Game Day AFL Round 20 - Matchday Discussion Collingwood@Sydney(SCG – 7:25PM)

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
It’s an absolutely critical game this Saturday, with two finals contenders in Collingwood and the Swans going head to head at the SCG. Both these teams have had injured seasons, which have really hampered the campaigns of both teams. Both teams are coming off a crucial losses. For Collingwood, it was a last quarter fade out to Richmond after playing a brilliant first three quarters. For Sydney, they have dropped a few crucial games in the past few weeks. Both sides will be eyeing a win this week to steady their ship in their 2018 campaign.


Collingwood

The Magpies can’t seem to catch a break this season, with injuries to more key players occurring each week. Last week, key backmen in Jeremy Howe and Matt Scharenberg has decimated the Collingwood backline. To go along with this, star forward Jamie Elliott has suffered what will most likely be a season ending injury. It’s quite unfortunate for Collingwood, as many will wonder what could have been if the injuries could have been minimized. Nevertheless, Collingwood are still in contention for a top eight spot, and a win against Sydney can really secure their spot in the finals.

Similar to the match earlier in the season, Collingwood were able to hang with Richmond for three quarters, but injuries caused them to really fall away in the last quarter. Brodie Grundy and Josh Thomas were outstanding for the Magpies, with Darcy Moore controlling the backline. However, injuries to Howe and Scharenberg proved costly to the Magpies.

The man to watch for Collingwood is Jack Madgen. Standing at 6’4, Madgen spent three years at Delta State University in the United States. Madgen gets his chance with Howe out with concussion. He will get have his work cut out for him with a very potent Swans forward line. Madgen will have to deal with likes of Ronke and Franklin in a very dangerous forward line.



Sydney

Like Collingwood, injuries to the Swans have really derailed their season. For Sydney, their season is on the ropes, and they will need a win against the Magpies to keep their season alive. The Swans are coming off two disappointing performances, a huge upset against the Suns and a mighty disappointing performance. Simply put, the Swans lack imagination when going forward. They are predictable in the forward line, and when they are on the defensive, their tackle count is much lower than what many have expected from the Swans in the past few years. Last week against the Bombers, Sydney just couldn’t get any fluid movement going. Lance Franklin copped the brunt of the criticism, with many stating that the star forward is starting to significantly slowing down. Longmire came out during the week stating that Franklin has been carrying an injury all season, but has made the bold move not to rest Franklin.

The man to watch for the Swans is Alex Johnson. 2136 days. That’s how many days it has been since Alex Johnson has played top level football. The star backman has suffered numerous long term injuries, but his resilience should be commended, as many would have quit long before him, if they suffered the same setbacks. While Johnson may not live up to the lofty standards he set in 2012, it is one of the feel-good stories of the season. Many will be hoping he can make an impact on the game.



Head to Head odds

Collingwood: $2.15

Sydney: $1.72


Changes

Sydney

IN

Alex Johnson, Kieren Jack, Jarrad McVeigh, Daniel Robinson

OUT

Robbie Fox (Omitted), Colin O'Riordan (Injured), Zak Jones (Suspension), Heath Grundy (Mental Health)

Collingwood

IN

Jack Madgen, Brayden Sier

OUT

Matthew Scharenberg (Injured), Jeremy Howe (Injured)

TV

Live on Fox Footy, Commercial Free

Live on Channel 7, Except SA and QLD

Radio

3AW
ABC
MMM

IPTV

AFL Live Pass
Foxtel Now
WatchAFL



The run home…

So, it’s the pointy end of the season, and it’s necessary to see what a loss or win means for Collingwood. The ladder predictor will assume that all the other favorites win.


If Collingwood wins

They will remain where they are.

If Collingwood loses

They could drop significantly. If a particular set of results occur, Collingwood could be outside the eight by the end of the round.


Tip

Both sides are troubled with injuries, but the Swans have a much more complete team. With Collingwood lacking some key backmen, Franklin should have a field day and lead the Swans to a critical victory.

Swans by 25.
 
Last edited:

Log in to remove this ad.

Have we won yet?

We’ll win nicely.

Pessimism stays In Melbourne.
Victory goes to Sydney.

Ps Geelong losing helps us too
 
It’s an absolutely critical game this Saturday, with two finals contenders in Collingwood and the Swans going head to head at the MCG. Both these teams have had injured seasons, which have really hampered the campaigns of both teams. Both teams are coming off a crucial losses. For Collingwood, it was a last quarter fade out to Richmond after playing a brilliant first three quarters. For Sydney, they have dropped a few crucial games in the past few weeks. Both sides will be eyeing a win this week to steady their ship in their 2018 campaign.


Collingwood

The Magpies can’t seem to catch a break this season, with injuries to more key players occurring each week. Last week, key backmen in Jeremy Howe and Matt Scharenberg has decimated the Collingwood backline. To go along with this, star forward Jamie Elliott has suffered what will most likely be a season ending injury. It’s quite unfortunate for Collingwood, as many will wonder what could have been if the injuries could have been minimized. Nevertheless, Collingwood are still in contention for a top eight spot, and a win against Sydney can really secure their spot in the finals.

Similar to the match earlier in the season, Collingwood were able to hang with Richmond for three quarters, but injuries caused them to really fall away in the last quarter. Brodie Grundy and Josh Thomas were outstanding for the Magpies, with Darcy Moore controlling the backline. However, injuries to Howe and Scharenberg proved costly to the Magpies.

The man to watch for Collingwood is Jack Madgen. Standing at 6’4, Madgen spent three years at Delta State University in the United States. Madgen gets his chance with Howe out with concussion. He will get have his work cut out for him with a very potent Swans forward line. Madgen will have to deal with likes of Ronke and Franklin in a very dangerous forward line.



Sydney

Like Collingwood, injuries to the Swans have really derailed their season. For Sydney, their season is on the ropes, and they will need a win against the Magpies to keep their season alive. The Swans are coming off two disappointing performances, a huge upset against the Suns and a mighty disappointing performance. Simply put, the Swans lack imagination when going forward. They are predictable in the forward line, and when they are on the defensive, their tackle count is much lower than what many have expected from the Swans in the past few years. Last week against the Bombers, Sydney just couldn’t get any fluid movement going. Lance Franklin copped the brunt of the criticism, with many stating that the star forward is starting to significantly slowing down. Longmire came out during the week stating that Franklin has been carrying an injury all season, but has made the bold move not to rest Franklin.

The man to watch for the Swans is Alex Johnson. 2136 days. That’s how many days it has been since Alex Johnson has played top level football. The star backman has suffered numerous long term injuries, but his resilience should be commended, as many would have quit long before him, if they suffered the same setbacks. While Johnson may not live up to the lofty standards he set in 2012, it is one of the feel-good stories of the season. Many will be hoping he can make an impact on the game.



Head to Head odds

Collingwood: $2.15

Sydney: $1.72


Changes

Sydney

IN

Alex Johnson, Kieren Jack, Jarrad McVeigh, Daniel Robinson

OUT

Robbie Fox (Omitted), Colin O'Riordan (Injured), Zak Jones (Suspension), Heath Grundy (Mental Health)

Collingwood

IN

Jack Madgen, Brayden Sier

OUT

Matthew Scharenberg (Injured), Jeremy Howe (Injured)

TV

Live on Fox Footy, Commercial Free

Live on Channel 7, Except SA and QLD

Radio

3AW
ABC
MMM

IPTV

AFL Live Pass
Foxtel Now
WatchAFL



The run home…

So, it’s the pointy end of the season, and it’s necessary to see what a loss or win means for Collingwood. The ladder predictor will assume that all the other favorites win.


If Collingwood wins

They will remain where they are.

If Collingwood loses

They could drop significantly. If a particular set of results occur, Collingwood could be outside the eight by the end of the round.


Tip

Both sides are troubled with injuries, but the Swans have a much more complete team. With Collingwood lacking some key backmen, Franklin should have a field day and lead the Swans to a critical victory.

Swans by 25.

Are you going to the game bo?
 
Swans by 25?


Who wrote this s**t?
Bored, that’s a bit rough.

Boxy does a great intro each week.
Applaud what it adds to our Board.

Happy to disagree with his prediction this week, actually most weeks he is less optimistic than me.

I reckon we have a real chance and win nicely.
 
Have some respect. They go to a lot of effort every week to do this. Some of us enjoy their insight.

Bo Doesn't deserve much respect considering he's born out of a black/white concept that he hasn't moved on from, so trolls gameday threads from the OP.

I personally find his Americanizations and having American athletes in his avatar annoying too.
 
Big game. Win this and we basically cement ourselves in the top 8 (barring a complete disaster and all results going against us). If we want to make something of this year, must win to keep our top 4 hopes alive.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

boxmatrix careful there.
You don’t want to be heading to the MCG when it’s a bit more North than there.
800km.

Poor old Spud Frawley went to Etihad Stadium tonight instead of the MCG.
A poor appropriate nickname has yet to be given than Spud.
 
Swans by 25? Da *?

Not sure if the op remembers but they lost to gc at home and then got pantsed at their second home ground in etihad by the dons.

If they win it will be less than a goal. However I'm confident in what we are doing and feel we can cover for the losses. Our midfield and forward line is superior than theirs. Our pace will be too much.

Pies by 25
 
Have some respect. They go to a lot of effort every week to do this. Some of us enjoy their insight.
Bored, that’s a bit rough.

Boxy does a great intro each week.
Applaud what it adds to our Board.

Happy to disagree with his prediction this week, actually most weeks he is less optimistic than me.

I reckon we have a real chance and win nicely.
Apologies, thought it was just copied and pasted from AFL.com

We aren't losing tomorrow night.
 
Heading off to the game tomorrow morning, lucky undies in tow.
A smile on my face and hope in my heart.
Have the 2010 Jumper signed by the whole side in the tote and a fist full of beer drinkin dollars.

Go Pies!:thumbsu::thumbsu:
 
Thong hey.
Not my thing but each to their own.
No thong.
Old school undies.
Black and white of course.....
Circa 2007.....
They been off twice in public...2007 and 2010
 
This is easily the weakest team we have put on the park all year.

A win would be excellent but a loss wouldn't exactly be to shocking
A loss would be a disaster as we would slide down the ladder significantly.

That being said, the team actually stacks up alright to the team that beat them there last year...

Schade -> Madgen
Broomhead -> Brown?
Fasolo -> JT?
White -> Cox
Reid -> Mihocek
Smith -> Daicos
Goldsack -> Langdon
Ramsay -> Murray

WHE 2017 is far surpassed by WHE 2018, and Stephenson a huge in

Treloar is a big loss so we need a big game from The Bear. Howe out also hurts.
 
This is Grind-It-Out Time, people.

We're pretty banged up. So, it must be said, are they. We're trying to sustain a rise. They're trying to arrest a fall. This will, consequently, probably not be the prettiest game to watch.

So just win, Collingwood. Just put the shoulders to the wheel, grind it out and just f.ucken well win.

Collingwood by 9 points.

(Congratulations to Jack Madgen on the debut. Can play...)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top