Remove this Banner Ad

AFL Evolution player ratings discussion thread

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

ioppolo said:
Don't feed the troll. Has a major issue with any AFL or Cricket game.
Click to expand...
I know, I had a crack at him in another thread. I just want to know why he's saying that. What can make him come to that conclusion this early?
 
Interesting to see who WW consider among the best players at their respective clubs.

ADEL: T. Walker 88, R. Sloane 87, E. Betts 87, D. Talia 84, S. Thompson 83
BRIS: D. Beams 85, T. Rockliff 85, D. Rich 82, S. Martin 82, D. Zorko 80
CARL: M. Murphy 86, B. Gibbs 83, P. Cripps 83, M. Kreuzer 80, K. Simpson 80
COLL: S. Pendlebury 91, S. Sidebottom 85, J. Elliot 84, A. Treloar 84, B. Reid 82
ESS: D. Heppell 85, B. Goddard 84, J. Watson 84, C. Hooker 82, M. Hurley 82
FREM: N. Fyfe 94, D. Mundy 86, S. Hill 84, M. Johnson 83, L. Neale 83
GEEL: P. Dangerfield 91, J. Selwood 90, H. Taylor 84, T. Hawkins 83, M. Blicavs 83
GC: G. Ablett 93, T. Lynch 85, D. Swallow 83, S. May 81, R. Thompson 80
GWS: J. Cameron 86, S. Mumford 86, H. Shaw 86, C. Ward 85, D. Shiel 85
HAW: C. Rioli 89, L. Hodge 88, J. Gunston 87, J. Roughead 86, L. Breust 86
MELB: J. Lewis 87, N. Jones 86, B. Vince 85, M. Gawn 83, J. Hogan 82
NM: T. Goldstein 87, J. Ziebell 84, S. Thompson 84, B. Cunnington 82, S. Higgins 82
PORT: R. Gray 91, C. Wingard 88, T. Boak 87, H. Hartlett 85, O. Wines 84
RICH: A. Rance 90, D. Martin 88, J. Riewoldt 88, T. Cotchin 87, D. Prestia 82
STK: N. Riewoldt 89, J. Steven 87, D. Armitage 82, J. Bruce 81, L. Montagna 81
SYD: J. Kennedy 91, L. Franklin 91, L. Parker 89, D. Hannebery 89, K. Tippett 87
WCE: S. Mitchell 90, J. Kennedy 90, M. Priddis 89, A. Gaff 86, N. Naitanui 85
WB: L. Dahlhaus 86, M. Bontempelli 85, E. Wood 84, R. Murphy 83, M. Wallis 83

So if we believe WW, the best players in the league:

94 - N. Fyfe
93 - G. Ablett
91 - P. Dangerfield, R. Gray, J. Kennedy (SYD), L. Franklin, S. Pendlebury
90 - A. Rance, S. Mitchell, J. Kennedy (WCE), J. Selwood
 
conrad_437 said:
How Bontempelli is only 85 is beyond me.
Click to expand...
i think botempelli with an 85 rating and say high potential to reach 90/91 would be fair enough, seeing as he is only a few years into his career. No point having him at 90 now because there's no way he has already reached his peak.

also there are a lot of great players rated 85 or below too
 

Remove this Banner Ad

The rankings are pretty good i think, apart from a bunch of a grade 22yo's a bit low and some older 30+ players still too high its much better than I expected

I wonder if there is a growth curve built into the ratings so that guys like coniglio and zach merrett will grow throughout the season?
 
I'm led to believe that like the facescans that occured in 2015, the ratings are reflective of the 2015 season also. Fyfe cant be 3 clear points ahead of Dangerfield even last season if Fyfe wasn't injured they would've been tied. Luckily we can just change them ourselves!
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

I'm about to post an updated AFL Evolution Player ratings list for those who wish to change the ratings to a more accurate representation of the players abilities. I will post the lists in two ways. Sorted by rating alone and then sorted in ratings by team.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

AFL Evolution player ratings discussion thread

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top