All-Australian selections are overrated

[Bulldog Joe]

All awards have inbuilt bias of some nature.
The coaches award would have more credibility if the rated every player on the ground not just their best 5.
Brownlow has issues because it is just best 3

 

[txbyhull]

Strange example to pick given even though Wilkie is awesome, Gov was arguably the best key back of a decade.

I think the issue I see with AA selection is the over representation of centre square midfielders. They pick them in every ****ing position?