AFL Dream Team 2006

[drew_j]

Hello all,

Long time reader, first time poster. This is my team, any thoughts? I have issues with the bench for the ruck, Drum's posibility of playing this year and John's breaking down or playing like crap. Comments appreciated.

Backs:
Sinclair, J
Brown N,D
Burgoyne, S
McLeod, A
Goddard, B
Boyle, T
Rooke, J
Brennan, J
Drum, M

Centres:
Dal Santo, N
Hasleby,P
Monfries, A
Rodan, D
Allan, M
Murphy, M

Rucks:
Cox, D
Sandilands, A
Fraser, J
Skipper, W
Deluca, F
Brooks, B

Forwards:
Riewoldt, N
Grant, S
Williams, M
McGregor, K
Franklin, L
Watson, J
Lonergan, T
Johns, C
Dale Thomas

Anyone out there???

 

[chooka_delic]

There's a lot of ifs buts and maybes aren't there!

I jumped online to tweak my team - it's two hours later and I've made one change!

Couple of things I'm a bit worried about:

Prestigiacomo in my 22!
Franklin and Merret in my 22!
Steven King or Mooney? For some reason my rucks are frustrating me!!
Melb's Nathan Brown - Something tells me shouldn't be in my 22...

Gooness, just reading this list, I think I'm in more trouble than I thought!!

Having Presti in your 22 is a huge mistake. Definitely NOT a dream team player. Averages in the 20s and wont improve on that. Mooney is better than King in dream team and Nathan D Brown isnt as good as he used to be

 

[Cats_Fan]

Matthew Lappin or Chance Bateman or Neither?

 

[Waite_30]

Anyone out there???

Very differnt team compared to other teams posted. You have wasted too much on your backs and rucks. Downgrade from both positions and upgrade your forwards.

 

[Waite_30]

Matthew Lappin or Chance Bateman or Neither?

Bateman, but i have both in my team.

 

[theone5]

Matthew Lappin or Chance Bateman or Neither?

Bateman.

Hodge and Cornes are overpriced. Agree?

 

[macca69]

hmm I am rather frustrated ATM, got a fair bit of money left and not sure who to upgrade. I like all my cheaper players, but I can upgrade one of them to a gun.

 

[lord]

Bateman.

Hodge and Cornes are overpriced. Agree?

agree. the best defender from 270,000 to 300,000 is who do you think? already have newman and mooney.

 

[rota69]

Deledio and tenace
or
black and richetelli

please tell me asap

 

[Waite_30]

agree. the best defender from 270,000 to 300,000 is who do you think? already have newman and mooney.

Burgoyne or Johncock.

BTW, on the AFL website it says that Jesse Smith will only be out for 3 weeks. Can a kangas fan back this up???

 

[Cassius_Clay]

Do you have Simmonds?
And you didn't answer my question. The only ruck i am considering getting rid of is Mooney. What do you think?

And CC, let me have a punt at your Port players:
C.Cornes
S.Burgoyne
S.Salopek
D.Cassisi
D.Motlop

???

Pretty confident i am right.

Leave Mooney.

3/5 of those Port players are right however when I had 7 in all of them were in

 

[Cassius_Clay]

peoples thoughts on Brent Reilly?

and Symes?

If Neil Craig guaranteed that he would get 60% game time I would get him without a doubt.

 

[rota69]

Deledio and tenace
or
black and richetelli

please tell me asap

Someone answer!

 

[lord]

Burgoyne or Johncock.

BTW, on the AFL website it says that Jesse Smith will only be out for 3 weeks. Can a kangas fan back this up???

Johncocks stats for his last match werent crash hot. not sure on burgoyne. what baout mcmahon.. i thought he wasnt that good (esp as a DT player)

With regards to smith im guessing ur referring to this:
""Jesse will begin a rehab program in two-to-three weeks after his recuperation from surgery and we look forward to getting him back out playing as soon as possible," Harrington said.

"We really won't know until after the first four weeks. He's going to be in a camwalker for probably two or three and after that when he comes out of that and begins walking and begins some light training, we'll know very quickly whether he's a couple of weeks away or whether he's still got an extended period"

Its still a risk. i had him initially and it was very annoying to see him go down. get waters and fixter in the mean time and pick him up after hes third game. thats my plan anyway.

 

[theone5]

agree. the best defender from 270,000 to 300,000 is who do you think? already have newman and mooney.

S.Burgoyne would go close IMO.

 

[Waite_30]

Someone answer!

2nd option

 

[lord]

Deledio and tenace
or
black and richetelli

please tell me asap

the latter. not sure about black though.

 

[macca69]

anyone think Knights is worhty of a spot in the 22?

 

[lord]

D Harris and R Biglands
or
D Hale and B Schammer

 

[sante]

D Harris and R Biglands
or
D Hale and B Schammer

Option 1 IMO

 

[U2 Tigers]

Braun or J. Sinclair

In

1. dream team

2. Champion data or supercoach type scoring.

 

[Don Cottagers]

Braun or J. Sinclair

In

1. dream team

2. Champion data or supercoach type scoring.

Id take Sinclair in DT, not really interested in Supercoach so cant help out there

 

[Don Cottagers]

anyone think Knights is worhty of a spot in the 22?

Not quite yet, may very well warrant a top 22 birth soon though

 

[nicho_magic]

anyone think Knights is worhty of a spot in the 22?

don't really think he's a worthy starter mate. you can easily fit in a player that is round 170 who will be a much better performer. knights has copped way too much hype imo.

 

[sante]

don't really think he's a worthy starter mate. you can easily fit in a player that is round 170 who will be a much better performer. knights has copped way too much hype imo.

Maybe too much hype but in DT he is going to be worth every cent you pay for him