All things ROK (We don't need multiple threads)

[Team Mo']

Re: O'Keefe keen to go to Carlton

because were cheating the salary cap???

yes because we must of been all the guys who got us to 5 bottom 5 finishes in a row piles of money. I don't know how we can have any room what with all the stars we are paying.

 

[Marc Shmurf 3]

Re: O'Keefe keen to go to Carlton

HBF couldn't agree with you more.... if only more people could open their eyes, and if we have pick 12 as well...

Lets hope Swanny can get the deal done and then pick up Warnock in the PSD, it would nearly be as good as last trade week/draft

In: O'Keefe, Warnock, pick 12 (+24 and another traded in player)
Out: pick 6 and another player we send to Sydney (Bentick etc)

I know which one I would prefer

Still think there is a real chance that one of O'Keefe/Warnock will come to us via the PSD... Although that deal does look tantalising...

 

[OneEyedHawk]

Re: O'Keefe keen to go to Carlton

Pick 6 for ROK + Pick 12 would be a win for you guys. ROK is a superstar, and still could have 4+ yrs left.

I'm still clinging to the hope that we can snare him for pick 16, and maybe a fringe player. Whoever can add ROK to their line-up next year can count themselves very lucky IMO.

 

[Premiership Quarter]

Re: O'Keefe keen to go to Carlton

need to make sure we get the warnock deal done first, or they might start asking for pick 12 for warnock then all we have is pick 24. I wouldnt be happy if we didnt at least have pick 12.

 

[Marc Shmurf 3]

Re: O'Keefe keen to go to Carlton

I cant believe how short memories some people have...

Watch the Carlton vs sydney game this year and see how bloody good O'Keefe is... He single handedly got them over the line...

If we can get O'Keefe + Pick 12 for pick 6 and another player and Warnock for pick 24, we would have pulled off the greatest trading coup EVER...

 

[Team Mo']

Re: O'Keefe keen to go to Carlton

I cant believe how short memories some people have...

Watch the Carlton vs sydney game this year and see how bloody good O'Keefe is... He single handedly got them over the line...

If we can get O'Keefe + Pick 12 for pick 6 and another player and Warnock for pick 24, we would have pulled off the greatest trading coup EVER...

cough*Judd*cough

 

[HyperAgressiveDonk]

Re: O'Keefe keen to go to Carlton

I cant believe how short memories some people have...

Watch the Carlton vs sydney game this year and see how bloody good O'Keefe is... He single handedly got them over the line...

If we can get O'Keefe + Pick 12 for pick 6 and another player and Warnock for pick 24, we would have pulled off the greatest trading coup EVER...

Wow don't get carried away mate. O'Keefe isn't even in the top 30 players in the comp. He is very good but not that good mate. He isn't the answer to Carltons problems. Take a punt, keep pick 6 and try and pick up a player like Selwood

 

[bourbons]

Re: O'Keefe keen to go to Carlton

Just depends what you think is the best course of action.. stock up now and try to pinch a premiership in 2010.. or keep building a list full of gun youngsters and gear up for chance at a couple from about 2012 - 16.

Personally I'd go with the 2nd option.

 

[Team Mo']

Re: O'Keefe keen to go to Carlton

Wow don't get carried away mate. O'Keefe isn't even in the top 30 players in the comp. He is very good but not that good mate. He isn't the answer to Carltons problems. Take a punt, keep pick 6 and try and pick up a player like Selwood

not in top 30? Joking right?

 

[juddola]

Re: O'Keefe keen to go to Carlton

Just depends what you think is the best course of action.. stock up now and try to pinch a premiership in 2010.. or keep building a list full of gun youngsters and gear up for chance at a couple from about 2012 - 16.

Personally I'd go with the 2nd option.

why not just go 2010-2016.lol

 

[Bronx Bomber]

Re: O'Keefe keen to go to Carlton

I cant believe how short memories some people have...

Watch the Carlton vs sydney game this year and see how bloody good O'Keefe is... He single handedly got them over the line...[/SIZE]

29 touches, 10 marks, 3 goals.....yeah decent game

 

[HyperAgressiveDonk]

Re: O'Keefe keen to go to Carlton

not in top 30? Joking right?

Well he wasn't in the All Australian team this year. He is good but don't over-rate and over value him. He is not worth 600k a season

 

[Team Mo']

Re: O'Keefe keen to go to Carlton

Well he wasn't in the All Australian team this year. He is good but don't over-rate and over value him. He is not worth 600k a season

Probably not. If he is asking for that then maybe we might just look elsewhere.

 

[Stig O'Hara]

Re: O'Keefe keen to go to Carlton

If it is any gauge.

http://www.news.com.au/heraldsun/sport/afl/story/0,26576,24474796-19742,00.html

COLLINGWOOD have traded Rhyce Shaw and their fourth-round pick (No.61) to Sydney for the Swans' third-round round selection (no.46).

 

[Marc Shmurf 3]

Re: O'Keefe keen to go to Carlton

Well he wasn't in the All Australian team this year. He is good but don't over-rate and over value him. He is not worth 600k a season

Id have him ahead of Harley thats for bloody sure, but 600p/y is a bit too much i agree

 

[bluesx10withjudd]

Re: O'Keefe keen to go to Carlton

i think we should go gun ho on picking up okeefe if freo dont want to give us robbie...it would complete our forward line... and continue developing kreuzer and hampson. even if they get smashed in the ruck our midfield is strong enough to compensate........forget warnock

 

[Athomas]

Re: O'Keefe keen to go to Carlton

Hmmm. 24 and Bentick for ROK, 40 and Fisher for Warnock

Naaaa this is gonna be a strange 90 minutes, i'm confident we will get someone, we love trading.

 

[Warsaw]

Re: O'Keefe keen to go to Carlton

Hmmm. 24 and Bentick for ROK, 40 and Fisher for Warnock

Naaaa this is gonna be a strange 90 minutes, i'm confident we will get someone, we love trading.

It's be such an anti climax if we didn't get anyone.
We've got a reputation to uphold people!

 

[HyperAgressiveDonk]

Re: O'Keefe keen to go to Carlton

Id have him ahead of Harley thats for bloody sure, but 600p/y is a bit too much i agree

I hope you gus pick him up and become a legitimate top 4 chance in 2010 or 2011. Would love to see big blockbuster Hawks and Blues games just like the 80s

 

[Marc Shmurf 3]

Now for O'Keefe in the PSD...

This is a real possibility now... I just don’t see how he would go back to Sydney and Harford spoke to him and he said he was adamant he wanted to come back to Victoria...

If we can get Warnock for pick 24 and some shrapnel and O'Keefe in the PSD whilst drafting Ziebell/ Hartlett/ Hurley/ Yarren what a wonderful way to end the year...

Well done Swanny, Icke and Co...

 

[[ToTTi]]

Re: O'Keefe keen to go to Carlton

Looks like Essendon will nab him in the PSD now, surely they'd have the cap space to fit him in...

 

[[ToTTi]]

Re: Now for O'Keefe in the PSD...

What about Essendon??

KB is already all over this...

 

[HBF]

Re: Now for O'Keefe in the PSD...

Could be a possibility Shmurf. Would love to get him in the PSD.

 

[one_twelve112]

Re: Now for O'Keefe in the PSD...

I doubt we could fit both ROK and Warnock in the salary...my guess is it was one or the other and we got the right man and at pretty good price

 

[Marc Shmurf 3]

Re: Now for O'Keefe in the PSD...

I doubt we could fit both ROK and Warnock in the salary...my guess is it was one or the other and we got the right man and at pretty good price

picks wise yes... $$$$$ he better be worth it...

Swanny seems to think that there would still be plenty of room even if we got both