Norm Smith Medallist
- Jul 20, 2010
- AFL Club
Not at all. Tiges too clean and played the conditions far better, which included the aforementioned kicking off the ground to a teammates advantage.You guys are sooo unlucky
Thats correct, and we're in furious agreement.It's called "wet-weather football"
Keep the ball moving forward by any means and play in front, it ain't rocket science
Boyd did, but that's easily the best game of his 6 game career, and it was solid rather than starring. He keeps putting 'em together yeah you'd have to think about it, but even considering last night nah other blokes come straight in for him, its only one game. May change in time.Boyd played a very good game last night and young also did pretty well
Im thinking there is no way eith would have done much better than Young & Boyd
Marchbank & McGovern are ghosts
they have both been at Carlton for 3+ years and hardly played for 1 reason or another , Not thinking this will be changing too much going foward
March - Unfortunate
McGov - Has stolen a AFL Career
I would genuinely like to see a best 22 list from Carlton supporters taking into consideration the injury history of playersBoyd did, but that's easily the best game of his 6 game career, and it was solid rather than starring. He keeps putting 'em together yeah you'd have to think about it, but even considering last night nah other blokes come straight in for him, its only one game. May change in time.
Agree re: Marchbank, can't really count him I think. Seems destined to be one of those guys who's body just never gives them a proper run at it, poor bloke. Gov while also being injury-prone has still managed far more footy - like I said, small sample size but assuming he plays even close to what he did during the first 3 games this year as 3rd/intercept defender he most definitely comes back in. Probably not for Young, more like Plowman.
Yeah just depends where you draw the line really, like I said I think Marchbank falls into that category. McGovern not quite yet for mine but you're right, its getting pretty close. If he happens to cop another 8-10 week injury again after he returns this time, yep probably reasonable to discount him in terms of best 22.I would genuinely like to see a best 22 list from Carlton supporters taking into consideration the injury history of players
MMcGov as an example 33 games in 4 seasons and will be 28 end of this year , The likely chance he plays 00 games for carlton is very low
so in my eyes i wouldnt really be calling him best 22 and the same would now apply to Kane Lambert at Richmond.
I am also yet to see Williams play a $900k game for Carlton , He just looks like an average player and easily replaced in the line up without losing much
Cerra & Wietering are both big losses , Pitto is a loss due to position but hardly a world beater Ruckman and if he was available who misses out
cant have 4 bigs playing fwd plus Pitto in the ruck
Me showing immaturity when you're claiming something so unlikely ?Fingers were moving before ball even touched.
As soon as you use a word like salty you're just showing your immaturity mate. Jog on.