
Bjo187
Club Legend
- Apr 30, 2020
- 1,996
- 2,341
- AFL Club
- Essendon
Now I was tired of State of Origin myself and it being brought up every year as possibly coming back, but the reason it lost it's appeal is because Victoria became too powerful, with a massive increase in population differential from the other footy states, therefore fans lost interest and so did the players. I was thinking to myself, isn’t it silly that the NRL uses an AFL concept of state of origin successfully, for a sport that is basically only played in two states, and yet we don’t have any representative football for a sport played across the whole of Australia. The key to the success of representative games is for them to be competitive.
The solution therefore, is staring us right in the face. By using the successful under 18s TAC Cup national championships model. This is what I would like to see going forward in the round before the bye each year or bi-annually. Apologies if I get any names or states of players wrong.
Thursday Night - This would arguably be the best game of the series
W.A V S.A (Optus Stadium or Adelaide Oval)
W.A Coach: John Worsfold
W.A Key players: Cripps, Natanui, Franklin, Coniglio, T.Mitchell, S.Bolton, Naughton, Fyfe
S.A Coach: Simon Goodwin
S.A Key players: Grundy, Neale, C. Daniel, Hurn, Rozee, Laird, J. Graham, Ballard, Fredrick
Commentators: Try to bring Bruce (SA) and Dennis (WA) back for a one off each year as they are both passionate about their states. In saying that it seems JB, BT and Hamish are from SA & WA anyway so they could just go with them. Special comments from former SA and WA stars of the past.
Friday Night - this would be like an all-star game with some of the biggest names in the sport.
Vic Metro V Vic Country (MCG, Marvel or Geelong),
Vic Metro Coach: Mick Malthouse
Vic Metro Key players: Petracca, Oliver, Bontompelli, Gawn, De Goey, McKay etc.
Vic Country Coach: Alistair Clarkson
Vic Country Key players: Dangerfield, Martin, Wines, Stringer, Parish, J.Cameron etc.
Commentators: The standard 7 commentary team but ensuring a country special comments ex player and metro ex player.
Saturday Night - There is usually no sport on FTA into NSW and QLD on Saturday nights, free space & great promotion for the code
NSW V QLD (SCG or Gabba)
NSW Coach: John Longmire
NSW Key players: Hawkins, Walker, Bruest, Witts, Heeney, Mills, Cumming, Hopper, Rampe
QLD Coach: Michael Voss
QLD Key players: Dixon, Chol, C.Cameron, Keays, Tom Green
, Zorko, H.Andrews, Allir
Commentators: The standard 7 commentary team but ensuring Carey (NSW) and Dunstall (QLD) as special comments.
*NSW and QLD are surprisingly strong lists and are an even match up. To increase depth, players from ACT that have lived in NSW (ie, Steele, Bruce) and players from N.T that have lived in QLD (ie. May, Jeffrey) can nominate to play for NSW & QLD.
Potential issues
*To avoid the issue of players pulling out, any player selected that pulls out must sit out the following weeks home and away match as well. You would fixture it so that the games are like this to ensure the big players want to play in the origin games rnd 10. State of origin, rnd 11. Bye Round, rnd 12. Top teams playing each other in the H&A competition.
I found a study done a few years ago where they put the state teams together and found that on paper and supercoach rankings wise, each of the state teams listed actually out rank the current day premier. This is interesting and blows away the myth of some of the states not having strong enough talent to field teams.
This concept is great promotion in the northern states as I think most people in NSW and QLD have little idea about how many players there are from their own state that play in the AFL and that it’s a southerners sport. It also rekindles big rivalries in the traditional footy states where S.A would love to knock off W.A and W.A fans would love to see the likes of Buddy Franklin representing them on the national stage.
Also the pride of country Victoria in potentially knocking off the city slickers would be immense.
The fixture could change from year to year, for example year two you might have the winners going up a rung to play off. So year two could be W.A V Vic Metro at Optus stadium, S.A V Vic Country etc. Actually just looking at the teams, NSW would give S.A a run for their money too.
What the concept also does is breaks the season up and gives the bottom teams and their supporters something to look forward to in a long season and great promotion for the AFL as Australia’s only truly popular and fully national domestic competition with high calibre footballers from every state in the country.
The solution therefore, is staring us right in the face. By using the successful under 18s TAC Cup national championships model. This is what I would like to see going forward in the round before the bye each year or bi-annually. Apologies if I get any names or states of players wrong.
Thursday Night - This would arguably be the best game of the series
W.A V S.A (Optus Stadium or Adelaide Oval)
W.A Coach: John Worsfold
W.A Key players: Cripps, Natanui, Franklin, Coniglio, T.Mitchell, S.Bolton, Naughton, Fyfe
S.A Coach: Simon Goodwin
S.A Key players: Grundy, Neale, C. Daniel, Hurn, Rozee, Laird, J. Graham, Ballard, Fredrick
Commentators: Try to bring Bruce (SA) and Dennis (WA) back for a one off each year as they are both passionate about their states. In saying that it seems JB, BT and Hamish are from SA & WA anyway so they could just go with them. Special comments from former SA and WA stars of the past.
Friday Night - this would be like an all-star game with some of the biggest names in the sport.
Vic Metro V Vic Country (MCG, Marvel or Geelong),
Vic Metro Coach: Mick Malthouse
Vic Metro Key players: Petracca, Oliver, Bontompelli, Gawn, De Goey, McKay etc.
Vic Country Coach: Alistair Clarkson
Vic Country Key players: Dangerfield, Martin, Wines, Stringer, Parish, J.Cameron etc.
Commentators: The standard 7 commentary team but ensuring a country special comments ex player and metro ex player.
Saturday Night - There is usually no sport on FTA into NSW and QLD on Saturday nights, free space & great promotion for the code
NSW V QLD (SCG or Gabba)
NSW Coach: John Longmire
NSW Key players: Hawkins, Walker, Bruest, Witts, Heeney, Mills, Cumming, Hopper, Rampe
QLD Coach: Michael Voss
QLD Key players: Dixon, Chol, C.Cameron, Keays, Tom Green
PLAYERCARDSTART
12
Tom Green
- Age
- 22
- Ht
- 192cm
- Wt
- 92kg
- Pos.
- Mid
Career
Season
Last 5
- D
- 11.5
- 3star
- K
- 4.3
- 2star
- HB
- 7.3
- 5star
- M
- 1.8
- 2star
- T
- 2.3
- 4star
- CL
- 2.8
- 4star
- D
- 11.5
- 3star
- K
- 4.3
- 2star
- HB
- 7.3
- 4star
- M
- 1.8
- 2star
- T
- 2.3
- 3star
- CL
- 2.8
- 4star
- D
- 11.5
- 3star
- K
- 4.3
- 2star
- HB
- 7.3
- 5star
- M
- 1.8
- 2star
- T
- 2.3
- 4star
- CL
- 2.8
- 5star
PLAYERCARDEND
Commentators: The standard 7 commentary team but ensuring Carey (NSW) and Dunstall (QLD) as special comments.
*NSW and QLD are surprisingly strong lists and are an even match up. To increase depth, players from ACT that have lived in NSW (ie, Steele, Bruce) and players from N.T that have lived in QLD (ie. May, Jeffrey) can nominate to play for NSW & QLD.
Potential issues
*To avoid the issue of players pulling out, any player selected that pulls out must sit out the following weeks home and away match as well. You would fixture it so that the games are like this to ensure the big players want to play in the origin games rnd 10. State of origin, rnd 11. Bye Round, rnd 12. Top teams playing each other in the H&A competition.
I found a study done a few years ago where they put the state teams together and found that on paper and supercoach rankings wise, each of the state teams listed actually out rank the current day premier. This is interesting and blows away the myth of some of the states not having strong enough talent to field teams.
This concept is great promotion in the northern states as I think most people in NSW and QLD have little idea about how many players there are from their own state that play in the AFL and that it’s a southerners sport. It also rekindles big rivalries in the traditional footy states where S.A would love to knock off W.A and W.A fans would love to see the likes of Buddy Franklin representing them on the national stage.
Also the pride of country Victoria in potentially knocking off the city slickers would be immense.
The fixture could change from year to year, for example year two you might have the winners going up a rung to play off. So year two could be W.A V Vic Metro at Optus stadium, S.A V Vic Country etc. Actually just looking at the teams, NSW would give S.A a run for their money too.
What the concept also does is breaks the season up and gives the bottom teams and their supporters something to look forward to in a long season and great promotion for the AFL as Australia’s only truly popular and fully national domestic competition with high calibre footballers from every state in the country.