All Time XI's.

Remove this Banner Ad

I'm bored, so I'm compiling an "all time XI" for every test nation.

Australia

1. Justin Langer (45.27)
2. Matthew Hayden (50.73)
3. Don Bradman (99.94)
4. Ricky Ponting (51.84)
5. Steve Waugh (51.06/37.44)
6. Allan Border (50.56/39.1, c)
7. Adam Gilchrist (47.6/4.33d, +)
8. Keith Miller (36.97/22.97)
9. Shane Warne (17.32/25.41)
10. Dennis Lillee (13.71/23.92)
11. Glenn McGrath (7.36/21.64)

12th man Greg Chappell

Langer and Hayden have the 2nd most runs of any opening combination in test cricket, and the 3rd most century stands so opening with them was obvious. Bradman picks himself. The middle order was tough to split between Ponting, Waugh, Border and Chappell so I went with the two genuine bowling options and the best Australian bat I've ever seen. Gilly also picks himself. I almost went Davidson ahead of Miller to provide variety but Miller was a better bat which edged him ahead (which is a legitimate tie breaker for players like them), and Lillee/McGrath pick themselves along with Warne.

Bangladesh

1. Tamim Iqbal (40.34)
2. Mominul Haque (51.66)
3. Habibul Bashar (30.87)
4. Mahmudullah (31.17)
5. Shakib Al Hasan (39.05/32, c)
6. Nasir Hossain (37.34)
7. Mushfiqur Rahim (31.97/1.86d, +)
8. Mohammed Rafique (18.57/40.76)
9. Mashrafe Mortaza (12.85/41.52)
10. Taijul Islam (11.85/32.13)
11. Shahadat Hossain (10.01/51.83)

12th man Enamul Haque jr

This side really picks itself with 7 blokes averaging over 30 with the bat. Hossain might be controversial, but he's the second best seamer they've produced.

England

1. Herbert Sutcliffe (60.73)
2. Jack Hobbs (56.94)
3. Eddie Paynter (59.23)
4. Wally Hammond (58.45/37.8)
5. Ken Barrington (58.45)
6. Dennis Compton (50.06/56.4)
7. Les Ames (40.56/2.06d, +)
8. Jim Laker (14.08/21.24)
9. Fred Trueman (13.81/21.57)
10. Frank Tyson (10.95/18.56)
11. Sydney Barnes (8.06/16.43)

12th man Harold Larwood

Sutcliffe and Hobbs have the highest average opening partnership in the history of test cricket and the second most century opening stands. The next three pick themselves with their averages, and then I chose Compton with his ability to bowl part time along with his batting average. Ames averages a lot more thank Knott as a keeper/bat. Laker, Trueman, Tyson, Barnes are four great bowlers, Larwood extremely unlucky to miss out.

India

1. Sunil Gavaskar (51.12)
2. Virender Sehwag (49.43)
3. Rahul Dravid (52.63)
4. Sachin Tendulkar (53.78)
5. Vinod Kambli (54.2)
6. Virat Kohli (50.1)
7. MS Dohni (38.09/3.27d, c, +)
8. Kapil Dev (31.05/29.64)
9. Anil Kumble (17.77/29.65)
10. Zaheer Khan (11.95/32.94)
11. Bishan Bedi (8.98/28.71)

12th man Harbhajan Singh

6 of the top 7 pick themselves, and I went with Virat because of his superb average and he will be a guarantee by the end of his career IMO. Kapil Dev and Zaheer are the two seamers that have done anything for India hence their inclusion and then Kumble and Bedi are their two greatest spinners.

New Zealand

1. Mark Richardson (44.77)
2. Glenn Turner (44.64)
3. Kane Williamson (49.44/38.24)
4. Ross Taylor (46.7)
5. Martin Crowe (45.36)
6. Stephen Fleming (40.06, c)
7. BJ Watling (38.69/3.3, +)
8. Daniel Vettori (30/34.36)
9. Sir Richard Hadlee (27.16/27.29)
10. Dion Nash (23.51/28.48)
11. Bruce Taylor (20.4/26.6)

12th man Shane Bond

This side may not have anyone that averages over 50 but it has an advantage in the fact that their #11 averages 20 with the bat and has multiple test tons. Their bowling attack isn't as strong as England or South Africa but it's still right up there.

Pakistan

1. Saeed Anwar (45.52)
2. Azhar Ali (47.07)
3. Javed Miandad (52.57)
4. Yousuf Khan (53.06)
5. Mohammed Yousuf (52.29)
6. Inzamam-ul-Haque (50.16)
7. Sarfraz Ahmed (42.34/3.12d, +)
8. Imran Khan (37.69/22.81, c)
9. Wasim Akram (22.64/23.62)
10. Saqlain Mushtaq (14.48/29.83)
11. Waqar Younis (10.2/23.56)

12th man Shoaib Akhtar

This side largely picks itself with only two openers averaging over 45 in the countries history plus four middle order players who average 50. Sarfraz is the best batsman/keeper they've produced IMO so he gets the nod.

South Africa

1. Barry Richards (72.57)
2. Graeme Smith (48.7, c)
3. Hashim Amla (49.45)
4. Graeme Pollock (60.97)
5. Jacques Kallis (55.37/32.65)
6. AB de Villiers (50.46/2.09d, +)
7. Aubrey Faulkner (40.79/26.58)
8. Shaun Pollock (32.31/23.11)
9. Hugh Tayfield (16.9/25.91)
10. Dale Steyn (14/22.3)
11. Allan Donald (10.68/22.25)

12th man Dudley Nourse

Nourse was unlucky not to break into that incredible top 6, and unfortunately Aubrey's bowling puts him well ahead of him. Amla is the only player there to have played his career out at #3, Kallis and Pollock were mostly batting at 4 or 5 for South Africa. This is probably the second best side out of the lot.

Sri Lanka

1. Sanath Jayasuriya (40.07/34.34)
2. Marvin Atapattu (39.02)
3. Kumar Sangakkara (57.4)
4. Mahela Jayawardena (49.84, c)
5. Aravinda de Silva (42.97)
6. Angelo Matthews (46.74/54.38)
7. Dinesh Chandimal (42.3/2.24)
8. Chaminda Vaas (24.32/29.58)
9. Rangan Herath (14.81/28.92)
10. Lasith Malinga (11.45/33.15)
11. Muttiah Muralitharan (11.67/22.72)

12th man Tillakaratne Dilshan

The only one I'm not sure about here is Dilshan vs Atapattu. The bowlers pick themselves, 4 of the 5 bowlers who have taken over 100 wickets for Sri Lanka.

West Indies

1. Gordon Greenidge (44.72, c)
2. Desmond Haynes (42.29)
3. George Headley (60.83)
4. Everton Weekes (58.81)
5. Garry Sobers (57.78/34.03)
6. Brian Lara (53.17)
7. Clyde Walcott (56.68/1.27d, +)
8. Malcolm Marshall (18.85/20.94)
9. Joel Garner (12.44/20.97)
10. Curtley Ambrose (12.4/20.99)
11. Colin Croft (10.93/23.3)

12th man Michael Holding

This is a seriously impressive XI, Greenidge and Haynes have the most century opening partnerships in the history of the game, then that middle order have 5 players averaging over 53. Their four pronged pace attacks were legendary. This would be in my top 4 along with Australia, England and South Africa.

Zimbabwe

1. Brendan Taylor (34.72)
2. Grant Flower (29.54)
3. Andy Flower (51.54, c)
4. Dave Houghton (42.84)
5. Murray Goodwin (42.84)
6. Craig Ervine (33.5)
7. Tatenda Taibu (30.31/2.21d, +)
8. Paul Strang (27.06/36.02)
9. Heath Streak (22.35/28.14)
10. Ray Price (8.7/36.06)
11. Henry Olonga (5.41/38.52)

12th man Guy Whittall

Easy side to pick considering that there are only 6 players who average over 30 with the bat and Flower is an opener.
 
Arthur Morris is the finest opening batsman in Australian Test history. Considering WW2 consumed the best years of his cricketing life, his record is phenomenal. And selecting Steve Waugh and Allan Border ahead of Greg Chappell is tantamount to sacrilege.
Hayden and Langer's record speaks for itself. Many people would argue that Ponsford, Hayden, Lawry, Trumper, Simpson and Morris have all got claims to being the best. Waugh and Border were fantastic players, just because you would select Chappell ahead of them doesn't make my opinion wrong.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

I'm bored, so I'm compiling an "all time XI" for every test nation.

Australia

1. Justin Langer (45.27)
2. Matthew Hayden (50.73)
3. Don Bradman (99.94)
4. Ricky Ponting (51.84)
5. Steve Waugh (51.06/37.44)
6. Allan Border (50.56/39.1, c)
7. Adam Gilchrist (47.6/4.33d, +)
8. Keith Miller (36.97/22.97)
9. Shane Warne (17.32/25.41)
10. Dennis Lillee (13.71/23.92)
11. Glenn McGrath (7.36/21.64)

12th man Greg Chappell

Langer and Hayden have the 2nd most runs of any opening combination in test cricket, and the 3rd most century stands so opening with them was obvious. Bradman picks himself. The middle order was tough to split between Ponting, Waugh, Border and Chappell so I went with the two genuine bowling options and the best Australian bat I've ever seen. Gilly also picks himself. I almost went Davidson ahead of Miller to provide variety but Miller was a better bat which edged him ahead (which is a legitimate tie breaker for players like them), and Lillee/McGrath pick themselves along with Warne.

Bangladesh

1. Tamim Iqbal (40.34)
2. Mominul Haque (51.66)
3. Habibul Bashar (30.87)
4. Mahmudullah (31.17)
5. Shakib Al Hasan (39.05/32, c)
6. Nasir Hossain (37.34)
7. Mushfiqur Rahim (31.97/1.86d, +)
8. Mohammed Rafique (18.57/40.76)
9. Mashrafe Mortaza (12.85/41.52)
10. Taijul Islam (11.85/32.13)
11. Shahadat Hossain (10.01/51.83)

12th man Enamul Haque jr

This side really picks itself with 7 blokes averaging over 30 with the bat. Hossain might be controversial, but he's the second best seamer they've produced.

England

1. Herbert Sutcliffe (60.73)
2. Jack Hobbs (56.94)
3. Eddie Paynter (59.23)
4. Wally Hammond (58.45/37.8)
5. Ken Barrington (58.45)
6. Dennis Compton (50.06/56.4)
7. Les Ames (40.56/2.06d, +)
8. Jim Laker (14.08/21.24)
9. Fred Trueman (13.81/21.57)
10. Frank Tyson (10.95/18.56)
11. Sydney Barnes (8.06/16.43)

12th man Harold Larwood

Sutcliffe and Hobbs have the highest average opening partnership in the history of test cricket and the second most century opening stands. The next three pick themselves with their averages, and then I chose Compton with his ability to bowl part time along with his batting average. Ames averages a lot more thank Knott as a keeper/bat. Laker, Trueman, Tyson, Barnes are four great bowlers, Larwood extremely unlucky to miss out.

India

1. Sunil Gavaskar (51.12)
2. Virender Sehwag (49.43)
3. Rahul Dravid (52.63)
4. Sachin Tendulkar (53.78)
5. Vinod Kambli (54.2)
6. Virat Kohli (50.1)
7. MS Dohni (38.09/3.27d, c, +)
8. Kapil Dev (31.05/29.64)
9. Anil Kumble (17.77/29.65)
10. Zaheer Khan (11.95/32.94)
11. Bishan Bedi (8.98/28.71)

12th man Harbhajan Singh

6 of the top 7 pick themselves, and I went with Virat because of his superb average and he will be a guarantee by the end of his career IMO. Kapil Dev and Zaheer are the two seamers that have done anything for India hence their inclusion and then Kumble and Bedi are their two greatest spinners.

New Zealand

1. Mark Richardson (44.77)
2. Glenn Turner (44.64)
3. Kane Williamson (49.44/38.24)
4. Ross Taylor (46.7)
5. Martin Crowe (45.36)
6. Stephen Fleming (40.06, c)
7. BJ Watling (38.69/3.3, +)
8. Daniel Vettori (30/34.36)
9. Sir Richard Hadlee (27.16/27.29)
10. Dion Nash (23.51/28.48)
11. Bruce Taylor (20.4/26.6)

12th man Shane Bond

This side may not have anyone that averages over 50 but it has an advantage in the fact that their #11 averages 20 with the bat and has multiple test tons. Their bowling attack isn't as strong as England or South Africa but it's still right up there.

Pakistan

1. Saeed Anwar (45.52)
2. Azhar Ali (47.07)
3. Javed Miandad (52.57)
4. Yousuf Khan (53.06)
5. Mohammed Yousuf (52.29)
6. Inzamam-ul-Haque (50.16)
7. Sarfraz Ahmed (42.34/3.12d, +)
8. Imran Khan (37.69/22.81, c)
9. Wasim Akram (22.64/23.62)
10. Saqlain Mushtaq (14.48/29.83)
11. Waqar Younis (10.2/23.56)

12th man Shoaib Akhtar

This side largely picks itself with only two openers averaging over 45 in the countries history plus four middle order players who average 50. Sarfraz is the best batsman/keeper they've produced IMO so he gets the nod.

South Africa

1. Barry Richards (72.57)
2. Graeme Smith (48.7, c)
3. Hashim Amla (49.45)
4. Graeme Pollock (60.97)
5. Jacques Kallis (55.37/32.65)
6. AB de Villiers (50.46/2.09d, +)
7. Aubrey Faulkner (40.79/26.58)
8. Shaun Pollock (32.31/23.11)
9. Hugh Tayfield (16.9/25.91)
10. Dale Steyn (14/22.3)
11. Allan Donald (10.68/22.25)

12th man Dudley Nourse

Nourse was unlucky not to break into that incredible top 6, and unfortunately Aubrey's bowling puts him well ahead of him. Amla is the only player there to have played his career out at #3, Kallis and Pollock were mostly batting at 4 or 5 for South Africa. This is probably the second best side out of the lot.

Sri Lanka

1. Sanath Jayasuriya (40.07/34.34)
2. Marvin Atapattu (39.02)
3. Kumar Sangakkara (57.4)
4. Mahela Jayawardena (49.84, c)
5. Aravinda de Silva (42.97)
6. Angelo Matthews (46.74/54.38)
7. Dinesh Chandimal (42.3/2.24)
8. Chaminda Vaas (24.32/29.58)
9. Rangan Herath (14.81/28.92)
10. Lasith Malinga (11.45/33.15)
11. Muttiah Muralitharan (11.67/22.72)

12th man Tillakaratne Dilshan

The only one I'm not sure about here is Dilshan vs Atapattu. The bowlers pick themselves, 4 of the 5 bowlers who have taken over 100 wickets for Sri Lanka.

West Indies

1. Gordon Greenidge (44.72, c)
2. Desmond Haynes (42.29)
3. George Headley (60.83)
4. Everton Weekes (58.81)
5. Garry Sobers (57.78/34.03)
6. Brian Lara (53.17)
7. Clyde Walcott (56.68/1.27d, +)
8. Malcolm Marshall (18.85/20.94)
9. Joel Garner (12.44/20.97)
10. Curtley Ambrose (12.4/20.99)
11. Colin Croft (10.93/23.3)

12th man Michael Holding

This is a seriously impressive XI, Greenidge and Haynes have the most century opening partnerships in the history of the game, then that middle order have 5 players averaging over 53. Their four pronged pace attacks were legendary. This would be in my top 4 along with Australia, England and South Africa.

Zimbabwe

1. Brendan Taylor (34.72)
2. Grant Flower (29.54)
3. Andy Flower (51.54, c)
4. Dave Houghton (42.84)
5. Murray Goodwin (42.84)
6. Craig Ervine (33.5)
7. Tatenda Taibu (30.31/2.21d, +)
8. Paul Strang (27.06/36.02)
9. Heath Streak (22.35/28.14)
10. Ray Price (8.7/36.06)
11. Henry Olonga (5.41/38.52)

12th man Guy Whittall

Easy side to pick considering that there are only 6 players who average over 30 with the bat and Flower is an opener.

jj3254.jpg
 
Hayden and Langer's record speaks for itself. Many people would argue that Ponsford, Hayden, Lawry, Trumper, Simpson and Morris have all got claims to being the best. Waugh and Border were fantastic players, just because you would select Chappell ahead of them doesn't make my opinion wrong.

Doesn't make it right either.
 
I'm bored, so I'm compiling an "all time XI" for every test nation.

Australia

1. Justin Langer (45.27)
2. Matthew Hayden (50.73)
3. Don Bradman (99.94)
4. Ricky Ponting (51.84)
5. Steve Waugh (51.06/37.44)
6. Allan Border (50.56/39.1, c)
7. Adam Gilchrist (47.6/4.33d, +)
8. Keith Miller (36.97/22.97)
9. Shane Warne (17.32/25.41)
10. Dennis Lillee (13.71/23.92)
11. Glenn McGrath (7.36/21.64)

12th man Greg Chappell

Langer and Hayden have the 2nd most runs of any opening combination in test cricket, and the 3rd most century stands so opening with them was obvious. Bradman picks himself. The middle order was tough to split between Ponting, Waugh, Border and Chappell so I went with the two genuine bowling options and the best Australian bat I've ever seen. Gilly also picks himself. I almost went Davidson ahead of Miller to provide variety but Miller was a better bat which edged him ahead (which is a legitimate tie breaker for players like them), and Lillee/McGrath pick themselves along with Warne.

Bangladesh

1. Tamim Iqbal (40.34)
2. Mominul Haque (51.66)
3. Habibul Bashar (30.87)
4. Mahmudullah (31.17)
5. Shakib Al Hasan (39.05/32, c)
6. Nasir Hossain (37.34)
7. Mushfiqur Rahim (31.97/1.86d, +)
8. Mohammed Rafique (18.57/40.76)
9. Mashrafe Mortaza (12.85/41.52)
10. Taijul Islam (11.85/32.13)
11. Shahadat Hossain (10.01/51.83)

12th man Enamul Haque jr

This side really picks itself with 7 blokes averaging over 30 with the bat. Hossain might be controversial, but he's the second best seamer they've produced.

England

1. Herbert Sutcliffe (60.73)
2. Jack Hobbs (56.94)
3. Eddie Paynter (59.23)
4. Wally Hammond (58.45/37.8)
5. Ken Barrington (58.45)
6. Dennis Compton (50.06/56.4)
7. Les Ames (40.56/2.06d, +)
8. Jim Laker (14.08/21.24)
9. Fred Trueman (13.81/21.57)
10. Frank Tyson (10.95/18.56)
11. Sydney Barnes (8.06/16.43)

12th man Harold Larwood

Sutcliffe and Hobbs have the highest average opening partnership in the history of test cricket and the second most century opening stands. The next three pick themselves with their averages, and then I chose Compton with his ability to bowl part time along with his batting average. Ames averages a lot more thank Knott as a keeper/bat. Laker, Trueman, Tyson, Barnes are four great bowlers, Larwood extremely unlucky to miss out.

India

1. Sunil Gavaskar (51.12)
2. Virender Sehwag (49.43)
3. Rahul Dravid (52.63)
4. Sachin Tendulkar (53.78)
5. Vinod Kambli (54.2)
6. Virat Kohli (50.1)
7. MS Dohni (38.09/3.27d, c, +)
8. Kapil Dev (31.05/29.64)
9. Anil Kumble (17.77/29.65)
10. Zaheer Khan (11.95/32.94)
11. Bishan Bedi (8.98/28.71)

12th man Harbhajan Singh

6 of the top 7 pick themselves, and I went with Virat because of his superb average and he will be a guarantee by the end of his career IMO. Kapil Dev and Zaheer are the two seamers that have done anything for India hence their inclusion and then Kumble and Bedi are their two greatest spinners.

New Zealand

1. Mark Richardson (44.77)
2. Glenn Turner (44.64)
3. Kane Williamson (49.44/38.24)
4. Ross Taylor (46.7)
5. Martin Crowe (45.36)
6. Stephen Fleming (40.06, c)
7. BJ Watling (38.69/3.3, +)
8. Daniel Vettori (30/34.36)
9. Sir Richard Hadlee (27.16/27.29)
10. Dion Nash (23.51/28.48)
11. Bruce Taylor (20.4/26.6)

12th man Shane Bond

This side may not have anyone that averages over 50 but it has an advantage in the fact that their #11 averages 20 with the bat and has multiple test tons. Their bowling attack isn't as strong as England or South Africa but it's still right up there.

Pakistan

1. Saeed Anwar (45.52)
2. Azhar Ali (47.07)
3. Javed Miandad (52.57)
4. Yousuf Khan (53.06)
5. Mohammed Yousuf (52.29)
6. Inzamam-ul-Haque (50.16)
7. Sarfraz Ahmed (42.34/3.12d, +)
8. Imran Khan (37.69/22.81, c)
9. Wasim Akram (22.64/23.62)
10. Saqlain Mushtaq (14.48/29.83)
11. Waqar Younis (10.2/23.56)

12th man Shoaib Akhtar

This side largely picks itself with only two openers averaging over 45 in the countries history plus four middle order players who average 50. Sarfraz is the best batsman/keeper they've produced IMO so he gets the nod.

South Africa

1. Barry Richards (72.57)
2. Graeme Smith (48.7, c)
3. Hashim Amla (49.45)
4. Graeme Pollock (60.97)
5. Jacques Kallis (55.37/32.65)
6. AB de Villiers (50.46/2.09d, +)
7. Aubrey Faulkner (40.79/26.58)
8. Shaun Pollock (32.31/23.11)
9. Hugh Tayfield (16.9/25.91)
10. Dale Steyn (14/22.3)
11. Allan Donald (10.68/22.25)

12th man Dudley Nourse

Nourse was unlucky not to break into that incredible top 6, and unfortunately Aubrey's bowling puts him well ahead of him. Amla is the only player there to have played his career out at #3, Kallis and Pollock were mostly batting at 4 or 5 for South Africa. This is probably the second best side out of the lot.

Sri Lanka

1. Sanath Jayasuriya (40.07/34.34)
2. Marvin Atapattu (39.02)
3. Kumar Sangakkara (57.4)
4. Mahela Jayawardena (49.84, c)
5. Aravinda de Silva (42.97)
6. Angelo Matthews (46.74/54.38)
7. Dinesh Chandimal (42.3/2.24)
8. Chaminda Vaas (24.32/29.58)
9. Rangan Herath (14.81/28.92)
10. Lasith Malinga (11.45/33.15)
11. Muttiah Muralitharan (11.67/22.72)

12th man Tillakaratne Dilshan

The only one I'm not sure about here is Dilshan vs Atapattu. The bowlers pick themselves, 4 of the 5 bowlers who have taken over 100 wickets for Sri Lanka.

West Indies

1. Gordon Greenidge (44.72, c)
2. Desmond Haynes (42.29)
3. George Headley (60.83)
4. Everton Weekes (58.81)
5. Garry Sobers (57.78/34.03)
6. Brian Lara (53.17)
7. Clyde Walcott (56.68/1.27d, +)
8. Malcolm Marshall (18.85/20.94)
9. Joel Garner (12.44/20.97)
10. Curtley Ambrose (12.4/20.99)
11. Colin Croft (10.93/23.3)

12th man Michael Holding

This is a seriously impressive XI, Greenidge and Haynes have the most century opening partnerships in the history of the game, then that middle order have 5 players averaging over 53. Their four pronged pace attacks were legendary. This would be in my top 4 along with Australia, England and South Africa.

Zimbabwe

1. Brendan Taylor (34.72)
2. Grant Flower (29.54)
3. Andy Flower (51.54, c)
4. Dave Houghton (42.84)
5. Murray Goodwin (42.84)
6. Craig Ervine (33.5)
7. Tatenda Taibu (30.31/2.21d, +)
8. Paul Strang (27.06/36.02)
9. Heath Streak (22.35/28.14)
10. Ray Price (8.7/36.06)
11. Henry Olonga (5.41/38.52)

12th man Guy Whittall

Easy side to pick considering that there are only 6 players who average over 30 with the bat and Flower is an opener.
Vinod Kambli? Might as well hve Brad Hodge in Australian XI then.
 
Hayden and Langer's record speaks for itself. Many people would argue that Ponsford, Hayden, Lawry, Trumper, Simpson and Morris have all got claims to being the best. Waugh and Border were fantastic players, just because you would select Chappell ahead of them doesn't make my opinion wrong.

Yes, it does

Also, Vinod Kambli is basically India's Adam Voges. VVS Laxman and Sourav Ganguly would fit better, and that's just guys from my generation

For New Zealand, Dion Nash in the side over Shane Bond is woeful. And you can't quote matches played cause he reached more than Kambli's 17. Beyond that, Chris Martin and Danny Morrison have better claims

Pakistan, I'd be inclined to give the gloves to their first ever keeper, Hanif Mohammad

Sri Lanka, gloves to Sanga, add Samaraweera, Dilshan, or Tillekeratne as better batting options than Chandimal

Zimbabwe, you've got 2 keepers in the top three. Scrap Taibu and add Guy Whittall
 
Yes, it does

Also, Vinod Kambli is basically India's Adam Voges. VVS Laxman and Sourav Ganguly would fit better, and that's just guys from my generation

For New Zealand, Dion Nash in the side over Shane Bond is woeful. And you can't quote matches played cause he reached more than Kambli's 17. Beyond that, Chris Martin and Danny Morrison have better claims

Pakistan, I'd be inclined to give the gloves to their first ever keeper, Hanif Mohammad

Sri Lanka, gloves to Sanga, add Samaraweera, Dilshan, or Tillekeratne as better batting options than Chandimal

Zimbabwe, you've got 2 keepers in the top three. Scrap Taibu and add Guy Whittall
Azzharuddin could play a bit
 
Shahadat Hossian is a s**t human being and a s**t cricketer, even though he's young and barely played a test I'd have Mustafizur in the Bangladesh team.
 
Yes, it does

Also, Vinod Kambli is basically India's Adam Voges. VVS Laxman and Sourav Ganguly would fit better, and that's just guys from my generation

For New Zealand, Dion Nash in the side over Shane Bond is woeful. And you can't quote matches played cause he reached more than Kambli's 17. Beyond that, Chris Martin and Danny Morrison have better claims

Pakistan, I'd be inclined to give the gloves to their first ever keeper, Hanif Mohammad

Sri Lanka, gloves to Sanga, add Samaraweera, Dilshan, or Tillekeratne as better batting options than Chandimal

Zimbabwe, you've got 2 keepers in the top three. Scrap Taibu and add Guy Whittall

Dilshan was decent but I'd pick chandimal over him As a pure batsman. In a far weaker top order he's done a very good job.
 
Dilshan was decent but I'd pick chandimal over him As a pure batsman. In a far weaker top order he's done a very good job.
Interesting choice, Dilshan's early career wasn't great but when he became a permanent opener he had some ridiculously good form for a good 4 years there.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Conrad Hunte is an automatic choice as opener for the WI.
Vivian Richards would probably scrape into the side.
Andy Roberts is automatic as one of their 3 best-ever fast bowlers.
Lance Gibbs would be in the side.
Croft wouldn't even remotely be in contention.

NZ's best side includes Reid, Donnelly, Sutcliffe and Dempster.

SA's best ever keeper-batsman was Denis Lindsay. He still holds the keeper's series record of 606 runs, has by far the world's best record (10+ matches) for the least number of byes, and has a good dismissals per match record. He was, unfortunately, potentially one of the greats of the lost generation, along with Pollock and Richards.

I haven't looked at any of the teams in great detail, but it is fairly obvious that there has been an over-reliance on mere career averages, without any consideration of the factors leading to variations in averages between eras, such as uncovered pitches, smaller faster grounds, bigger bats and, in particular, quality of opposition.
 
Dilshan was decent but I'd pick chandimal over him As a pure batsman. In a far weaker top order he's done a very good job.
Dilshan was decent but I'd pick chandimal over him As a pure batsman. In a far weaker top order he's done a very good job.

I like Samaraweera for the role. A very patient man for the stroke makers to bat around, and Angelo Mathews can drop to 7
 
First impressions:

Greg Chappell, Victor Trumper, Arthur Morris, Neil Harvey from the Australian team. Hayden and Langer not so obvious to me. Waugh and Border miss the cut for mine. I would also take Healy over Gilchrist, simply because I always take the best wicketkeeper - but I know nobody else would.

Alan Knott takes the gloves for England, surely. That's quite a batting line up though, with the likes of May not making it.

I would have thought there was somebody other than Zaheer Khan, but I can't think of who. India's pace stocks are absurdly low, but the batting is top notch and incredibly recent really.

Hanif Mohammad for Pakistan? I also find it hard to leave out Zaheer Abbas, but agree he doesn't quite make it.

Viv and Holding not making the Windies side. Wow. Looking at those selected, I can understand it with Viv, but Holding ahead of Garner or Croft for me. Garner would be first picked for an ODI side, but Holding is (to me anyway) the equal of Marshall. Courtney Walsh also another to be considered.
And where are these games played? Alf Valentine in the right conditions? Probably not, that pace attack is fearsome and no matter where a hypothetiocal game was another spinner wouldn't help.

Eddo Brandes unlucky from the Zimmers, but probably correct call to go with Olonga. Maybe the chook farmer could play ahead of Ray Price when conditions suit pace more.
 
As a West Indies fan it is amazingly hard to fill their batting line up.
4 gun openers to choose from - Hunte, Fredericks, Greenidge and Haynes.
Ridiculous middle order with Weekes, Walcott, Kanhai, Richards, Sobers, Lara, Chanderpaul, Headley, Rowe, Lloyd, Worrell, Kallicharan etc.

If pressed I'd go
Haynes
Greenidge
Headley
Richards
Weekes
Sobers
Dujon or at a pinch Walcott to take the gloves
Marshall
Holding
Ambrose
Roberts

Harsh on Gibbs but he had a very high strike rate so I think sobers would do a decent job bowling tweak. And it's not as Though their pace attack would battle to sort teams out.

Can't believe Lara doesn't make it because he's probably the 5th best batsman in West Indies history imo but I guess you have to pick proper openers.

Headley was colossal in an era when he basically was the team, and the war robbed him of his most profitable cricketing years so to have the record he did - a century at better than every second test - was amazing.
Richards speaks for himself. Stats don't do him justice for what he brought to the team.
Weekes had a simply phenomenal record over a long period.
Sobers is the greatest all round cricketer the world has ever seen. So no Lara unfortunately. You could throw a dart at 10 bowlers and still randomly land on an amazing attack but I just went with what I think would be best.
 
Best Australia 11 that I have seen:

1. Matthew Hayden (50.73)
2. David Warner (49.16)
3. Ricky Ponting (51.85)
4. Steve Smith (60.15)
5. Michael Hussey (51.52)
6. Steve Waugh (51.06)
7. Adam Gilchrist (47.60)
8. Mitchell Johnson (bowl 28.40)
9. Shane Warne (bowl 25.41)
10. Craig McDermott (bowl 28.63)
11. Glenn McGrath (bowl 21.64)

12. Stuart MacGill (bowl 29.02)
13. Michael Clarke (49.10)
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top