Competitions All Time Draft Voting Thread

[Defacto]

Voted for defactos.
Hard choice over barrells and chills.

you're a great man!!! we need more of you

 

[Mowman]

Voted for defactos.
Hard choice over barrells and chills.

Did the same could you imagine Mc Adam & Milne working together with Roo and big Garry Sidebottom, WOW

 

[ST ROMNAR]

After much evaluation I found a very clear margin to the team of 12Chill.
Enjoyed thread greatly, as with competitions of this type many great players as well as many good players were not selected however I am sure supporters
will have enhanced their knowledge of the players and history of our great club.

 

[Defacto]

Did the same could you imagine Mc Adam & Milne working together with Roo and big Garry Sidebottom, WOW

would be amazing!!!!!

 

[STK2020]

Well done everybody ,
I picked Saintkildaman's team but very hard to choose .
Loved the lock down ability and run his team has in defence and is well served in the ruck department , hard working midfielders , forward line maybe needed another tall target but the strength down back would keep opposition score honest .

 

[St Kilda Death]

saintkildaman
Love your centre line.
Also nice defensive lines.
The rest, other than burkey, well...
Dunstan can't compare to the greats yet, but hopefully he proves worthy of that spot on your team in years to come!

 

[Barrels]

Reckon I'm getting shafted!

 

[Kilroy]

Reckon I'm getting shafted!

Had your best 22 in the Grand Final, but admit the outcome I imagined might have been a little biased.
The midfield I think you would have won. In fact the only lines where I figured he had you were your forward line and your half-back line.
Had blinkers on when it came to your backs against A2R's forwards "Georgy" Young, Kevin Roberts and "Stevie" Theodore (with their lack of height).
But the result in the end came down to actual performance over players' careers.

The breakdown...
Team of the Century - UB 1 vs A2R 4
Hall of Fame - UB 4 vs A2R 5
Best and Fairests - UB 4 players for 7 titles overall vs A2R 8 players for 15 titles overall
Leading goal kicking - UB 6 players for 11 titles overall vs A2R 4 players for 14 titles overall
You got him on Brownlows 3 to 1.

Other teams seemed more affected by the "recency effect", perhaps due to focussing on the modern type of player.
Reckon you were a bit stiff.

 

[Barrels]

Had your best 22 in the Grand Final, but admit the outcome I imagined might have been a little biased.
The midfield I think you would have won. In fact the only lines where I figured he had you were your forward line and your half-back line.
Had blinkers on when it came to your backs against A2R's forwards "Georgy" Young, Kevin Roberts and "Stevie" Theodore (with their lack of height).
But the result in the end came down to actual performance over players' careers.

The breakdown...
Team of the Century - UB 1 vs A2R 4
Hall of Fame - UB 4 vs A2R 5
Best and Fairests - UB 4 players for 7 titles overall vs A2R 8 players for 15 titles overall
Leading goal kicking - UB 6 players for 11 titles overall vs A2R 4 players for 14 titles overall
You got him on Brownlows 3 to 1.

Other teams seemed more affected by the "recency effect", perhaps due to focussing on the modern type of player.
Reckon you were a bit stiff.

Bah. Robbed!

 

[Sunshine Saint]

Loved the thread and the player reviews written by each team selector.

Gave my vote to 12Chili. A great team and see it as better than all others in this.

 

[12Chill]

Is it finished?

 

[Kilroy]

Is it finished?

No, Uncle Barrels has gone into meltdown and Bigfooty will never be the same again.

 

[TN25]

VOTING CLOSED

Congratulations 12Chill on winning. Defacto came second and Daddy_Barrels rounded out the top 3

 

[Barrels]

No, Uncle Barrels has gone into meltdown and Bigfooty will never be the same again.

 

[Defacto]

VOTING CLOSED

Congratulations 12Chill on winning. Defacto came second and Daddy_Barrels rounded out the top 3

finishing 2nd after such a strong start...sounds like i have the most st kilda side of the lot

 

[12Chill]

finishing 2nd after such a strong start...sounds like i have the most st kilda side of the lot

You were the second the whole way I thought.

 

[Defacto]

You were the second the whole way I thought.

well there goes that angle

 

[Kilroy]

30 seconds left! Halfy in the Back Pocket plays on and kicks down the line to a contest. They all fly! Saintkildaman!! - seizing the moment! Great grab!! ... dying seconds of the Grand Final .... one point the difference!!

Plays on quickly, handball to Armitage running by. Spots a lead from Goodie through the middle and hits him lace out on the chest. They’re on here! THEY'RE ON HERE!! One last roll of the dice for the Saints?

Short pass to Feisty on the wing in space. 15 seconds! He plays on - one bounce, two bounces. Kicks long into the 50. Defacto flew high, he can’t mark, but brings it to ground into the path of the running Chill.

Soccer off the ground to the top of the goal-square. 5 seconds!! Barrels down low, scoops one handed. He turns! Puts boot to ball!! ...... It’s high!! ..... It’s coming back!!!! ..... IT’S COMING BACK!!!!!!!!! .....

 

[Barrels]

Soccer off the ground to the top of the goal-square. 5 seconds!! Barrels down low.... *TWANG* "He's done a hamstring!! Geez, we heard that from here Darce"... "Haw, haw, we sure did Brian"..

EFA

 

[Kilroy]

Soccer off the ground to the top of the goal-square. 5 seconds!! Barrels down low ...*TWANG* “He’s done a hamstring!! Geez, we heard that from here Darce” ... “Haw, haw, we sure did Brian”...
....“CHILL KEPT GOING!!! .......TOE-POKE!!!! ....... GOOOOAAAAALLLLLLLLL!!!!!!!!!!!!!
"Oh s**t, Darce!! .... I just soiled meself!"

Edited just for the sheer unbridled joy of it!

 

[Defacto]

Just wanted to check if I finished ahead of uncle barrels?

 

[Barrels]

Just wanted to check if I finished ahead of uncle barrels?

Flog.

 

[felsty]

Flog.

List.

 

[Barrels]

List.

 

[Defacto]

Flog.

hehehehe <3