I don't mind the talls on your list. Frawley, Garland and Watts should be fine down back. Clark, Dawes, Hogan and Howe could be really good.
The midfield is obviously the worry but also probably the easiest to fix. You already have Jones, Viney, Trengrove, Sylvia and Toumpas. Use the top pick on the best mid available, use your second rounder and third rounders on mids from good clubs. No idea who is available but you could probably get a nice kid like Savage from Hawthorn for a third rounder and a nice 3 year deal, the way Sydney poaches their players. Then you see who you can shake loose in free agency, maybe one more in the PSD.
I apologise if this sounds like optimistic rubbish but I don't think it's unrealistic that with some nice draft picks, no salary cap pressures, the opportunity to cement a spot at senior level as incentives that you could potentially shake out maybe 3 decent mids plus the blue chip 1st round choice. Add that to what is already there, a nice positive coach like Ratten or Harvey and Melbourne could be at least back to where Brisbane are now which is perfectly average.
The midfield is obviously the worry but also probably the easiest to fix. You already have Jones, Viney, Trengrove, Sylvia and Toumpas. Use the top pick on the best mid available, use your second rounder and third rounders on mids from good clubs. No idea who is available but you could probably get a nice kid like Savage from Hawthorn for a third rounder and a nice 3 year deal, the way Sydney poaches their players. Then you see who you can shake loose in free agency, maybe one more in the PSD.
I apologise if this sounds like optimistic rubbish but I don't think it's unrealistic that with some nice draft picks, no salary cap pressures, the opportunity to cement a spot at senior level as incentives that you could potentially shake out maybe 3 decent mids plus the blue chip 1st round choice. Add that to what is already there, a nice positive coach like Ratten or Harvey and Melbourne could be at least back to where Brisbane are now which is perfectly average.