Wow something we agree on. Graham is a textbook example of a player who is overrated on account of him playing in a successful, flag winning side.Graham is still in and out of Richmond’s side
He’s better than poholke but he’s no star, just a good ordinary player
And def not someone to give a crap about missing out on
Mackay can be SANFL captain, can’t be? Or were Keath and Greenwood still technically Cat B rookies when they were co-captains?DM is still on the main list and not eligible for captain of the 2s.
I think Matty Wright is playing on or we would have heard that he's not.
Is he overrated?Wow something we agree on. Graham is a textbook example of a player who is overrated on account of him playing in a successful, flag winning side.
We have very different ideas about what "getting off to a flier" actually means.Is he overrated?
He completely turned the tide of a GF. Went to the player who, up until then, was the most influential player on the ground - instrumental in getting us away to a flier.
Graham not only cut Sloane out of the game but kicked 3 goals himself.
He may not have risen to those heights again ..yet. But he’s still young. Bit to play out yet.
Not overrated I wouldn’t have thought
Originally rules were had to be someone straight off list. Hence Callinan. After he retired we had no one eligible so gave it top up Carey. Following year Keath and Hugh. Then last year they loosened the rules to allow us to recruit a captain over 25. No rules on who. We got Wright and Port got Sutcliffe.Mackay can be SANFL captain, can’t be? Or were Keath and Greenwood still technically Cat B rookies when they were co-captains?
This may be the wrong thread, sorry if it is but I am responding to a comment above.
Why all the hate for David Mackay on this board? I don't understand it. He is a Crows player so should be supported by the "supporters" on this board.
He has played 206 AFL games and kicked 59 goals and been on an AFL list since 2008. I think the term used is that he is a spud, but spuds do not play over 200 AFL games.
To play even 1 AFL game you need to be a fairly decent footballer. I don't think there would be many posters on this board who have played even 1 AFL or SANFL game even.
Ease up on the lad.