He hasn't had a good game all year. I'd seriously replace him with Wills at this point.

Gotta try him in a different role where he can have even a modicum of impact on a game. Maybe give him a run with role or half forward role.

Wills is another one injured.

 

[Cousin of Daicos]

Too late to drop players now.

We’ve let this form rot all year and now we have too many injuries to start dropping players now. These players should have all been dropped FAR earlier to wake them up.

This is it now. We just have to hope we can win enough games to keep our spot in the 8 because I’m struggling to see where we win 3 or 4 more games that we’re going to need.