List Mgmt. Aisho Going Elsewhere

[The Royal Sampler]

Without the emotions but let's move on from Aish. Get someone for a 2nd rnd 2015 and see how happy Brisbane will be when Aish goes to Norf in the draft and they are left empty-handed. If they come around, we can still trade GWS 2nd 2016 plus something. Even Oxley last minute

We have the Saints' 2016 second from the Freeman deal, not GWS'.

 

[Matt_352]

Chris Pelchin who is doing Trade analysis for SEN believes we will get Aish.
He believes 2 second round picks favours us, but as Aish has "checked out" from Brisbane he believes the deal will get done

Good

 

[NT.Thunder]

Saw Aish this morning patiently waiting outside the Holden Centre

 

[DWil6]

Saw Aish this morning patiently waiting outside the Holden Centre

View attachment 187113

SAMSONITE? I was way off!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Crazy Tails]

Chris Pelchin who is doing Trade analysis for SEN believes we will get Aish.
He believes 2 second round picks favours us, but as Aish has "checked out" from Brisbane he believes the deal will get done

Don't get me wrong I want him and think it will get done but IF it didn't pan out it wouldn't be the worst thing. We'd keep two mid 20s picks this year (which we could try and turn into < 20 pick if we had time) and we have two 2nd rounders in 2016 ready to upgrade to get us back into the first round next year.

 

[PicaBoo]

We have the Saints' 2016 second from the Freeman deal, not GWS'.

Oops. Either, we got enough currency to do other trades and still come up with Aish. Got a feeling Brisbane won't be impressed unless we do something. they haven't done too bad this period

 

[Matt_352]

Saw Aish this morning patiently waiting outside the Holden Centre

View attachment 187113

Let him inside

 

[Baltimore Jack]

Don't get me wrong I want him and think it will get done but IF it didn't pan out it wouldn't be the worst thing. We'd keep two mid 20s picks this year (which we could try and turn into < 20 pick if we had time) and we have two 2nd rounders in 2016 ready to upgrade to get us back into the first round next year.

I like your outlook, I agree we are going to be ok either way

 

[Crazy Tails]

I like your outlook, I agree we are going to be ok either way

Especially when he is a nice to have, not need to have. Treloar was the prize.

 

[1892]

My guess

BL
In: Bastinac, 38, 40, 53 + 2x 2016 2nd round picks (StK, NM)
Out: 17, Aish

Coll:
In: Aish
Out: 28, 2016 2nd round pick (StK)

NM:
In: 17, 28
Out: Bastinac, 38, 40, 53, 2016 2nd round pick


Ours is straight forward, while NM get 28 for Bastinac and then swap picks this year and next for pick 17.

It would be nice if we could also bump our 47 up to Brisbane's last 3rd round pick 42, this would mean we jump StK (45) and Melb (46) who have live picks in between.

 

[Matt_352]

My guess

BL
In: Bastinac, 38, 40, 53 + 2x 2016 2nd round picks (StK, NM)
Out: 17, Aish

Coll:
In: Aish
Out: 28, 2016 2nd round pick (StK)

NM:
In: 17, 28
Out: Bastinac, 38, 40, 53, 2016 2nd round pick


Ours is straight forward, while NM get 28 for Bastinac and then swap picks this year and next for pick 17.

It would be nice if we could also bump our 47 up to Brisbane's last 3rd round pick 42, this would mean we jump StK (45) and Melb (46) who have live picks in between.

Like it

 

[DaVe86]

My guess

BL
In: Bastinac, 38, 40, 53 + 2x 2016 2nd round picks (StK, NM)
Out: 17, Aish

Coll:
In: Aish
Out: 28, 2016 2nd round pick (StK)

NM:
In: 17, 28
Out: Bastinac, 38, 40, 53, 2016 2nd round pick


Ours is straight forward, while NM get 28 for Bastinac and then swap picks this year and next for pick 17.

It would be nice if we could also bump our 47 up to Brisbane's last 3rd round pick 42, this would mean we jump StK (45) and Melb (46) who have live picks in between.

Yeah i like it.

Lions get the 2 second rounders they want, north get back into the 1st round and we keep a pick in the top 30 in this years draft.

 

[wicksy]

My guess

BL
In: Bastinac, 38, 40, 53 + 2x 2016 2nd round picks (StK, NM)
Out: 17, Aish

Coll:
In: Aish
Out: 28, 2016 2nd round pick (StK)

NM:
In: 17, 28
Out: Bastinac, 38, 40, 53, 2016 2nd round pick


Ours is straight forward, while NM get 28 for Bastinac and then swap picks this year and next for pick 17.

It would be nice if we could also bump our 47 up to Brisbane's last 3rd round pick 42, this would mean we jump StK (45) and Melb (46) who have live picks in between.

Post this on Hine's Twitter stat

EDIT: Remove North's #53 from the trade.... They're giving too much currently.

 

[Smoky]

Wouldnt we want to hand over our own second round pick for next year and keep the one from the Freeman deal?

Or aren't we allowed to?

 

[Apex36]

Wouldnt we want to hand over our own second round pick for next year and keep the one from the Freeman deal?

Or aren't we allowed to?

Not allowed.

 

[Crazy Tails]

Wouldnt we want to hand over our own second round pick for next year and keep the one from the Freeman deal?

Or aren't we allowed to?

Not allowed. If you trade your own future first (as we have) you can't trade any of your own future picks.

Open slather on future picks you've brought in from other clubs.

 

[jjsmitty8]

Wouldnt we want to hand over our own second round pick for next year and keep the one from the Freeman deal?

Or aren't we allowed to?

Not allowed. When you trade your future first, you can't trade anymore of your OWN futures. You can on-trade futures regardless of trading your own future first.

If you trade you first, you can't trade any more. If you don't trade your first, you can trade as many futures as you want.

 

[partypie]

Post this on Hine's Twitter stat

EDIT: Remove North's #53 from the trade.... They're giving too much currently.

I'd remove 53 and one of the 2016 2nd round picks personally - lions want 38 / 40 for this year's academy picks and two 2nd round picks next year for whoever comes up, so Roos only need to give up one of their 2016 2nd round picks if we're giving one as well. Lions can then take 28 to the draft as a live pick which should still have some value (or use it to meet any bids on their academy kids if needs be).

 

[ozzylion]

I’m interested to get peoples take on Aish's position in your best 22. He struggled to make Brisbane's best 22 this year and was dropped a couple of times. You guys have a stronger list so do you think he will make your team?

 

[thetruth000001]

I’m interested to get peoples take on Aish's position in your best 22. He struggled to make Brisbane's best 22 this year and was dropped a couple of times. You guys have a stronger list so do you think he will make your team?

Yes he is we have a need for outside run and polish Aish provides that.
He lost desire to play for brisbane etc etc, and didn't wanna be there with motivation to play well absolutely

 

[MAGPIE2013]

I’m interested to get peoples take on Aish's position in your best 22. He struggled to make Brisbane's best 22 this year and was dropped a couple of times. You guys have a stronger list so do you think he will make your team?

I have a full confidence that we will be able to get the best out of him just like how we did with crisp

 

[BEEG]

Any chance we through a late pick to Port for Aaron Young?

 

[Kilmo]

= Bastinic sacks Picknose. Bastinic can do whatever he wants and Picknose becomes yesterday's man. Ask Buddy...

Lol

 

[Pendles!]

I’m interested to get peoples take on Aish's position in your best 22. He struggled to make Brisbane's best 22 this year and was dropped a couple of times. You guys have a stronger list so do you think he will make your team?

It'll be interesting how they find best 22 spots for the 3 guys coming in and also Broomhead who finished the year on the sidelines. We always have bloody injuries so I'm sure there will be room for them.

 

[Crazy Tails]

Any chance we through a late pick to Port for Aaron Young?

Maybe as we were linked to him a couple of weeks ago. Is he essentially another mid though? Probably covered in that position now. I'd only do it at the death if Aish falls through.