AFL Evolution player ratings discussion thread

[bradburygold]

Boyd played 15 games. He averaged the same stats as Daniher and obviously kicked less goals from less games. You guys are kidding if you dont think his Grand Final performance puts him ahead of Daniher. Who else at 195+cm as their number 1 forward plays every game and only manages 43 goals? Thats laughable, on a team of scrubs he shouldve kicked 60 if he was any good!!

Nick riewoldt

 

[bradburygold]

Here's the wingmen. Remember the ratings aren't important yet, just the order from best to worst. Don't forget about the players rated <75 as well!
View attachment 325233

Think you need to look at that again before you post. Dale thomas is what?? No hartung?

 

[GOTHELIONS16]

Think you need to look at that again before you post. Dale thomas is what?? No hartung?

Added Hartung and changed Thomas to a FWD/MID

 

[FearTheBeard13]

Added Hartung and changed Thomas to a FWD/MID

I think he meant Thomas' rating? He certainly is primarily a wingman, but 82 is a bit generous no? 80.

 

[Thommo333]

Johanissen and Biggs are more half backs than wingman although they might be played there this year since we have so much depth in that position. Biggs should also be a 77-79. Also think Jetta, Stanton and Pearce are a couple of overalls to high should be around 78-80

 

[GOTHELIONS16]

Johanissen and Biggs are more half backs than wingman although they might be played there this year since we have so much depth in that position. Biggs should also be a 78-79. Also think Jetta, Stanton and Pearce are a couple of overalls to high should be high 70s

we are looking at the order of the players from best to worst, not ratings atm

 

[FearTheBeard13]

we are looking at the order of the players from best to worst, not ratings atm

Wouldnt the ratings determine that order?

 

[GOTHELIONS16]

Wouldnt the ratings determine that order?

part of it but as long as we are player order focused not just throwing out numbers of what a player should be rated without looking to see if they are better than the player below them and worse than the player above them if you see what I mean.

 

[GOTHELIONS16]

Keep suggestions coming. Here's the Small Defenders. Order of players from best to worst.

 

[bradburygold]

Keep suggestions coming. Here's the Small Defenders. Order of players from best to worst.
View attachment 325266

Zach is top 3 in that list, freak. The ratings for all need to drop about 2. Guessing stratton is a med def

 

[kangle4]

Lewis Jetta too high and Isaac Smith should be the best wingman.

Nick Smith is a small defender and should be second to Heath Shaw.

 

[FearTheBeard13]

Keep suggestions coming. Here's the Small Defenders. Order of players from best to worst.
View attachment 325266

Shaw deserves a 90 rating. Legitimately gets better each season at GWS. No way is Houli an 85 either, played half the season and pretty inconsistent with the ball usage.

 

[dylan93]

Is everyone happy with the ruckman list. Next its Key Forwards or Wingmen. Your choice!

So your telling me that Stretch, Kent, Oliver and Hunt are better than some of the demons rated above them? I will boost Jetta up to 80 and Tyson up too. Spencer is the second ruckman, if gawn gets injured he's in? Garland may not get a game but that hasn't happened yet his rating demonstrates that he is gradually declining as his bad form continues. I wil add Filipovic, Smith and Keilty. What are there positions? Thanks

Sure am! Spencer is still shite though?

 

[Thommo333]

Pittard and Williams are both better than Houli

 

[kangle4]

I don't mind where Docherty, Smith and Houli are positioned in the list but all of their ratings are too high by two or three points.

 

[Hawker98]

Here is the finalised Key forwards list and Ruck list. Feel free to continue posting your suggestions for these two categories. Especially the lower rated players which don't seem to be getting much attention. Wingmen to come.
View attachment 325226View attachment 325229

I know he missed the entire season but Roughead should defiantly be in the top 4, if not he should still be above Patton


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[GOTHELIONS16]

I know he missed the entire season but Roughead should defiantly be in the top 4, if not he should still be above Patton


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

I'll put him above Patton

 

[GOTHELIONS16]

For those of you who say Houli is listed too high and Williams should be above him. Houli has been a stable player for some time now. Williams reached a new level this year but has to back it up next year to go past 80.
Bachar Houli Season Highlights out of 12 games he played this year.

32 disps (21 kicks 11 hballs) and 11 marks in Rd 21 4-pt loss to Geelong at the MCG (14 Aug 2016)

30 disps (17 kicks 13 hballs) and 7 marks in Rd 20 15-pt win over Collingwood at the MCG (5 Aug 2016)

21 disps (12 kicks 9 hballs), 11 marks and 4 tackles in Rd 19 88-pt loss to GWS at Manuka Oval (30 Jul 2016)

34 disps (19 kicks 15 hballs) and 7 marks in Rd 6 35-pt loss to Port Adelaide at the MCG (30 Apr 2016)

36 disps (21 kicks 15 hballs), 10 marks and 5 tackles in Rd 3 36-pt loss to Adelaide at Etihad Stadium (9 Apr 2016)

35 disps (17 kicks 18 hballs) and 8 marks in Rd 2 1-pt loss to Collingwood at the MCG (1 Apr 2016)

24 disps (15 kicks 9 hballs) and 6 marks in Rd 1 9-pt win over Carlton at the MCG (24 Mar 2016)

Zach Williams Season Highlights out of 22 games he played this year.

24 disps (16 kicks 8 hballs) and 5 marks in Rd 20 8-pt win over Gold Coast at Metricon Stadium (6 Aug 2016)

24 disps (15 kicks 9 hballs) and 9 marks in Rd 19 88-pt win over Richmond at Manuka Oval (30 Jul 2016)

24 disps (18 kicks 6 hballs) and 3 marks in Rd 17 79-pt win over Brisbane at the Gabba (17 Jul 2016)

24 disps (19 kicks 5 hballs), 4 marks, 4 tackles and a goal in Rd 14 62-pt win over Carlton at Spotless Stadium (25 Jun 2016)

23 disps (12 kicks 11 hballs), 5 marks and 2 goals in Rd 13 27-pt win over Essendon at Etihad Stadium (19 Jun 2016)

23 disps (17 kicks 6 hballs) and 10 marks in Rd 12 42-pt win over Sydney at Spotless Stadium (12 Jun 2016)

25 disps (20 kicks 5 hballs) and 8 marks in Rd 11 10-pt loss to Geelong at Simonds Stadium (4 Jun 2016)

27 disps (12 kicks 15 hballs), 6 marks and 8 tackles in Rd 9 25-pt win over the Western Bulldogs at Spotless Stadium (22 May 2016)

31 disps (20 kicks 11 hballs) and 8 marks in Rd 8 91-pt win over Gold Coast at Spotless Stadium (14 May 2016)

26 disps (13 kicks 13 hballs), 3 marks, 4 tackles and a goal in Rd 5 47-pt win over St Kilda at Etihad Stadium (24 Apr 2016)

 

[GOTHELIONS16]

If that's not enough.

2016 comparison
Disposals:
Houli: 24.9
Williams:20.7
Marks:
Houli: 6.8
Williams: 4.4
Effective Disposals:
Houli: 18.7
Williams: 16.3
Tackles:
Houli: 2.4
Williams: 3.0
Rebound 50s:
Houli: 4.4
Williams: 2.7
Inside 50s:
Houli: 3.2
Williams: 3.4
1%
Houli: 2.2
Williams: 1.6
AFL Fantasy Score:
Houli: 93.3
Williams: 80.0

 

[GOTHELIONS16]

Here's the Forward/Midfielders. Ordered from best to worst. What players need shifting? Ignore the ratings, we need to get them in order first!

 

[JT_the_Man]

Here's the Forward/Midfielders. Ordered from best to worst. What players need shifting? Ignore the ratings, we need to get them in order first!
View attachment 325448

Melksham mid/fwd? From memory Melbourne wanted to play him as a defender.

 

[JT_the_Man]

Sam Mayes is also a defender, not a forward.

 

[GOTHELIONS16]

Sam Mayes is also a defender, not a forward.

Mayes is predominantly a fwd, only played defence this year due to lack of players.

 

[GOTHELIONS16]

What's important is if the players are ordered correctly, not if they are in the right position.

 

[kangle4]

What's important is if the players are ordered correctly, not if they are in the right position.

Players being in their correct positions is pretty important.