Competitions AFC Board Draft Game 2017 Thread...

[FAITH]

Maggsy and dogs105 last call

 

[FAITH]

Just totalled the results (euro vision style) and its highly unlikely that 2 remaining sets of votes will affect things too much, so here we go:

Pre-Season Results 2018:

Minor Premiers - Daniel1812
2nd - Kristof
3rd - 1990crow

 

[FAITH]

4th -6th equal on votes which is incredible, but separated by who got the most top votes:

4th Danoz
5th hendo8888
6th Danger in Texas

7th Mr MysteryGuest
8th Scorpus

 

[FAITH]

not that far off 8th:
9th Danger Zone
10th FAITH Slight chance I could've sneaked in if the other votes came in but oh well.
11th Maggsy

12th Drugs Are Bad Mackay?
13th AdelaideFan14

 

[FAITH]

not gonna reveal the bottom 4 in order.
so alphabetically, deaneus dogs105 Hank93 roo2macca
better luck in the proper season game.

 

[Danger in Texas]

For the record, this was my top 8:

1: Kristof
2: hendo8888
3: Daniel1812
4: Danger Zone
5: Mr Mystery Guest
6: Scorpus
7: Maggsy
8: AF14

 

[TubbsFarquhar]

not gonna reveal the bottom 4 in order.
so alphabetically, deaneus dogs105 Hank93 roo2macca
better luck in the proper season game.

I finished second bottom in the pre-season draft last year and ended up winning so this really means nothing.

 

[hendo8888]

1 Danger In Texas
2 Kristof
3 1990Crow
4 Danoz
5 Drugs Are Bad Mackay?
6 Daniel1812
7 AdelaideFan14
8 Scorpus

 

[FAITH]

I finished second bottom in the pre-season draft last year and ended up winning so this really means nothing.

I remember baccs was the same.
I think scorpus won it last season not you

 

[TubbsFarquhar]

I remember baccs was the same.
I think scorpus won it last season not you

Maybe I finished last and ended up 2nd. Either way, my point stands.

 

[Mr MysteryGuest]

1. Daniel1812
2. Danoz
3. Kristof
4. 1990crow
5. Danger in Texas
6. Maggsy
7. AdelaideFan14
8. Drugs are bad a Mackay?

 

[FAITH]

Pre-Season 2018 Finals:

1 - Daniel1812 v 8th Scorpus

FB: Grant Birchall ~ Steven May ~ Matt Scharenberg
HB: Nathan Wilson ~ Daniel Talia ~ Marley Williams
C: Jaeger O’Meara ~ Dustin Martin ~ Jack Newnes
HF: Lewis Taylor ~ Tom Hawkins ~ Jake Melksham
FF: Brandon Matera ~ Peter Wright ~ Mark LeCras
R: Stefan Martin ~ Stephen Coniglio ~ Scott Selwood
Bench: Jackson Thurlow ~ Lachie Weller ~ Sam Gibson ~ Karl Amon

B Luke Hodge - Joel Hamling - Dylan Grimes
HB Shaun Burgoyne - Jackson Trengove - Jarrad McVeigh
C Matthew Suckling - Callan Ward (c) - Isaac Smith
HF Dayne Zorko - James Stewart - Richard Douglas
F Jake Stringer - Tom McDonald - Eddie Betts
R Zac Smith - Marcus Bontempelli - David Mundy
I Alex Neal-Bullen - Liam Duggan - Dale Morris - Tim O'Brien

2 - Kristof v 7th Mr MysteryGuest

FF: Jack Gunston - - Josh Kennedy - - Cam Raynor
HF: Darcy Parish - - Paddy McCartin - - Brett Deledio
C: Lachie Whitfield - - Dan Hannebury - - Shaun Grigg
HB: Zac Williams - - Ben Reid - - Pearce Hanley
FB: Heath Shaw -- Harris Andrews -- Luke Ryan
1st R: Max Gawn - - Trent Cotchin - - Dom Tyson
INT: David Armitage - - Michael Barlow -- Mason Cox - - Jayden Laverde

FB: J. MacMillan - M. Hartley - N. Haynes
HB: B. Maynard - K. Brand - J. Hunt
C: T. Scully - B. Crouch - S. Hill
HF: W. Milera - C. McCarthy - S. Edwards
FF: C. Ah Chee - T. Walker (C) - O. Fantasia
Foll: S. Naismith - A. Treloar - J. Steven (vc)
Int: L. Shiels - M. Kennedy - S. Lycett - T. Dickson

3 - 1990crow v 6th Danger in Texas

FB: Grant Birchall ~ Steven May ~ Matt Scharenberg
HB: Nathan Wilson ~ Daniel Talia ~ Marley Williams
C: Jaeger O’Meara ~ Dustin Martin ~ Jack Newnes
HF: Lewis Taylor ~ Tom Hawkins ~ Jake Melksham
FF: Brandon Matera ~ Peter Wright ~ Mark LeCras
R: Stefan Martin ~ Stephen Coniglio ~ Scott Selwood
Bench: Jackson Thurlow ~ Lachie Weller ~ Sam Gibson ~ Karl Amon

B: Andrew McGrath, James Frawley, Marcus Adams
HB: Michael Hibberd, Harry Taylor, Nick Vlastuin
C: Jack Sinclair, Patrick Dangerfield, Zak Jones
HF: Jack Billings, Mason Wood, Jack Ziebell
F: Kayne Turner, Josh Jenkins, Bailey Dale
R: Sam Jacobs, Luke Parker, Jordan Lewis
I/C: Ed Curnow, Daniel Howe, Luke Davies-Uniacke, Mitch Hannan

4 - Danoz v 5th hendo8888

B: Easton Wood - Tom Jonas - Nick Smith
HB: Connor Blakely - Jacob Weitering - Ben Stratton
C: Allen Christensen - Nat Fyfe - Aaron Young
HF: Kane Lambert - Jarryd Roughead - Robbie Gray
FF: Cyril Rioli - Kurt Tippett - Taylor Garner
R: Todd Goldstein - Scott Pendlebury - Tom Liberatore
I/C:Tom Langdon - Martin Gleeson - Ryan Clarke - Stewart Crameri

FB: Luke Brown (ADE), Jake Carlisle (STK), Brad Sheppard (WCE)
HB: Nic Newman (SYD), Robbie Tarrant (NMK), Jarrod Harbrow (GCS)
C: Bernie Vince (MEL), Lachie Neale (FRE), Dion Prestia (RIC)
HF: Will Hayward (SYD), Charlie Curnow (CAR), Luke Dunstan (STK)
FF: Callum Sinclair (SYD), Tom Lynch (GCS), Daniel Rioli (RIC)
R: Jarrod Witts (GCS), Jarryd Lyons (GCS), Matt Crouch (ADE)
I/C: Brendon Ah Chee (WCE), Trent Dumont (NMK), Matt Taberner (FRE), Will Brodie (GCS)

 

[hendo8888]

How are we voting this?

 

[Drugs Are Bad Mackay?]

I could put the 4 match ups as a poll option in this thread?

Pick your four winners

 

[Deaneus!]

not gonna reveal the bottom 4 in order.
so alphabetically, deaneus dogs105 Hank93 roo2macca
better luck in the proper season game.

Ridiculous

Y’all got swept up in flashy names

We’ll see

 

[Drugs Are Bad Mackay?]

My top eight:

1. Fire Breathing Rubber Duckies (Daniel1812)
2. The Three Eyed Ravens (Danger Zone)
3. The Disloyal Shits (Scorpus)
4. The Tune Squad (Mr MysteryGuest)
5. The London Sillinannies (Danger in Texas)
6. Rams FC (1990crow)
7. Guns N Rookies (hendo8888)
8. The New Farm Avengers (Kristof)
9. The Fog Of War (Danoz)

Only one I missed in the 8 was Danoz (had him 9th). Had the other 7 in there.

The one I had in was Danger Zone who I actually ranked second best. He was 9th overall so I got the box ninefecta

 

[FAITH]

Pre-Season 2018 Finals:

1 - Daniel1812 v 8th Scorpus

B: Dane Rampe - Jack Hombsch - Luke McDonald
HB: Kade Simpson - Lachie Henderson - Tom Cutler
C: Dom Sheed - Dylan Shiel - Jared Polec
HF: Mav Weller - Joe Daniher - Isaac Heeney
F: Luke Breust - Sam Reid - Jamie Cripps
1R: Jordan Roughead - Jack Viney - Taylor Adams
INT: Angus Brayshaw - Adam Kennedy - Koby Stevens - Alex Sexton

B Luke Hodge - Joel Hamling - Dylan Grimes
HB Shaun Burgoyne - Jackson Trengove - Jarrad McVeigh
C Matthew Suckling - Callan Ward (c) - Isaac Smith
HF Dayne Zorko - James Stewart - Richard Douglas
F Jake Stringer - Tom McDonald - Eddie Betts
R Zac Smith - Marcus Bontempelli - David Mundy
I Alex Neal-Bullen - Liam Duggan - Dale Morris - Tim O'Brien

Cant split the mids, Scorpus's fwrds may cause some trouble for Dan's Defence at times, but Dan's frwds should be too good for Scorpus's defence.
Dan's team by 18points.

2 - Kristof v 7th Mr MysteryGuest

FF: Jack Gunston - - Josh Kennedy - - Cam Raynor
HF: Darcy Parish - - Paddy McCartin - - Brett Deledio
C: Lachie Whitfield - - Dan Hannebury - - Shaun Grigg
HB: Zac Williams - - Ben Reid - - Pearce Hanley
FB: Heath Shaw -- Harris Andrews -- Luke Ryan
1st R: Max Gawn - - Trent Cotchin - - Dom Tyson
INT: David Armitage - - Michael Barlow -- Mason Cox - - Jayden Laverde

FB: J. MacMillan - M. Hartley - N. Haynes
HB: B. Maynard - K. Brand - J. Hunt
C: T. Scully - B. Crouch - S. Hill
HF: W. Milera - C. McCarthy - S. Edwards
FF: C. Ah Chee - T. Walker (C) - O. Fantasia
Foll: S. Naismith - A. Treloar - J. Steven (vc)
Int: L. Shiels - M. Kennedy - S. Lycett - T. Dickson

Bloody hell another tough one. I think the mids are top quality for both, maybe MMG edges out Kristof, As much as I like MMG's Fwrd line I think Kristof's defense can keep them quiet, and im confident Kristofs frwd line will trouble MMG's defence.
Im going Kristof by 26points.

3 - 1990crow v 6th Danger in Texas

FB: Grant Birchall ~ Steven May ~ Matt Scharenberg
HB: Nathan Wilson ~ Daniel Talia ~ Marley Williams
C: Jaeger O’Meara ~ Dustin Martin ~ Jack Newnes
HF: Lewis Taylor ~ Tom Hawkins ~ Jake Melksham
FF: Brandon Matera ~ Peter Wright ~ Mark LeCras
R: Stefan Martin ~ Stephen Coniglio ~ Scott Selwood
Bench: Jackson Thurlow ~ Lachie Weller ~ Sam Gibson ~ Karl Amon

B: Andrew McGrath, James Frawley, Marcus Adams
HB: Michael Hibberd, Harry Taylor, Nick Vlastuin
C: Jack Sinclair, Patrick Dangerfield, Zak Jones
HF: Jack Billings, Mason Wood, Jack Ziebell
F: Kayne Turner, Josh Jenkins, Bailey Dale
R: Sam Jacobs, Luke Parker, Jordan Lewis
I/C: Ed Curnow, Daniel Howe, Luke Davies-Uniacke, Mitch Hannan

DIT's mids will smash 1990crow's mids, but 1990crows's defence will blanket DIT's frwds, and I get the feeling 1990's frwds may struggle as well against DIT's defence.
DIT's to win by 8 points

4 - Danoz v 5th hendo8888

FB: Luke Brown (ADE), Jake Carlisle (STK), Brad Sheppard (WCE)
HB: Nic Newman (SYD), Robbie Tarrant (NMK), Jarrod Harbrow (GCS)
C: Bernie Vince (MEL), Lachie Neale (FRE), Dion Prestia (RIC)
HF: Will Hayward (SYD), Charlie Curnow (CAR), Luke Dunstan (STK)
FF: Callum Sinclair (SYD), Tom Lynch (GCS), Daniel Rioli (RIC)
R: Jarrod Witts (GCS), Jarryd Lyons (GCS), Matt Crouch (ADE)
I/C: Brendon Ah Chee (WCE), Trent Dumont (NMK), Matt Taberner (FRE), Will Brodie (GCS)

B: Easton Wood - Tom Jonas - Nick Smith
HB: Connor Blakely - Jacob Weitering - Ben Stratton
C: Allen Christensen - Nat Fyfe - Aaron Young
HF: Kane Lambert - Jarryd Roughead - Robbie Gray
FF: Cyril Rioli - Kurt Tippett - Taylor Garner
R: Todd Goldstein - Scott Pendlebury - Tom Liberatore
I/C:Tom Langdon - Martin Gleeson - Ryan Clarke - Stewart Crameri

Tough Midf battle, but I like Danoz's just a bit more. cant split Danoz's frwds v Hendo's def, but I think Danoz's defence will completely shut down Hendo's fwrds.
Im going Danoz in an by 23 points


*Everyone else's thoughts?

 

[1990crow]

I could put the 4 match ups as a poll option in this thread?

Pick your four winners

Needs a polling system to work properly. Open it up to all bigfooty to make it interesting

 

[FAITH]

How are we voting this?

I could put the 4 match ups as a poll option in this thread?

Pick your four winners

Needs a polling system to work properly. Open it up to all bigfooty to make it interesting

I don't think people care that much mate.
do as I did in post #2194

 

[Danger Zone]

Reckon Scorpus was hard done by, had him right at the pointy end for mine. Interestingly my bottom 2 was completely different from the bottom 4 in the overall rankings.

I think that the worst year I ever had was the year I won the popular vote though, so that’s something.

Thought this was the most competitive year I’ve played. Very few bad picks and lots of solid teams.

 

[Drugs Are Bad Mackay?]

Yeah agree on Scorpus. Really like his team

 

[FAITH]

On scorpus many had him top 4, many had him bottom 4.
I can see his strengths and weaknesses

 

[Maggsy]

FAITH Can you refresh my memory,. how should I be doing the rankings? Simply ranking all teams in order,. or giving scores 1-10 per positions etc then total scores blah blah,... just wanna make sure i'm consistant with everyone else.

Cheers

FAITH
to be fair, I'd been waiting on you giving me the heads up with the scoring format.. but gimme ten minutes,.. I'll do it now (based on what i've seen others do)

Cheers

 

[Mr MysteryGuest]

FAITH
to be fair, I'd been waiting on you giving me the heads up with the scoring format.. but gimme ten minutes,.. I'll do it now (based on what i've seen others do)

Cheers

just rank them from best to worst

 

[FAITH]

FAITH
to be fair, I'd been waiting on you giving me the heads up with the scoring format.. but gimme ten minutes,.. I'll do it now (based on what i've seen others do)

Cheers

wouldnt make much of a difference mate, the top 7 were entrenched.
possibly whoever finished 9th and me at 10th couldve slipped into scorpus's 8th place but no major changes