MRP / Trib. All Things Richmond MRP/Trib

[Muddiemoose]

Was he cited?

No match day report from the umps but the MRO will pick it up no doubt

Probably 2 weeks
Will be graded as head impact that automatically gets upscaled due to high impact

 

[tigs2010]

the MRO will pick it up no doubt

 

[tigs2010]

Should Astbury have been rubbed out?

https://www.dailytelegraph.com.au/sport/afl/cotchin2/video/944aaf296d0268973a79347e33d45b06

How did Houli not get suspended for pushing him into it even though he took another 8 steps after

 

[sabso]

No match day report from the umps but the MRO will pick it up no doubt

Probably 2 weeks
Will be graded as head impact that automatically gets upscaled due to high impact

I actually had no idea who Michael Christian was until this point

Collingwood premiership player

AFL Tables - Essendon v Collingwood - Sat, 6-Oct-1990 2:30 PM - Match Stats

Coll no 19 in that gf has an interesting name as well

 

[Danog]

Love the club coming out and saying "We were gonna rest him for 2 weeks anyway lol"

 

[Rubber Hips]

Houston only gets 2 weeks for a deliberate elbow to the head…after recently serving 5 week suspension for a similar incident


If it was one of ours….corrupt Christian would have issued the severest penalty without doubt

 

[Meteoric Rise]

Going by Christian’s cry baby excuse making over his failure to deal with Ginbey even inadequately, that Dusty footage should have been too grainy for him.

 

[ShereKhan]

How quickly we forget [emoji638][emoji[emoji6[emoji640][emoji638]][emoji640][emoji6[emoji640][emoji638]]][emoji637][emoji[emoji6[emoji640][emoji638]][emoji640][emoji639]].

Give me an example of one incident prior to Cotchin where a player was going for the ball and wins the ball but due to damage to his opponent is suspended. I agree Cotchin would be suspended now … but if you can come up with a single example prior to that incident I’d like to hear about it.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[ShereKhan]

Show us another player suspended before or after Cotchin for making contact with another player contesting a ground ball where they both arrived almost simultaneously at the ball. Two since that spring to mind that did not result in suspensions were David McKay on Hunter Clark & Joel Selwood on Rhyan Mansell, the latter not even cited.

This is leaving aside the fact that there is strong evidence Shiel was not concussed by Cotchin(passed a HIA immediately after, was concussed in a later collision.)

But let’s put both of those telling points aside and assume for one minute the Cotchin case went our way. How many biased decisions would have to be made against Richmond subsequently without any obvious ones going our way before you would think that the Cotchin case no longer means we can rule out unfair bias? How many years of opponents maiming our players without penalty? How many games lost hinging on a never before or since seen umpiring or ARC decision(we are 0-3?) How many complete coincidences like 3 of our players cited for rubbish that was thrown out by the Tribunal from one single match? How many years worst off on the free kick table? How many Free Agent compo rulings that we seem to fall just the wrong side of? How many times the most 50m penalties for non obvious infringements that never seem to get paid our way with the same level of enthusiasm? How many rules need to be made to thwart our competitive advantage over the other clubs & hand an advantage to our main rivals? Why exactly do you think the AFL has significantly loosened the purse strings post Covid everywhere else bar the soft cap?

And how long before you realise that it doesn’t take a massive industry wide conspiracy to cause all of this? Most of it can be heavily influenced by a single position - the footy ops manager, and a small amount of people that person works with daily(who may not even be aware they are being unduly influenced.). Who filled that position during the period in question? Who succeeded them when they were appointed Geelong CEO? Which club has known tentacles in fixturing, auditing, and clearly great contacts in AFL Footy Ops? And which club has none of these things and had its CEO overlooked for AFL CEO despite just about universal acceptance that he was the most suitable candidate?

Wake. Up. And. Smell. The. Sewer. My. Friend. It ****ing stinks.

There’s no planned or spoken conspiracy. It’s just a subconscious bias that was brought to the surface when Richmond became successful. The footy world wasn’t ready for a successful Richmond … it made people uncomfortable, particularly Geelong people who went from laughing at Richmond for 30-years to becoming their finals bunnies.

So Steve Hocking would personally despise Richmond for what they did to his club, no different to other supporters - that’s a very normal emotion.

So when there’s an opportunity to prevent Richmond from emerging back to the top, which was so uncomfortable for four years for basically the entire industry, then we don’t get the rub of the green.

Umpiring/MRO/tribunal etc… everyone follows a footy team - anyone who doesn’t follow Richmond has an emotional need born out of our dynasty to do us no favours wherever possible.

That’s why the clear bias started only once we started winning.



Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[tigerisland]

Mansell’s problem is that he is not a good bloke. Tom Stewart is and so he only got 4 weeks for knocking out Prestia. Totally off the ball, completely pre meditated.
And of course Dangerfield never got anything for knocking Vlaustin out in a GF. That one was even more confounding.
We must do good bloke training for all our players.

 

[T4P]

Love the club coming out and saying "We were gonna rest him for 2 weeks anyway lol"

Basically telling the fans 'calm down, this is why we aren't appealing further'

 

[The_Kraken]

Unsurprising that none of the toxic trolls on this forum will do anything except whinge and play the victim.

The club and the players don’t whine and act like victims; they get on with working towards success.

You want to be a nuffy, knock yourself out.

 

[beema limapep]

Bump. Vlastuin confirmed broken nose.

Voss should get 4-6 weeks.

 

[tigs2010]

Bump. Vlastuin confirmed broken nose.

Voss should get 4-6 weeks.

Got 3 brah

 

[beema limapep]

Got 3 brah

He got ****ing WHAT?

 

[beema limapep]

 

[tigs2010]

View attachment 2283324

Ooze said he puts his head in places he shouldnt. Does he mean in the line of swinging haymakers?

Balta should have used Ooze as his defence counsel.

 

[Do the Dew]

Voss swings a fist into Vlastuin's face = 3 weeks.

Mansell pushes a guy = 3 weeks.

But but but having a 1-person MRP will remove inconsistencies...

 

[JAKLAUGHING]

Did Bolton get reprimanded for show boating with the footy when he played with us?!

 

[Meteoric Rise]

Did Bolton get reprimanded for show boating with the footy when he played with us?!

Only by the media.

 

[JAKLAUGHING]

Only by the media.

Notice no a word said about rioli's show boat agin the hawks!

 

[Truetiger]

Notice no a word said about rioli's show boat agin the hawks!

Am I the only one who believes it’s good for the game? Haha.

 

[tigs2010]

Notice no a word said about rioli's show boat agin the hawks!

You haven't been paying attention then lol

 

[JAKLAUGHING]

You haven't been paying attention then lol

So the AFL Old Boys Club mentioned something about it?!?

 

[tigs2010]

So the AFL Old Boys Club mentioned something about it?!?

Yes, Footy Classified had a full segment about it.