Alan Didak or Nathan G. Brown

[dreamteamerrrrrr]

who would u rather have in ur team?

 

[CrazyQ]

Alan, purely because of age/injury concern.

But Nathan is the better player.

 

[pieman123]

better player my ass, bcause he plays one good game a year?

 

[CrazyQ]

better player my ass, bcause he plays one good game a year?

Very similar stats.

Both dont waste possies too.

 

[TigerGlory]

better player my ass, bcause he plays one good game a year?

Didak's been average for most of his career except for this season.

Brown is more experienced and IS a better player.

 

[dreamteamerrrrrr]

Didak's been average for most of his career except for this season.

Brown is more experienced and IS a better player.

he won the copeland trophy 2 years ago....no clue

 

[Divado]

If Brown didn't break his leg this wouldn't be close. Brown is a better player but I'd take Didak for the future.

 

[TigerGlory]

he won the copeland trophy 2 years ago....no clue

The only thing Didak has on his side is age.

So what if hes won the Collingwood Best and Fairest?

I suppose your Best and Fairest has more relevance than anybody elses B&F Trophys?

Brown is an All Australian. Didak is a prick.

 

[dreamteamerrrrrr]

The only thing Didak has on his side is age.

So what if hes won the Collingwood Best and Fairest?

I suppose your Best and Fairest has more relevance than anybody elses B&F Trophys?

Brown is an All Australian. Didak is a prick.

no our b&f isn't more relevant...but the guy said didak has only played well this year...thats how its relevant

in conclusion: ur an idiot

 

[TigerGlory]

no our b&f isn't more relevant...but the guy said didak has only played well this year...thats how its relevant

in conclusion: ur an idiot

Hes only been universally recognised this season for being a reasonable footballer this season.

Quite simply, he hasnt been a gamebreaker until this season.

 

[kendrick]

who would ppl rather at their peak?

Brown>>>>>>>>>daylight>>>>>>didak

brown is all class

 

[CrazyQ]

Hes only been universally recognised this season for being a reasonable footballer this season.

Quite simply, he hasnt been a gamebreaker until this season.

Quite wrong.

Averaged 18 possies and 1.8 goals a game and was AA IIRC.

 

[TigerGlory]

Quite wrong.

Averaged 18 possies and 1.8 goals a game and was AA IIRC.

2006. Correct. Didnt research prior to this, so wasnt exactly sure.

Still, Brown is a better player.

 

[jonesy86]

If Brown didn't break his leg this wouldn't be close. Brown is a better player but I'd take Didak for the future.

If Didak didn't tear his ACL towards the end of his AA season in '06...

 

[smiddaz123]

So what if hes won the Collingwood Best and Fairest?

It means he HAS had other good seasons you total idiot.

Brown is an All Australian. Didak is a prick.

Didak is All Australian too.

You couldn't be more wrong if you tried.

 

[patto_man]

If Didak didn't tear his ACL towards the end of his AA season in '06...

i think a broken leg is worse than a tear

 

[Windas_Magic]

Brown is a much better player than Didak

 

[yulong]

Brown any day...Didak is good but if both players where at their peak no comparison

 

[dyl_tigerman]

this is bo comparison:

THE BROWN MAN by far...
he wins them off hes own boot... look at the game today and that magic game against collingwood a few years back where he kicke five goals in the last quarter and won us the game....
does any collingwood supporter remember that and btw when has didak done that

 

[hellfire]

If Brown didn't break his leg this wouldn't be close.

No doubt about that. If Brown had've kept going the way he was, he would've been close to the best player in the league. Right now, it's Didak for me on 2008 form (not by too much though), and given the age discrepancy, it's Didak easily.

 

[tigers_of_old_08]

Brown >>>>> Didak

 

[jimmy.h]

Didak. He is one of the few players in the competition I would really like to see play for Geelong.

Still think he is a ********, but he's a very, very good footballer.