Discussion AJL Round 20

[just_kick_it]

Please vote for the jumper you think is the better of the match up not your team’s jumper. The people that come here and make one vote vote for Brisbane or others just because it’s their team, isn’t really helping them, they haven’t won a match up and have minimal votes for so far.
You can ask to have a vote changed if you make a mistake or the jumper is changed after you vote.
If you accidentally vote for both of the options in the match up, you can post and say which option you actually vote for, if you don’t do this I will take away both vote from the match up.

Now on to the match ups.

vs

vs

vs

vs

vs

vs

vs

vs

 

[Willo #6]

GANTY, you have sydney jumper instead of WB

 

[just_kick_it]

Essendon-Im neither here or there on the Seatbelt design, but I know one thing its a hell of a lot better then the Adidas template
Carlton-Navy kit FTW.
Fremantle-The back of this jumper, on screen, just doesnot do it justice. The front is better also.
WB-Just is better IMO.
Port-Only just. A bit of bias
No Vote-Ouch. My freeking eyes
Melbourne-Easily.
North-As much as Im a fan of both of these, Im a bigger fan of North's.

 

[just_kick_it]

Yeh fixed now

 

[Willo #6]

Essendon- Nice intiative. Good way of incorporating it into the jumper.
Richmond- Sash FTW
Freo- In a close one
Geelong- Simple, classy kit
WCE- Two great jumpers. West Coast in another tight one.
NO VOTE- First time I have done this. Both poor excuses for a jumper imo.
Melbourne- As much as I love the brown & gold, can't go past Melbourne's yoke.
St.Kilda- Underated imo.

 

[Footy Legend]

Hey guys, mind if I come on and give my opinion
Essendon- don't mind this jumper, beats Collingwoods
Carlton- because of the home shorts
Freo- awesome jumper, would be better if it was the purple haze
Bulldogs- not a huge fan of Geelong's jumper
Port- two of the best, tough to pick
NONE- two embarresments, our old jumper would have annihilated this one
Melbourne- great jumper
North- like North's jumper, don't really like the Saint's

 

[Speck]

Essendon.
Carlton.
Sydney.
Geelong.
Port.
Brisbane (as bad as Brisbanes is, Adelaides is worse).
Melbourne.
St Kilda.

 

[El_Scorcho]

Crap, sorry, I thought Adelaide would be wearing their home and voted for them.

Can you change my vote from Adelaide to Brissie Ganty? Cheers.

 

[Ochre]

are brissie set for their first win?

 

[lionsman_16]

are brissie set for their first win?

Maybe. When I saw that load of crap that Adelaide are wearing its pretty hard to chose.

Essendon - dont love the seatbelt but collingwoods is worse
Richmond - always liked this one
Sydney - " "
Geelong - just
No Vote - both are too good
No Vote - both are too horrible
Melbourne - easily over b & g stripes
North

 

[aidancdaman]

Essendon-Supporting good causes, as always .
Carlton-Richmond+white shorts doesn't sit too well.
Fremantle-Because I'm listening to deep purple atm.
Western-Marginally better than the white Geelong kit.
West Coast-Can't go past the royal jumper.
Brisbane-Wins the battle of the s**t jumpers.
Melbourne-I struggle to like anything gold and brown.
St. Kilda-Don't like North with royal blue shorts.

 

[Liam Boy]

Collingwood - This jumper's growing on me, and that seatbelt looks more like a baby's bottle.
Richmond - Simply the better of the two jumpers.
Sydney - Fremantle's jumper is a mess, they need to ax the red and green.
Geelong - Better than the big animal jumper the bulldogs are wearing.
Port - I don't like West Coast's jumper that much, it looks better without the wings outline.
Brisbane - It's not that bad a jumper, I just dislike it because of lack of Fitzroy. Beats that crow head easily.
Melbourne - Great jumper with a ton of tradition against a jumper that I'm surprised lasted this long.
North Melbourne - I've just never really liked St. Kilda's jumper. Too much black, not enough red.

 

[Omegaville]

Essendon - seat belt is great
Richmond - bolder colours
Fremantle - feels sharper
Bulldogs - more striking
West Coast - feels a bit "uniquely traditional". Royal blue and gold wings clinches it
Brisbane - maroon back wins, sweeping crow loses
Melbourne - simple design
St Kilda - by the barest of margins

 

[just_kick_it]

Thanks for the input guys. Looks like Brisbane will get their first win

:EDIT: Can do TP14

 

[Sepul]

Essendon - despite the upside baby bottle, it beats Collingwood's Adidas horror
Carlton - home shorts
Sydney - red >>>> purple
Bulldogs - Geelong look better with white shorts than blue IMO, but still like the Dogs layout better
Port - there's very little that could beat their home strip
Brisbane - home shorts, in conjunction with Adelaide's bad clash strip. Still can't see why their home with white shorts clashes but anyway...
Hawks - home shorts (and the gold/brown combo looks good, bugger what everyone says!)
North - home shorts plus I still hate the black back of St. Kilda.