Autopsy AFL 2024 Preliminary Final - Cats v Lions Sat Sept 21st 5:15pm EST (MCG)

[PhatBoy]

I find that a bit hard to believe

I’m disappointed, any team’s fans are when they lose, but I’m not going to tear my hair out over it. We were never expected to get this far, we gave it a great crack, and were beaten by a better side, and dozens of neutrals seem to be celebrating like their own teams have just won a flag

 

[PhatBoy]

Joey D also from memory hasn’t put together a particularly good body of work against us as a forward in the past so I don’t think moving him out of there was necessarily the worst thing that could happen from a Lions perspective, he did a good job going with Stanley. It was gutsy as all hell from Oscar - I nearly spat my beer out when he came back on after seeing how distressed he was when he left the field, it was one of the braver things I’ve seen in recent years, but definitely the right call to get him out of there when they did and as a few people have pointed out, it’s enhanced Joe’s standing as a guy who is putting his best foot forward in finals matches regardless of what role he plays

 

[CatToTheFuture]

I dont. Thats how much of a dickhead i am. 60 bucks for a cheap laugh that only i found funny

Sometimes you have to spend the money on the things that bring you joy

 

[geelong_crazy26]

Scott must think that if he pre-empts ensuring the excuses are made known with the statement 'don't take these as excuses, BUT....' that people won't catch on that they are excuses.

Has got form the big sook.

A journalist asked the question and he answered. Not sure what you want him to do different.

 

[beema limapep]

A journalist asked the question and he answered. Not sure what you want him to do different.

Journo:- "Are there any excuses for losing
tonight? Covid?"

Scott in an alternate universe:- "Look, all credit to Brisbane as they were the better side. Both sides had injuries and I'm not going to be drawn into peripheral what ifs as Geelong has more integrity than that. We said prior to the game our Covid affected staff would be covered and Brisbane deserved the win.

 

[geelong_crazy26]

Journo:- "Are there any excuses for losing
tonight? Covid?"

Scott in an alternate universe:- "Look, all credit to Brisbane as they were the better side. Both sides had injuries and I'm not going to be drawn into peripheral what ifs as Geelong has more integrity than that. We said prior to the game our Covid affected staff would be covered and Brisbane deserved the win.

the journalist asked him about the health reports during the week coming out that we were dealing with a few players with gastro. He confirmed it was true and they trained away from the main group.

This doesn’t take a high IQ to grasp

 

[beema limapep]

the journalist asked him about the health reports during the week coming out that we were dealing with a few players with gastro. He confirmed it was true and they trained away from the main group.

This doesn’t take a high IQ to grasp

Of course but the narrative changed after the loss.

 

[RCAB]

If that were true, why would it ‘hurt’ anybody?

It’s football, not a child being diagnosed with a terminal disease

Weird comparison

 

[RCAB]

I'd back in Dempsey being more versatile and having a longer career as he can play multiple positions in any ever increasing positionless game.

You do that

He's a running machine, covers more ground than pretty much any player in the comp.

Lol

Guys like that will always have a place in the League and long careers.

Not necessarily

 

[Romeoh1]

Journo:- "Are there any excuses for losing
tonight? Covid?"

Scott in an alternate universe:- "Look, all credit to Brisbane as they were the better side. Both sides had injuries and I'm not going to be drawn into peripheral what ifs as Geelong has more integrity than that. We said prior to the game our Covid affected staff would be covered and Brisbane deserved the win.

Yawn.

 

[Shai]

Just watched the replay, what an epic game!

The 'worst midfield' in the league weren't too shabby

As the last final, the younger brigade impressed with their growth.

Defence - Cats - Humphries, Mullins
Lions - Payne, Starcevich, Wilmot

Mid - Cats - Bruhn, Holmes
Lions - Ashcroft, Fletcher, Rayner

Fwd - Cats - Dempsey, Henry, Neale
Lions - Lohmann, Morris

 

[Johnny Bananas]

Geelong have the home ground advantage and the crowd.

While brisbane just played there grand final against the giants, and have to travel a second time.

Cats by 40.

Geez the Bris nuffies are coming out thick and fast.

Really looking forward to flogging the Lions in yet another prelim.

The Lions haven't beaten Geelong in Victoria since the Preliminary Final in 2004, not that it makes much difference this week, but it's an interesting stat. I don't think the drought will be broken. Cats by 50 points.

 

[Happy_Neale]

Hopefully you’ll eventually learn how to win a GF.

We did.

 

[theprospector]

The better side won.

We has a crack but had one of those games where our weaknesses were exposed and our strengths blunted just enough for Brisbane to land the killer blows.

Congrats to the Lions. Go well in the grand final - continuing to knock on the door while improving deserves serious credit.

For the Cats - thereabouts but never felt like a premiership team. Similar to a number of years under Scott. Our bottom 5 were comfortably worse than Brisbane's and their clutch players almost all delivered.

Backhanded compliment here. "Never felt like a premiership team.' You were four goals up and blew it. Face the facts.

 

[Lunchtime]

Backhanded compliment here. "Never felt like a premiership team.' You were four goals up and blew it. Face the facts.

Yep exactly.

 

[Mr Meow]

Backhanded compliment here. "Never felt like a premiership team.' You were four goals up and blew it. Face the facts.

Was I? Because I thought I was a guy watching a bunch of blokes kicking a ball around.

As my original post said, the better side won. Geelong had quarters or halves where they were obliterated throughout the season. That wasnt just going to magically disappear in finals.

The death knell rang when a weak midfield lost its stand out player (Holmes). Brisbane's small forwards also stood up more than Geelong's as the game progressed. The end.

 

[Simbatheking21]

I’d rather have no hope than have false hope that you’re a chance. Enjoy another loss under grandpa Fagan ahhaahh champ

 

[Blue_1nvasion]

I’d rather have no hope than have false hope that you’re a chance. Enjoy another loss under grandpa Fagan ahhaahh champ

he champ’d ya, went early and looks like a fool now! Just like trading a top 10 pick for a Kako bid that they didn’t even need to do he’s a small forward Rez no one was bidding on him that high!!! Bombers on prime time next year will be better then p*rn

 

[Lunchtime]

I’d rather have no hope than have false hope that you’re a chance. Enjoy another loss under grandpa Fagan ahhaahh champ

I give you the 2024 AFL Premiers....the Brisbane Lions Football Club.

What an absolutely horrendous assessment by you. Horrific.

 

[FootyLad0]

I give you the 2024 AFL Premiers....the Brisbane Lions Football Club.

What an absolutely horrendous assessment by you. Horrific.

Stacked list finally stopped choking in Finals to win it all.

Congrats

 

[theprospector]

Stacked list finally stopped choking in Finals to win it all.

Congrats

How about just saying congratulations and that you lost at home after being four goals up?

 

[Lunchtime]

How about just saying congratulations and that you lost at home after being four goals up?

Exactly right. You've absolutely nailed it.

 

[GOTHELIONS16]

Stacked list finally stopped choking in Finals to win it all.

Congrats

I’m pretty sure Geelong have been choking in finals a lot more in the last 12 years

 

[theprospector]

Streets won’t forget Dangerfield nominating for a ruck contest without telling anyone two min to go.

 

[FootyLad0]

I’m pretty sure Geelong have been choking in finals a lot more in the last 12 years

Cats didn’t have the best side in a lot of those years. Overachieved with many squads full of late round picks and rookie drafted players.

Lions full to the brim of top picks and superstars. Should be a dynasty already.

Two entirely different situations.

 

[GOTHELIONS16]

Cats didn’t have the best side in a lot of those years. Overachieved with many squads full of late round picks and rookie drafted players.

Lions full to the brim of top picks and superstars. Should be a dynasty already.

Two entirely different situations.

They had a a very talented side in half of those 12 years though. Lost multiple home qualifying/semi/prelim finals. In 2019 Cats won minor premiership, and didn’t make the grand final. In 2021 rnd 23 they were 5 goals up against dees in minor premiership battle, for dees to comeback and win. Dees then smash them in the prelim and go on to win the whole thing. Cats have ‘choked’ more than us in the last 10 years. And being 4 goals up in a prelim is just the cherry on top. I know their side wasn’t always as talented blah, blah, blah, but it really is another good old example of a Cats choke. If you cats fans are going to give it, you gotta take it as well.