MVP AFL Coaches Association votes 2018

[Miguel Sanchez]

West Coast v Sydney

10 Franklin (Syd)
7 Parker (Syd)
5 Heeney (Syd)
4 LeCras (WCE)
2 Darling (WCE)
2 Hurn (WCE)

Means the individual votes were
5 Franklin
4 Parker
3 LeCras
2 Darling/Hurn
1 Heeney

and

5 Franklin
4 Heeney
3 Parker
2 Darling/Hurn
1 LeCras

 

[Miguel Sanchez]

WESTERN BULLDOGS v WEST COAST

10 Hurn (WCE)
8 Darling (WCE)
4 Macrae (WB)
3 Ryan (WC)
2 Lycett (WC)
2 Naitanui (WC)
1 Hunter (WB)

Eagles leaderboard
12 Hurn
10 Darling
4 LeCras
3 Ryan
2 Lycett
2 Naitanui

 

[Chris_6678]

http://www.aflca.com.au/fileadmin/u..._AFLCA_Champion_Player_Votes_-_Rd_3__2018.pdf

Eagles leaderboard
12 Hurn
10 Darling
9 Sheed
5 Shep
4 Shuey
4 LeCras
3 Ryan
2 Lycett
2 Naitanui
1 Gaff

 

[RookiePick]

Shredder with a 5 and 4

 

[Biggie]

Shredder with a 5 and 4

My man!

 

[Miguel Sanchez]

9: Sheed
5: Sheppard
5: Dangerfield
4: Shuey
3: Menegola
2: Ablett
1: Gaff
1: Stewart

Breakdown
5: Sheed
4: Shuey
3: Danger/Shep
2: Shep/Danger
1: Gaff/Stewart

5: Shep/Danger
4: Sheed
3: Danger/Shep
2: Ablett
1: Stewart/Gaff

 

[eaglespremiers]

9: Sheed
5: Sheppard
5: Dangerfield
4: Shuey
3: Menegola
2: Ablett
1: Gaff
1: Stewart

Breakdown
5: Sheed
4: Shuey
3: Danger/Shep
2: Shep/Danger
1: Gaff/Stewart

5: Shep/Danger
4: Sheed
3: Danger/Shep
2: Ablett
1: Stewart/Gaff

Staggering that Naitanui didn't get a single vote.
Both coaches have absolutely no clue.

 

[Miguel Sanchez]

He's only gotten votes against the Dogs which I thought was his quietest game.

 

[nameless]

By his standards Dangerfield was very average.

Would have thought Naitanui deserves a vote, but think the others are very deserving.

 

[Chris_6678]

For overall influence surely Nic Nat was better than Abblet.

 

[RookiePick]

For overall influence surely Nic Nat was better than Abblet.

Ablett carved us up in the third term. A massive part of their run.

 

[Inside Bull]

Am I alone in being suspicious of Scott? It is entirely possible that he could have given the 5,3,2 and 1 votes to Cats. Probably (and hopefully) unlikely however

I really do hope it was Shep, not Danger, that got the other 5 vote nomination though

 

[BartBart]

I reckon it was:

5: Sheed
4: Shuey
3: Dangerfield
2: Ablett
1: Gaff

5: Sheppard
4: Sheed
3: Menegola
2: Dangerfield
1: Stewart

 

[Bender_]

Am I alone in being suspicious of Scott? It is entirely possible that he could have given the 5,3,2 and 1 votes to Cats. Probably (and hopefully) unlikely however

I really do hope it was Shep, not Danger, that got the other 5 vote nomination though

LoL I don't want to cast "dispersions" but I wouldn't put that past one of the Snott twins.

 

[kranky al]

LoL I don't want to cast "dispersions" but I wouldn't put that past one of the Snott twins.

For all intensive purposes i think you are right.

 

[dodgie]

Am I alone in being suspicious of Scott? It is entirely possible that he could have given the 5,3,2 and 1 votes to Cats. Probably (and hopefully) unlikely however

I really do hope it was Shep, not Danger, that got the other 5 vote nomination though

Nah * both the Scotts.

Would be a pretty good idea at the end of the year to analyse these coaches votes. e.g. what proportion of votes went towards Geelong players in games that they lost or it was close in and compare it to the competition average. If there's a significant difference there's probably some funny buggers going on. Although at the end of the day, is the award really all that prestigious and does it really matter?

 

[RookiePick]

For all intensive purposes i think you are right.

I was about to rage but well played ser!

 

[BartBart]

For all intensive porpoises i think you are right.

Corrected

 

[Chris_6678]

http://www.aflplayers.com.au/article/coaches-votes-pies-duo-dominate/

Eagles leaderboard
12 Hurn
11 Darling
9 Sheed
9 Yeo
9 Mcgoven
5 Shep
4 Shuey
4 LeCras
3 Ryan
3 Naitanui
3 Cripps
3 JK
3 Gaff
2 Lycett
2 Masten

Loving the more even spread of votes early on.

 

[BartBart]

http://www.aflplayers.com.au/article/coaches-votes-pies-duo-dominate/

Eagles leaderboard
12 Hurn
11 Darling
9 Sheed
9 Yeo
9 Mcgoven
5 Shep
4 Shuey
4 LeCras
3 Ryan
3 Naitanui
3 Cripps
3 JK
3 Gaff
2 Lycett
2 Masten

Loving the more even spread of votes early on.

Wow - 15 different players

 

[dodgie]

Eagles leaderboard
12 Hurn
11 Darling
9 Sheed
9 Yeo
9 Mcgoven
5 Shep
4 Shuey
4 LeCras
3 Ryan
3 Naitanui
3 Cripps
3 JK
3 Gaff
2 Lycett
2 Masten

Loving the more even spread of votes early on.

Let's not get too carried away, still only a small sample size.

 

[Eaglespur]

Darlingggg

 

[Bender_]

Can some smart guy that wants to prove how clever he is (I'm looking at you Miguel Sanchez) break down this week's votes for me?

 

[BartBart]

Assuming the question wasn't sarcastic...

This week's votes is pretty easy. Just hard to know which coach voted what on each line.

Interesting they were similar on 5/4 votes but totally different on the rest.

5: Yeo / McGovern
4: McGovern / Yeo
3: Cripps / Kennedy
2: Masten / Gaff
1: Darling / Naitanui

 

[The Falcon Strike]

Not sure how JK got 3 votes

Despite kicking 5 - Wouldn’t have had him in our top dozen players - certainly didn’t think he was as good as jack

Nice issue to have though