Mate, i totally agree, i would never get him this week. Don't get a rookie after one game. As dont bowl there said, wait until he is named for his third game.
With regards to Carr and McManus, even if they do kill it, Hinkley has been doing the WAFL same, why play old players when younger ones are just as good?. So if Hinkley can get past this week and play a good game, he will be in for a while IMO. As i said he is averaging 24 touches and 5 marks in 4 games in thew WAFL. I would not be playing the Carr and McManus type of players if i was Harvey, the dockers should be looking towards the future.