WATCH IT LIVE NOW: NAB AFL Mid-Season Rookie Draft
The only place to watch the mid-season rookie draft is right here
Last edited by a moderator:
POR
83 v GCS
70 3QT
COL
88 v GWS
77 FT
CAR
81 v FRE
50 FT
NM
58 v ADE
115 FT
GEE
89 v RIC
86 FT
SYD
83 v STK
32 FT
PER
51 v WP
112 FT
PA
37 v GLE
76 FT
EP
72 v CLA
46 FT
FFC
94 v BH
46 FT
WCE
90 v SFR
49 FT
GEE
89 v RIC
103 FT
STH
48 v ADE
107 FT
CEN
79 v NA
117 FT
EFR
88 v PT
77 FT
SWA
104 v SUB
53 FT
NWD
76 v STU
50 FT
WIL
72 v ESS
110 FT
WES
76 v WWT
96 FT
List Mgmt. AFL Draft Watch 2022
- Thread starter Old Campaigner
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Given the dees missed Andrew already not sure they'd be inclined. We could ask given the long standing tiwi connection. But don't like the chances
Langford compensation pick.... would you do it?
Ideally we upgrade our 2nd to get ahead of a davey bid, then have collateral to trade in and draft munkara.
Add wardlaw, szybkowski, davey and munkara before the 1st rd finishes - tidy result
We'd need the pick to ideally be traded on the night post-davey bid.
Could trade it out and back in again... I was more interested in the hypothetical Langford for Munkara?
Nope. Look how often we break down both offensively and defensively between the arcs. Plus my entire off-season plan is centred around free agency and trading in cheap fringe players, so that would compromise any Langford compensation
Only way we get 3 first rounders before a Davey bid is by trading Parish or Merrett.
And you misspelled Tsatas, how many 180 cm inside midfielders do we need to realise that it's stupid?
Hence szybkowski
Tsatas perfectly fine too. Just get competitive mids in.
I reckon we could get ahead of a davey bid with shiel + 2nd. It would be mid teens so davey needs to slow down now.
Yeah, we could possibly get one. Not two.Hence szybkowski
Tsatas perfectly fine too. Just get competitive mids in.
I reckon we could get ahead of a davey bid with shiel + 2nd. It would be mid teens so davey needs to slow down now.
Tippa just retired.
If langford left i'd need time to cope.
Bad enough francis may get delisted too.
- May 6, 2007
- 33,631
- 18,074
- AFL Club
- Essendon
- Other Teams
- Tottenham Hotspurs, Melbourne Vixen
We've asked this for 10 years of ourselves.. Stupid doesn't even comprehend what we do
Oh, i meant one
Our pick - tsatas
Shiel pick - szybkowski
Match davey bid
Trade in and draft munkara. (This i dont know how we do).
- May 6, 2007
- 33,631
- 18,074
- AFL Club
- Essendon
- Other Teams
- Tottenham Hotspurs, Melbourne Vixen
We need everything
Scully ticks boxes
So does sheezel
As do the host of mids
Oh to be an expansion club
I'm happy to hold off on KPP's. Jones is a gun if we get his body right, Wright is playing really well and has a long time left, Baldwin is showing plenty in the VFL and we have a ruck combo still developing.
You get Szybkowski or Munkara. Not both, unless we trade Merrett or Parish. Which I'm not averse to doing.
Easy pick - find the mid (or two) we need via MSD or via a trade, then munkara. Fwd line is really suffering with a lack of goal threats.
So much so I'd almost go sheezel at our first
- Sep 29, 2016
- 7,197
- 10,850
- AFL Club
- Essendon
- Other Teams
- Bayern Munich
- Moderator
- #292
There is no way that any pick we get for Shiel is going to be high enough to get Szybkowski
Shiel + 2nd, but I'm getting that feel too with the draft boards.
Either way I still try trade up ahead of a davey bid for whoever is on the board. Pick will get impacted and I think this is the last chance we get to recoup any meaningful value from shiel
- May 6, 2007
- 33,631
- 18,074
- AFL Club
- Essendon
- Other Teams
- Tottenham Hotspurs, Melbourne Vixen
your opinion is your prerogative, I disagree and I am fine with that. I still feel like a genuine KPF (198+) is what we need to look at developing for the future.
Agree but i think we need someone more mature than an 18yo. Have jones, baldwin, eyre, mcbride all developing.
Extremely limited at all other things but is a pure out and out key forward - fogarty?
Let wright roam. Keep him deep. No midfield experiments. Just key forward
- Sep 29, 2016
- 7,197
- 10,850
- AFL Club
- Essendon
- Other Teams
- Bayern Munich
- Moderator
- #296
I dont know how much clearer in can repeat this.
Teams are not handing over a first round pick in any - and I mean ANY trade - for Shiel, period.
The deal we get for him will be, at best, a Dan Hannebery deal which was St Kilda’s 2019 second-round pick and pick 39 in 2018 in exchange for Sydney’s pick 28 in 2018 and Hannebery. And Hannebery was a three time AA mid.
To think a team is going to give over a first round pick is not realistic, regardless of how many picks you want to bundle up with him.
- May 6, 2007
- 33,631
- 18,074
- AFL Club
- Essendon
- Other Teams
- Tottenham Hotspurs, Melbourne Vixen
I have been very vocal about a key forward, it doesn't necessarily need to be a 2022 draft fix but I wouldn't mind us looking at one in '22 or '23.
- May 6, 2007
- 33,631
- 18,074
- AFL Club
- Essendon
- Other Teams
- Tottenham Hotspurs, Melbourne Vixen
Shiel is 29, his flaws have been put on full show the last month and should his form get better, we likely hold anyway.
Same page
Banged on about lynch when he left GCS.
We've lacked a strong 1-2 punch outside hooker-daniher in 2017. Never really got to see that again
We were never getting Lynch. Never. Why would he go to Essendon when Richmond were able to offer more money and were the best team in the country?
Similar threads
