AFL Evolution player ratings discussion thread

[bradburygold]

If people are going to nitpick the footsoldiers, keep in mind 80 should be a decent B grade player/ top 15ish on list for average side

75 should be the average for players on a playing list so bench and emergencies, not reserves.

70 is D grade / just meets AFL standard.

69 and below are players only considered for games if enormous injuries mount

 

[JT_the_Man]

Zac Merrett should be around 88, Fantasia way too low should be closer to 82. Parish, Laverde, Langford and Francis should be higher than McGrath. All the rest are pretty fair. Also no Tippungwuti or McKenna. Tippa should be around 78-80 and McKenna 70-74.

Didn't even notice how low he had Fanta

 

[GOTHELIONS16]

Thanks guys for all your feedback. I really appreciate it. I have taken on alot of your ratings suggestions and will update them now where they are posted on page 3. However, a couple of them i just don't agree with. that is Wells being lower and Fantasia being rated 82. He is a 75 at best. Also i think Dangerfield at a 94 is fair and he will be the highest rated player. I don't think he is as good as Ablett was when rated 95 in 2013. Thanks guys!

 

[GOTHELIONS16]

Stay tuned for some more teams today.

 

[JT_the_Man]

Thanks guys for all your feedback. I really appreciate it. I have taken on alot of your ratings suggestions and will update them now where they are posted on page 3. However, a couple of them i just don't agree with. that is Wells being lower and Fantasia being rated 82. He is a 75 at best. Also i think Dangerfield at a 94 is fair and he will be the highest rated player. I don't think he is as good as Ablett was when rated 95 in 2013. Thanks guys!

Fanta kicked 29 goals as a small forward in the most dysfunctional forward line ever assembled. Second in the team to Joe Daniher, who was our target when entering the forward 50 every time.

 

[eDPS]

Thanks guys for all your feedback. I really appreciate it. I have taken on alot of your ratings suggestions and will update them now where they are posted on page 3. However, a couple of them i just don't agree with. that is Wells being lower and Fantasia being rated 82. He is a 75 at best. Also i think Dangerfield at a 94 is fair and he will be the highest rated player. I don't think he is as good as Ablett was when rated 95 in 2013. Thanks guys!

He is miles ahead of Green who you have at 74, he is one of the better small forwards in the comp and should be closer to 80

 

[GOTHELIONS16]

He is miles ahead of Green who you have at 74, he is one of the better small forwards in the comp and should be closer to 80

Green kicked 33 goals 2 seasons in a row in an even more dysfunctional forward line at Brisbane. I have put Fantasia at 74. That is all he should be. There is no way he is an 80! I would like to see the opinion of a non-Essendon supporter on the subject

 

[JT_the_Man]

Green kicked 33 goals 2 seasons in a row in an even more dysfunctional forward line at Brisbane. I have put Fantasia at 74. That is all he should be. There is no way he is an 80! I would like to see the opinion of a non-Essendon supporter on the subject

I know I'm no opposition supporter, but Fanta is one of my few locks for round 1 next year.

Just my 2c.

 

[GOTHELIONS16]

If people are going to nitpick the footsoldiers, keep in mind 80 should be a decent B grade player/ top 15ish on list for average side

75 should be the average for players on a playing list so bench and emergencies, not reserves.

70 is D grade / just meets AFL standard.

69 and below are players only considered for games if enormous injuries mount

agreed

 

[GOTHELIONS16]

I know I'm no opposition supporter, but Fanta is one of my few locks for round 1 next year.

Just my 2c.

but then again you thought tim membrey should be on the cover instead of the Bont.

 

[GOTHELIONS16]

AFL Evolution- Gold Coast Player Ratings

Is Gazza too low? Is Harbrow too high? What about new recruits Hanley and Barlow?
Gold Coast

Gary Ablett- 92

Tom Lynch- 90

Seven May- 86

Pearce Hanley- 85

Jarrod Harbrow- 84

David Swallow- 83

Michael Rischitelli- 83

Michael Barlow- 81

Rory Thompson- 80

Jack Martin- 80

Aaron Hall- 79

Trent McKenzie- 79

Kade Kolodjashnij- 79

Matt Rosa- 79

Adam Saad- 78

Touk Miller- 78

Jarrod Witts- 78

Tom Nicholls- 77

Brandon Matera- 77

Jarryd Lyons- 76

Sam Day- 75

Jesse Lonergan- 75

Matt Shaw- 75

Peter Wright- 74

Daniel Currie- 74

Alex Sexton- 73

Mitch Hallahan- 73

Sean Lemmens- 71

Callum Ah Chee- 71

Jarrad Grant- 70

Ben Ainsworth- 69

Will Brodie- 69

Jack Scrimshaw- 67

Josh Schoenfield- 67

Jack Leslie- 66

Jack Bowes- 66

Keegan Brooksby- 66

Ryan Davis- 65

Jesse Joyce- 64

Brayden Fiorini- 64

Darcy Macpherson- 62

Brad Scheer- 62

Mackenzie Willis- 61

Cameron Loersch- 59

 

[JT_the_Man]

but then again you thought tim membrey should be on the cover instead of the Bont.

...

You do realise that whole thing was a joke right? Seeing if the AFL would let anyone but Bont get on?

 

[GOTHELIONS16]

AFL Evolution- GWS Player Ratings
Is Toby Greene right despite being AA? Is Heath Shaw too high? Is Rory Lobb worth an 80?

GWS

Shane Mumford- 89

Heath Shaw- 88

Tom Scully- 88

Jeremy Cameron- 87

Callan Ward- 87

Phil Davis- 86

Brett Deledio- 86

Steve Johnson- 86

Toby Greene- 85

Dylan Shiel- 85

Ryan Griffen- 85

Stephen Coniglio- 85

Jonathan Patton- 84

Josh Kelly- 83

Joel Patfull- 82

Lachie Whitfield- 81

Rory Lobb- 80

Devon Smith- 79

Zach Williams- 79

Adam Kennedy- 77

Matt de Boer- 77

Tendai Mzungu- 76

Nick Haynes- 76

Dawson Simpson- 75

Jacob Hopper- 75

Adam Tomlinson- 74

Nathan Wilson- 73

Matthew Kennedy- 72

Tim Taranto- 72

Will Setterfield- 70

Tim Mohr- 70

Aidan Corr- 70

Matt Buntine- 70

Harrison Himmelberg- 70

Sam Reid- 69

Tom Downie- 69

Isaac Cumming- 69

Harry Perryman- 67

Matthew Flynn- 64

Jeremy Finlayson- 63

Lachie Tiziani- 61

Zach Sproule- 60

Daniel Lloyd- 60

Jake Stein- 59

 

[GOTHELIONS16]

...

You do realise that whole thing was a joke right? Seeing if the AFL would let anyone but Bont get on?

yes, i'm just being annoying.

 

[GOTHELIONS16]

AFL Evolution- Hawthorn Player Ratings
Is Burgoyne rated accurately? Should Rioli be equal to Betts? What's everyone's thoughts on Roughy?
Hawthorn

Cyril Rioli- 91

Josh Gibson- 87

Luke Hodge- 87

Jack Gunston- 86

James Frawley- 85

Shaun Burgoyne- 85

Jarryd Roughead- 84

Isaac Smith- 84

Jaegar O'Meara- 84

Tom Mitchell- 84

Luke Breust- 83

Liam Shiels- 82

Ben Stratton- 82

Grant Birchall- 82

Ben McEvoy- 81

Ty Vickery- 80

Paul Puopolo- 79

Jonathan Ceglar- 79

Taylor Duryea- 77

Billy Hartung- 76

James Sicily- 75

Jonathan O’Rourke- 75

Ricky Henderson- 75

Ryan Schoenmakers- 75

Will Langford- 74

Brendan Whitecross- 74

Ryan Burton- 72

Tim O’Brien- 71

Jack Fitzpatrick- 70

Marc Pittonet- 69

Daniel Howe- 67

Kieran Lovell- 67

Teia Miles- 65

Kade Stewart- 65

Blake Hardwick- 64

Dallas Willsmore- 63

Kurt Heatherley- 63

Luke Surman- 62

Kaiden Brand- 62

Mitchell Lewis- 59

Conor Glass- 59

Oliver Hanrahan- 59

James Cousins- 57

Conor Nash- 57

 

[GOTHELIONS16]

AFL Evolution- Melbourne Player Ratings
Who is Melbourne's best player. Dee fans? Is 85 fair for Gawn or not?
Melbourne

Bernie Vince- 87

Jordan Lewis- 87

Jack Viney- 86

Nathan Jones- 86

Tom McDonald- 86

Jesse Hogan- 85

Max Gawn- 85

Jack Watts- 82

Michael Hibberd- 81

Jeff Garlett- 80

Thomas Bugg- 79

Colin Garland- 78

Jack Trengove- 78

Angus Brayshaw- 78

Christian Petracca- 78

Dom Tyson- 77

Sam Frost- 76

Neville Jetta- 76

Jake Spencer- 76

Christian Salem- 75

Cameron Pederson- 74

Oscar McDonald- 73

Jake Melksham- 72

James Harmes- 72

Ben Kennedy- 71

Aaron Vandenberg- 70

Billy Stretch- 70

Dean Kent- 69

Clayton Oliver- 69

Sam Weideman- 69

Jayden Hunt- 68

Jay Kennedy –Harris- 67

Josh Wagner- 65

Mitchell King- 64

Alex Neal-Bullen- 64

Liam Hulett- 62

Mitch White- 60

Dion Johnstone- 60

Joel Smith- 59

Corey Maynard- 58

Mitch Hanan- 58

 

[JT_the_Man]

AFL Evolution- Hawthorn Player Ratings
Is Burgoyne rated accurately? Should Rioli be equal to Betts? What's everyone's thoughts on Roughy?
Hawthorn

Cyril Rioli- 91

Josh Gibson- 87

Luke Hodge- 87

Jack Gunston- 86

James Frawley- 85

Shaun Burgoyne- 85

Jarryd Roughead- 84

Isaac Smith- 84

Jaegar O'Meara- 84

Luke Breust- 83

Tom Mitchell- 83

Liam Shiels- 82

Ben Stratton- 82

Grant Birchall- 82

Ben McEvoy- 81

Ty Vickery- 80

Paul Puopolo- 79

Jonathan Ceglar- 79

Taylor Duryea- 77

Billy Hartung- 76

James Sicily- 75

Jonathan O’Rourke- 75

Ricky Henderson- 75

Ryan Schoenmakers- 75

Will Langford- 74

Brendan Whitecross- 74

Angus Litherland- 73

Tim O’Brien- 71

Marc Pittonet- 69

Ryan Burton- 68

Dallas Willsmore- 67

Daniel Howe- 65

Teia Miles- 65

Kade Stewart- 65

Kurt Heatherley- 63

Luke Surman- 62

Kaiden Brand- 62

Blake Hardwick- 61

Kieran Lovell- 60

Mitchell Lewis- 59

Conor Glass- 58

He was delisted.

 

[eDPS]

Green kicked 33 goals 2 seasons in a row in an even more dysfunctional forward line at Brisbane. I have put Fantasia at 74. That is all he should be. There is no way he is an 80! I would like to see the opinion of a non-Essendon supporter on the subject

Doesn't seem right when he has has a better year than Charlie Cameron as a forward yet Cameron is a 78. I could argue for a lot of players but no way should he be any lower than 78 if Cameron is 78

 

[GOTHELIONS16]

Doesn't seem right when he has has a better year than Charlie Cameron as a forward yet Cameron is a 78. I could argue for a lot of players but no way should he be any lower than 78 if Cameron is 78

Cameron isn't just a forward. played alot of wing time as well as at half forward. Cameron is better than Fantasia in my unbiased opinion. Fantasia is very hit and miss.

 

[eDPS]

Cameron isn't just a forward. played alot of wing time as well as at half forward. Cameron is better than Fantasia in my unbiased opinion. Fantasia is very hit and miss.

So did Fantasia, he was averaging 25 touches on a wing before he was needed forward. I'm not saying Cameron is bad but as a comparison he should be on par with him. He has averaged more Disposals and goals so what makes him hit and miss compared to Cameron?

 

[GOTHELIONS16]

So did Fantasia, he was averaging 25 touches on a wing before he was needed forward. I'm not saying Cameron is bad but as a comparison he should be on par with him. He has averaged more Disposals and goals so what makes him hit and miss compared to Cameron?

I think the problem is Cameron is too high. I have lowered him to 76 and boosted Fantasia to 75

 

[GOTHELIONS16]

He was delisted.

who was delisted?

 

[GOTHELIONS16]

AFL Evolution- North Melbourne Player Ratings
Have I got Big Ben Brown right at 79? Is Hansen too high Roo fans?

North Melbourne

Todd Goldstein- 88

Jack Ziebel- 86

Andrew Swallow- 85

Robbie Tarrant- 84

Scott Thompson- 84

Ben Cunnington- 83

Jarrad Waite- 83

Shaun Higgins- 82

Lindsay Thomas- 81

Shaun Atley- 80

Sam Gibson- 80

Ben Brown- 79

Jamie Macmillan- 78

Majak Daw- 78

Lachie Hansen- 78

Jed Anderson- 75

Ben Jacobs- 75

Luke McDonald- 75

Sam Wright- 74

Mason Wood- 73

Marley Williams- 73

Joel Tippett- 73

Jed Anderson- 73

Nathan Hrovat- 73

Aaron Mullett- 73

Kayne Turner- 72

Paul Ahern- 71

Taylor Garner- 70

Brad McKenzie- 70

Trent Dumont- 69

Ben McKay- 69

Ryan Clarke- 68

Jy Simpkin- 67

Mitchell Hibberd- 66

Sam Durdin- 65

Corey Wagner- 65

Daniel Nielsen- 65

Ed Vickers- Willis- 64

Declan Watson- 64

Will Fordham- 62

Declan Mountford- 62

Josh Williams- 62

Matt Taylor- 61

Cameron Zurhaar- 61

Brayden Preuss- 60

Nick Larkey- 59

Oscar Junker- 58

 

[JT_the_Man]

who was delisted?

Litherland.

 

[Scullywag]

AFL Evolution- GWS Player Ratings
Is Toby Greene right despite being AA? Is Heath Shaw too high? Is Rory Lobb worth an 80?

GWS

Shane Mumford- 89

Heath Shaw- 88

Tom Scully- 88

Jeremy Cameron- 87

Callan Ward- 87

Phil Davis- 86

Brett Deledio- 86

Steve Johnson- 86

Toby Greene- 85

Dylan Shiel- 85

Ryan Griffen- 85

Jonathan Patton- 84

Stephen Coniglio- 83

Joel Patfull- 82

Josh Kelly- 82

Lachie Whitfield- 81

Rory Lobb- 80

Devon Smith- 79

Zach Williams- 79

Adam Kennedy- 77

Matt de Boer- 77

Tendai Mzungu- 76

Nick Haynes- 76

Dawson Simpson- 75

Jacob Hopper- 75

Adam Tomlinson- 74

Nathan Wilson- 73

Matthew Kennedy- 72

Tim Taranto- 72

Will Setterfield- 70

Tim Mohr- 70

Aidan Corr- 70

Matt Buntine- 70

Harrison Himmelberg- 70

Sam Reid- 69

Tom Downie- 69

Isaac Cumming- 69

Harry Perryman- 67

Matthew Flynn- 64

Jeremy Finlayson- 63

Lachie Tiziani- 61

Zach Sproule- 60

Daniel Lloyd- 60

Jake Stein- 59

Coniglio is better than Scully and Ward, I'd have all 3 at 87. Zac Williams is also an 83-84