MVP AFL Coaches Association votes 2018

[Miguel Sanchez]

Coach A (reckon it was Simpson, he singled out Hurn's game in his presser
5: Hurn
4: Gaff
3: Redden
2: Tomlinson
1: Shuey/NicNat

Coach B
5: Gaff
4: Tomlinson
3: Hurn
2: Coniglio
1: NicNat/Shuey

 

[DickDunn]

This is pretty remarkable. Surely becoming a pretty decent chance to win the Brownlow:

 

[fidstar]

This is pretty remarkable. Surely becoming a pretty decent chance to win the Brownlow:

He's been super consistent.

But it also means his average votes is less than 5 votes per game, which means he will probably get a lot of 1s or just miss a vote. Brownlow medalists are the guys that get 10 votes i.e. 3 Brownlow votes.

Has a decent polling history though, so that will help.

 

[bombard]

Also something to be said for recency bias. All the FA talk means he will be a lot more prominent / front of mind for the umpires than previous years.

 

[eaglespremiers]

He's been super consistent.

But it also means his average votes is less than 5 votes per game, which means he will probably get a lot of 1s or just miss a vote. Brownlow medalists are the guys that get 10 votes i.e. 3 Brownlow votes.

Has a decent polling history though, so that will help.

Umps have liked him in the past more than he's probably deserved, so that may be a factor.

 

[Miguel Sanchez]

10: McGovern
7: Hurn
6: Redden
5: De Goey
1: Gaff
1: Hutchings

Coach A
5 Gov
4 Hurn
3 De Goey
2 Redden
1 Gaff/Hutchings

Coach B
5 Gov
4 Redden
3 Hurn
2 De Goey
1 Hutchings/Gaff

 

[ioppolo]

Simpson would've given Hutchings his vote

 

[Biggie]

WEST COAST V WESTERN BULLDOGS
10 Yeo (WCE)
8 Gaff (WCE)
3 Crozier (WB)
3 Jetta (WCE)
2 Cripps (WCE)
2 Darling (WCE)
2 McGovern (WCE)

 

[Quinz]

Gaff now has coaches votes in 13 games out of 17

 

[Shmiddy15]

JD would have a pretty good ratio of coaches votes v games played too I'd imagine.

 

[Suma Magic]

Was Crozier that good?

Do they publish a running total of West Coast votes anywhere?

 

[PintSzedSlasher]

Was Crozier that good?

Do they publish a running total of West Coast votes anywhere?

He was easily the dogs best but prob didn't deserve 3 coaches votes. I thought Masten could've easily have pinched one!

 

[avishka5]

Was Crozier that good?

Do they publish a running total of West Coast votes anywhere?

He was pretty good but its not hard for a half back flanker to get a ton of the ball in a floggings. His heat maps shows that his hot spots is well inside their defensive 50.

 

[ziad]

Was Crozier that good?

Do they publish a running total of West Coast votes anywhere?

what do you expect - coaches are not impartial

 

[Miguel Sanchez]

Eagles leaderboard
61 Gaff (5th overall)
47 Yeo (equal 15th overall)
44 Darling
40 Hurn
26 Redden
25 McGovern
16 Sheppard
13 Kennedy
10 Naitanui
9 Sheed
7 Lycett
6 Cripps
5 Shuey
4 LeCras
4 Masten
3 Ryan
3 Barrass
3 Rioli
3 Jetta
2 Hutchings
1 Cole

Jetta's votes this week make him the 21st WCE player to receive votes this season.

 

[Miguel Sanchez]

Votes from the North game

10 Cunnington
8 Ahern
5 Daw
3 Clarke
2 Goldstein
2 McGovern

Slightly surprising, I didn't even have Gov in our top five.

 

[Miguel Sanchez]

Votes from the Derby

10: Yeo
7: Redden
4: Gaff
3: Sheppard
3: Cripps
2: Darling
1: Lycett

One coach had Gaff second BOG behind Yeo, the other gave him no votes. Anyone want to hazard a guess as to which coach was which?

 

[Miguel Sanchez]

Eagles leaderboard
65 Gaff (5th overall, probably can't catch the leaders though)
57 Yeo (11th overall)
46 Darling
40 Hurn
33 Redden
27 McGovern
19 Sheppard
13 Kennedy
10 Naitanui
9 Sheed
9 Cripps
8 Lycett
5 Shuey
4 LeCras
4 Masten
3 Ryan
3 Barrass
3 Rioli
3 Jetta
2 Hutchings
1 Cole

 

[dodgie]

One coach had Gaff second BOG behind Yeo, the other gave him no votes. Anyone want to hazard a guess as to which coach was which

Bloody hell Ross, the guy just knocked out one of your players and you go and give the man votes?

 

[Suma Magic]

Eagles leaderboard
65 Gaff (5th overall, probably can't catch the leaders though)
57 Yeo (11th overall)
46 Darling
40 Hurn
33 Redden
27 McGovern
19 Sheppard
13 Kennedy
10 Naitanui
9 Sheed
9 Cripps
8 Lycett
5 Shuey
4 LeCras
4 Masten
3 Ryan
3 Barrass
3 Rioli
3 Jetta
2 Hutchings
1 Cole

The Brownlow predictor is interesting, Yeo right up there.

 

[mad_eagle]

Votes from the Derby

10: Yeo
7: Redden
4: Gaff
3: Sheppard
3: Cripps
2: Darling
1: Lycett

One coach had Gaff second BOG behind Yeo, the other gave him no votes. Anyone want to hazard a guess as to which coach was which?

I actually thought Ross might give Ballantyne or Johnson a vote tbh...

 

[twce13]

I don't think Yeo is gonna contend this year, but I'm gonna put a cheeky 50 on him next year's. The guys a jet.

 

[mad_eagle]

I don't think Yeo is gonna contend this year, but I'm gonna put a cheeky 50 on him next year's. The guys a jet.

Yeh, Titch has it in the bag...surprised none of the agencies have paid out on it yet

 

[Suma Magic]

I don't think Yeo is gonna contend this year, but I'm gonna put a cheeky 50 on him next year's. The guys a jet.

My syndicate just put $10 on Yeo at 81/1.

Unlikely to win but seems decent value. Especially if he can get a few votes in the last three.

Agree that Mitchell should romp it in.

 

[PintSzedSlasher]

My syndicate just put $10 on Yeo at 81/1.

Unlikely to win but seems decent value. Especially if he can get a few votes in the last three.

Agree that Mitchell should romp it in.

Yeah I just chucked 10 on as well (at 101), just in case Yeo smashes these last 3 games!