After Three Rounds...

[adam10]

Average score: 2046
Ranking: 4,988
Best pick: ROK, Barlow, Montagna
Worst pick: Medhurst
Player I considered, but glad I left out: Buddy, Hall
Player I considered, and should have picked: Boyd, took him out for Montagna night before, so not THAT bad.
Can't believe I didn't consider: Silvani, although got now
Devastation: Roo and Daniel Connors
Dud Trade: Dont really have one
Season so far out of 10: 7.5/10

Going to be on 16 trades already after this week, which takes down my grade.

 

[bones25]

Average score: 2059.33
Ranking:3368
Best pick: At this stage, Ballantyne, Barlow, Maguire, and very happy with Gilbert, Hodge.
Worst pick: Early days but possibly, Medhurst, will stick with him for now.
Player I considered, but glad I left out: None
Player I considered, and should have picked: Anthony, Sandilands
Can't believe I didn't consider: Brown
Devastation: None
Dud Trade: None

Season so far out of 10: 8/10

 

[oddsok]

Average score: 2039
Ranking:5989
Best pick: Stanton and Kane Bloody Cornes (Obvious ones include ROK, Barlow, Hodge, Sandilands)
Worst pick: Tippett, Hall (maybe) and in the opinion of some; Hille. Ziebell and Duffield haven't bombed but could improve.
Player I considered, but glad I left out: Swan, actually. Armitage, Mackay.
Player I considered, and should have picked: Malceski (Went Hunt), Brown (Traded to ROK on the last day which worked out dandy), Carazzo
Can't believe I didn't consider: Gilbert
Devastation: Riewoldt injury.
Dud Trade: None...so far

Season so far out of 10: 7/10

 

[Majestic1]

Average score: 2102
Ranking: 728
Best pick: Pavlich, Stanton (as more unique's). Bartel, Ablett, Barlow,Sandilands, Hodge, Malceski, Bastinac, Ladson, Waters, Okeffe, Carazzo
Worst pick: Well i dont think you can say after 3 rounds that there is necessarily a bad pick unless of role change or something else more significant. But if i was to put a name down it would be Tippett, Roberts.
Player I considered, but glad I left out: B.Warren, Mcveigh, Connors
Player I considered, and should have picked: Rioli, Goodes, Brown, Kennelly
Can't believe I didn't consider: I considered just about everyone
Devastation: Riewoldt same as everyone though.
Dud Trade: Havnt made any yet. Will trade Riewoldt to one of those players i shouldve picked.

Season so far out of 10: 8/10

 

[Hurley300]

Average score: 2063.33
Ranking:2956
Best pick: Sandilands, ROK, Hodge
Worst pick: M McVeigh
Player I considered, but glad I left out: Clark, Selwood
Player I considered, and should have picked: Gilbert, Brennan
Can't believe I didn't consider: Brown, Stanton
Devastation: Riewoldt. McVeigh playing 1 game from 4.
Dud Trade: None

Season so far out of 10: 8/10

 

[qldbluesman_43]

Average score: 2092
Ranking:1081
Best pick: Boyd or Sandilands
Worst pick: Hall, Medhurst
Player I considered, but glad I left out: Jolly, C. Cornes
Player I considered, and should have picked: Brown,
Can't believe I didn't consider: O'Keefe
Devastation: Don't really care about Riewoldt so much because sure costs me a trade but it costs everyone a trade so it doesn't really matter too much in the end. Devastated i chose not to go with Brown and had to trade him in.
Dud Trade: None really. I'd call Hall + Medhurst - 2 mad mid-range picks for Brown and Duncan a decent enough trade

Season so far out of 10: 9/10

 

[Borshk]

Average Score:2076
Ranking:1883
Best Pick:Boyd
Worst Pick:Warren
Player I considered, but glad I left out:Armitage
Player I considered, and should have picked:Malceski
Devastation:Riewoldt hurt. Grays been on my bench all this time. Hope he plays this sunday
Dud Trade:No trades as yet. Gonna get pav for riewoldt

Season so far out of 10:8/10

 

[Ball Hog]

Average Score: Approx. 2010
Ranking: Top 12 000 approx.

Small sample size but so far...
Best Pick(s): Boyd, Scotland, Reimers, Duncan, Peterson, Barlow, Hodge
Worst Pick(s): Giansiracusa, Redden
Player(s) considered but glad i left out: S.Selwood, Mcgrath
Player I considered and should have picked: Malceski
Devastation: Roo and Connors
Dud Trade: None

So far by my standards: 9/10, by Bigfooty standards probably: 6-7/10

 

[bigburger]

Average Score: 1932
Ranking: 35k roughly

Best Pick(s): Hodge, Barlow, ROK, Malceski,
Worst Pick(s): Giansiracusa, Kennedy(wce), Gray, Waite, Pendles, Ball, Martin, Hille, Hall, Hurn (How f**ken terrible is that)
Player(s) considered but glad i left out: S.Selwood, Tippett,
Player I considered and should have picked: Carrazo
Devastation: Roo (same as everyone), Gray, Waite!!!, Gibbs as captain this week
Dud Trade: No trades yet

Season so far: 3/10

 

[Jonny27]

Average score: 2093
Ranking: 1,050
Best pick: Malceski, O'Keefe
Worst pick: Well none that really stand out, Warren hasn't done all that much so far but Ill give him some time. Would have said Mitch Farmer but he got named today so he does have alright job security. Giansiracusa aswell, he needs to lift.
Player I considered, but glad I left out: Kelly, Connors, Wright, Gray.
Player I considered, and should have picked: Brown, Higgins over Gia although he will probably get injured, Silvagni, Ballantyne, Bastinac.
Can't believe I didn't consider: Boyd. Hopefully he slows down!
Devastation: Nothing yet, dont care about Riewoldt because everybody has him.
Dud Trade: Yet to make a trade yet, Roo to Goodes will be the first.
Season so far out of 10: 8/10

 

[Johnson#26]

Average score: 1982.67
Ranking: 18753
Best pick: None in particular. Kennelly and Maguire, perhaps.
Worst pick: Cox and Clark. I've already offloaded Coxy.
Player I considered, but glad I left out: Ryan Hargrave. Still rate him.
Player I considered, and should have picked: Malcheski, Hodge.
Can't believe I didn't consider: Boyd, Sandilands.
Devastation: Cox and Clark.
Dud Trade: Not yet.

Season so far out of 10: 6.5/10

 

[boonisgod]

Average score: 2095.33
Ranking: 949
Best pick: Brown over Pavlich, forking out the extra dough for Ablett
Worst pick: Hargrave and Gia, will keep them and hopefully they come good
Player I considered, but glad I left out: Mitch Clark, Masten
Player I considered and should have picked: Malceski, Gilbert
Can't believe I didn't consider: Boyd,
Devastation: Switching from Gilbert to Hargrave at the last minute
Dud Trade: Riewoldt out is my only trade so far

Season so far out of 10: 8/10

 

[M-boy]

Average score: 1900
Ranking: 47450
Best pick: Maguire, Barlow, ROK
Worst pick: Clark, Jolly, Gia, Wright, Hunt, McVeigh
Player I considered, but glad I left out: Tippett
Player I considered and should have picked: Malceski, Sandilands, Ballantyne, Peterson, Boyd
Can't believe I didn't consider: J Brown
Devastation: All of the worst picks. Riewoldt was unfortunate, but a lot easier to put right.
Dud Trade: Harvey -> Brown. Hate burning trades.
Season so far out of 10: 3/10

Not a total disaster, but it's going that way.