Analysis AFC SANFL 2019 Thread

[Scorpus]

Metres gained per disposal is hardly relevant when you average 12 possessions.
Stupid stat. Anyone can get the ball 12 times and just boot it long every time and they’ll do well in that stat.

I also showed he had the third highest score involvements per disposal of any player, and is coming 2nd for meters gained per disposal.

He has the biggest impact from his disposals of any player in our side. I stand by that as the evidence shows.

 

[Brenton Davy]

Free kick count?

I know we've got a couple from HTB frees.

 

[MRB37]

Yeah theres no way gooch was ever worth a first round pick. Second round pick at best. Hamish got this one wrong.

Hamish wanted Tim English. Coaches wanted speed and pushed for Gooch.

 

[lunacy]

Anyway I don’t want to be like some other critics on this board. He is really the only young player (or early selection) I am critica of, because I felt it at the time and nothing has changed. His peers in that draft are killing him.
I like many wanted Jarrod Berry. But there are so many others who are miles ahead of him.
He is a crow now so I won’t compare him to players from other clubs. But looking at the other crow players in his draft year;
Davis pick 75 I rate higher than Gallucci, Murphy went undrafted that year.
Himmelberg pick 51 or thereabouts
Stengle rookie selection
Poholke pick 43. He hasn’t been great either but he still dominates sanfl level unlike the Gooch.

 

[MRB37]

Free kick count?

I know we've got a couple from HTB frees.

13-11 our way.

 

[ams4crows]

People are forgetting that we as a club have absoultely refused to develop the next generation. Im not suprised that our last 4 years of draft picks arent up to standard at AFL level.

The fact Douglas and Mackay are still getting regular games prove this.

 

[MRB37]

13-11 our way.

Numbers have been a lot more even since the differentials were released for us and Port a couple of months ago and both clubs went to the SANFL about it.

 

[the universal]

Hamish wanted Tim English. Coaches wanted speed and pushed for Gooch.

Fancy that, but we refuse to utilise it.

 

[Scorpus]

Fancy that, but we refuse to utilise it.

It's just like how we play David Mackay, but he never gets any B&F votes

 

[MRB37]

3rd quarter about to start.

 

[Tex200]

Anyway I don’t want to be like some other critics on this board. He is really the only young player (or early selection) I am critica of, because I felt it at the time and nothing has changed. His peers in that draft are killing him.
I like many wanted Jarrod Berry. But there are so many others who are miles ahead of him.
He is a crow now so I won’t compare him to players from other clubs. But looking at the other crow players in his draft year;
Davis pick 75 I rate higher than Gallucci, Murphy went undrafted that year.
Himmelberg pick 51 or thereabouts
Stengle rookie selection
Poholke pick 43. He hasn’t been great either but he still dominates sanfl level unlike the Gooch.

He’ll be a good player...just not with us.

Needs to get away from our system ASAP. Same as Lyons

 

[the universal]

It's just like how we play David Mackay, but he never gets any B&F votes

Coaches who play Mackay think he's 'fast' because he 'breaks the lines' by running for 10 metres and bombing it to a pack on the wing 3 times a game.

 

[MRB37]

Strachan marks inside 50 and gets the first goal for the quarter

 

[maxlilly]

Hamish wanted Tim English. Coaches wanted speed and pushed for Gooch.

It's funny how the coaches wanted speed and then they continually pick our slowest side possible

 

[MRB37]

Another turnover on a kick in leads to a Westies goal. 4 of their 5 goals now due to direct turnovers in our D50.

 

[MRB37]

JJ with a direct tap down to Poholke who kicks a nice banana to goal.

 

[ABAB]

People are forgetting that we as a club have absoultely refused to develop the next generation. Im not suprised that our last 4 years of draft picks arent up to standard at AFL level.

The fact Douglas and Mackay are still getting regular games prove this.

O'Brien and Doedee both developed very well in the SANFL......you are going too early on Gallucci (played very well with limited possession this year, surprised he got dropped TBH), Forgarty/McPherson, Jones/McHenry/Scholl/Hamil/Butts and what about Doedee/Milera (they were both in the 2015 draft 4 years ago).

 

[MRB37]

Hutchinson with the break through

 

[MRB37]

End of 3rd

61 to 38 our way.

 

[Scorpus]

End of 3rd

61 to 38 our way.

It's amazing what can be done when our best midfielders are in the side

 

[Bender20]

Strahan was good in the air that quarter, he's made some real progress since the start of the season.

 

[MRB37]

Strahan was good in the air that quarter, he's made some real progress since the start of the season.

Took some nice grabs in defence when we needed one.

 

[Thegibbsgamble]

Strahan was good in the air that quarter, he's made some real progress since the start of the season.

any chance posting every center bounce whose in thier?

 

[MRB37]

Stengle gets clipped high in the marking contest but misses a simple set shot.

 

[Bender20]

any chance posting every center bounce whose in thier?

I'm watching my canberra raiders going down to the roosters and watching sanfl on phone so posting is difficult.