MVP AFLCA Voting Watch

[ChampRevesby]

WCE LEADERBOARD
57 Elliot Yeo
29 Luke Shuey
19 Josh Kennedy
18 Andrew Gaff
15 Jeremy McGovern
10 Mark LeCras
9 Shannon Hurn
9 Sam Mitchell
7 Lewis Jetta
5 Brad Sheppard
4 Drew Petrie
4 Tom Barrass
3 Jamie Cripps
3 Mark Hutchings
2 Dom Sheed
1 Chris Masten
1 Nathan Vardy

This round:

Gov - 5
Petrie - 3
Shep - 2
Barrass - 1

The fact that Priddis does not even register says everything about his demise.

 

[Chris_6678]

WCE LEADERBOARD
57 Elliot Yeo
29 Luke Shuey
25 Andrew Gaff
19 Josh Kennedy
15 Jeremy McGovern
10 Mark LeCras
9 Shannon Hurn
9 Sam Mitchell
9 Jack Darling
7 Lewis Jetta
6 Brad Sheppard
5 Dom Sheed
5 Mark Hutchings
4 Drew Petrie
4 Tom Barrass
3 Jamie Cripps
3 Eric Mckenzie
1 Chris Masten
1 Nathan Vardy

9 - Darling
7 - Gaff
3 - Mckenzie
2 - Hutchings
1 - Shep

 

[Biggie]

Sheppard eh? Ok..

 

[larrikin]

Sheed got 3 too.

Someone (read Bevo) gave Cordy 4 votes - that surprised me.

 

[Miguel Sanchez]

9 Darling
7 Gaff
4 Cordy
3 MacKenzie
3 Sheed
2 Hutchings
1 Hunter
1 Sheppard

One coach had Gaff best and Darling 2nd. The other had Darling best and Gaff 4th. They didn't agree at all on the other players.

 

[DanWCE]

9 Darling
7 Gaff
4 Cordy
3 MacKenzie
3 Sheed
2 Hutchings
1 Hunter
1 Sheppard

One coach had Gaff best and Darling 2nd. The other had Darling best and Gaff 4th. They didn't agree at all on the other players.

That took some fair working out to understand how votes were given! I thought there was a stuff up somewhere

 

[Ok Boomer]

Meh, had Gaff ahead of Darling but doesn't really matter, and it is great that Jack played really well. Good that Emac got recognised for a really good shut down job.

 

[avishka5]

Bevo probably have gaff 4 after he got critize for not tagging him. Probably wants to show the media that he did rate his performance that high.

Bevo is lucky that it was not gaff of 18 months ago as that gaff would have done much more damage and we possibly would have wrapped that up by 3qt time.

 

[06Premiers]

Cordy eh?
The only thing I remember about him is that he's an ugly campaigner with a gross mo.

 

[Keys]

5 - Darling : Gaff
4 - Cordy : Darling
3 - Sheed / Mackenzie
2 - Gaff : Hutchings
1 - Shepp / Hunter

The 3 and 1 votes are interchangeable but the others can't fall any other way

So Beveridge has either given 5 votes to a player he refused to try and negate or has given Cordy 4 votes

 

[Keys]

Not a single West Coast Player in the coaches votes for yesterday's game

That's a damning indictment on the players given scores were level at three quarter time

 

[Chris_6678]

Simmo not happy with ANY players from our team.. this is good.

I thought Duggan or Darling would have got a vote or two at least.

 

[DanWCE]

Not a single West Coast Player in the coaches votes for yesterday's game

That's a damning indictment on the players given scores were level at three quarter time

But Simmo said it wasn't the personnel Guess we can assume what he says in a presser and behind closed doors are entirely different.

 

[ioppolo]

But Simmo said it wasn't the personnel Guess we can assume what he says in a presser and behind closed doors are entirely different.

You'd hope so.

 

[Miguel Sanchez]

10 Hurn (WCE), 4 Duggan (WCE), 4 McGovern (WCE), 3 Kennedy (WCE), 3 Neale (Frem), 2 Blakely (Frem), 2 Fyfe (Frem), 1 B. Hill (Frem), 1 Sheppard (WCE)

Complete disagreement about the second to fifth-best players.

 

[avishka5]

LOL i got pissede reading this and then i realised this was from last week.

Not a single West Coast Player in the coaches votes for yesterday's game

That's a damning indictment on the players given scores were level at three quarter time

 

[Avalor]

10 Hurn (WCE), 4 Duggan (WCE), 4 McGovern (WCE), 3 Kennedy (WCE), 3 Neale (Frem), 2 Blakely (Frem), 2 Fyfe (Frem), 1 B. Hill (Frem), 1 Sheppard (WCE)

Complete disagreement about the second to fifth-best players.

I thought Duggan would have pulled a few more votes than that - deserved a 7 at least.

 

[Chris_6678]

lol Brad hill did not deserve a vote.

Duggan was wayyyy better than McGovern.

 

[06Premiers]

10 Hurn (WCE), 4 Duggan (WCE), 4 McGovern (WCE), 3 Kennedy (WCE), 3 Neale (Frem), 2 Blakely (Frem), 2 Fyfe (Frem), 1 B. Hill (Frem), 1 Sheppard (WCE)

Complete disagreement about the second to fifth-best players.

Good old Ross Lyin' not giving Duggan votes.

 

[Keys]

10 Hurn (WCE), 4 Duggan (WCE), 4 McGovern (WCE), 3 Kennedy (WCE), 3 Neale (Frem), 2 Blakely (Frem), 2 Fyfe (Frem), 1 B. Hill (Frem), 1 Sheppard (WCE)

Complete disagreement about the second to fifth-best players.

That's a rather bizarre set of votes

 

[mad_eagle]

Pretty fitting...Those votes are a hot mess, just like that game yesterday really.

 

[dewcefault]

Very bizarre voting, I can't recall seeing it this disjointed before.

My very uneducated guess is this is how each coach voted:

Simo / Ross the boss
5: Hurn / Hurn
4: Dugg / McLov
3: JJK / Neale
2: Blake / Fyfe
1: Shep / Hill

Crazy there's no overlap other than Hurn.

 

[Bender_]

Simmo on 6PR said he gave 4 to Duggan and Lyon gave 3 to Kennedy.

 

[RookiePick]

Mcgovern had a very good game. Cant see the problem really

 

[RookiePick]

Rtb probably doesnt even know what duggan looks like