List Mgmt. All Trades and Draft Part 2- Draft edition

Status
Not open for further replies.
Sep 28, 2009
23,073
32,314
AFL Club
West Coast
Other Teams
Reading FC
Like the guy a lot and his passion playing for the reserves, but not sure why we're persisting with Brayshaw tbh. I reckon he'll definitely be delisted in 12 months time. Simply too slow for AFL, would be more confident if Sam Mitchell was still around to teach him how to move through traffic despite a lack of speed. Hopefully we decide to move him to the rookie list at least.
Cant delist everyone with the limited picks we have. He is probably the best of the bunch but agree he will struggle to adapt to the AFL. Dont think it makes a difference if he is rookie or main listed.
 
Oct 17, 2018
1,651
3,021
AFL Club
West Coast
I cant believe there has been no mention of Ben Middleton on this thread.

Middleton was the leading 2019 goal kicker in the WAFL Colts and scored 5.4 in the Grand Final.

I have watched the Final a few times and he's an impressive prospect. With Kennedy seemingly on his last legs Middleton would be an excellent back-up pick for us in the pre-season draft or as a rookie.

Ben is a Peel Thunder player and I would be amazed if Fremantle doesn't have their eyes on him. He reminds me a bit of Fyfe who kicked a bag in the Colts Grand Final prior to his being drafted.

Draft Central has done a good write up on Middleton.
I agree I did a stat search throughout the WAFL COLTS and Seniors looking at the numbers and looking at players (18 or Over-agersthat we haven't really discussed, Ben was the only one from Peel that should be looked at
Only query is he is undersized for a key foward, plus do we really need him?
LAST 10 MATCHES
ROUNDGRADEOPPOSITIONKHDMTHOFFFAGB
Grand Final, 2019ColtsClaremont110115110154
Finals Week 2, 2019ColtsClaremont92116310222
Round 20, 2019ReservesPerth4371400100
Round 19, 2019ReservesSwan Districts94137501142
Round 18, 2019ColtsSouth Fremantle93126300011
Round 17, 2019ColtsClaremont6285000020
Round 15, 2019ColtsEast Fremantle77143100120
Round 14, 2019ColtsEast Perth5384000121
Round 12, 2019ColtsSwan Districts132158000044
Round 11, 2019ColtsPerth113149200243
 

twce13

Premiership Player
Apr 29, 2012
4,735
7,568
AFL Club
West Coast
dont understand the menadue love.
was drafted as a athlete in the post-bont craze and never proved to be worth the hype.
Tigers wouldn't be letting go if he was any good (and yeah not buying into the he played in a diff role, if he was adept enough in another role tigers would have seen it.)
 


Feel a bit for Matty Allen. I never really feel like he got a shot at it and had done at least as much as some others who got an opportunity.

Maybe something will come for him on a rookie list somewhere but our left overs never seem to get any attention. He's only just 22 maybe he can force his way back in through a state league as a mature ager.
 
Menadue is absolutely terrible. Hope freo pick that spud up.

If eagles did it would scream of Cale Morton.

On SM-G973F using BigFooty.com mobile app

Morto, what a gun 😍


To be fair Morto cost us pick 88 and was on the main list if my memory serves correct.

Menadue is a complete free hit and costs us nothing other than a rookie spot. More upside than Smith by a country mile IMO.

Hell i don't really want either. I'd rather find a raw young player with a massive upside we could throw a lifeline to. Like the Tigers have recently.
 
Jun 11, 2013
10,371
11,597
AFL Club
West Coast
Like the guy a lot and his passion playing for the reserves, but not sure why we're persisting with Brayshaw tbh. I reckon he'll definitely be delisted in 12 months time. Simply too slow for AFL, would be more confident if Sam Mitchell was still around to teach him how to move through traffic despite a lack of speed. Hopefully we decide to move him to the rookie list at least.


I was watching Sam Mitchell highlights in the blue n gold about an hour ago, and * me if he wasn’t an absolute bloody legend. I wish we still had him at the club.
 
Oct 17, 2018
1,651
3,021
AFL Club
West Coast
From Claremont these youngsters could be in discussions:

Ronin O'Connor- Has a bit of size and alot to work with- hasn't been a huge accumulator
Anthony Davis-193cm- Don't know much about if other then looks like a backman
Jye Clark
LAST 10 MATCHES
ROUNDGRADEOPPOSITIONKHDMTHOFFFAGB
Grand Final, 2019ColtsPeel Thunder105150400110
Preliminary Final, 2019ColtsWest Perth143172200000
Round 18, 2019ColtsWest Perth154194401210
Round 17, 2019ColtsPeel Thunder1613293201001
Round 16, 2019ColtsPerth0000000020
Round 14, 2019ColtsSubiaco1421353300000
Round 13, 2019ColtsSouth Fremantle1210222602200
Round 12, 2019ColtsEast Fremantle2211334301002
Round 11, 2019ColtsEast Perth1713303702000
Round 10, 2019ColtsSwan Districts1315282801100

Riley Morgan as an Overager. The kid loves to tackle

LAST 10 MATCHES
ROUNDGRADEOPPOSITIONKHDMTHOFFFAGB
Grand Final, 2019ReservesWest Perth610162301100
Finals Week 2, 2019ReservesWest Perth8111941201001
Round 20, 2019ReservesSwan Districts228305601010
Round 19, 2019ReservesSouth Fremantle228308603102
Round 18, 2019LeagueWest Perth87153700201
Round 17, 2019LeaguePeel Thunder66121800000
Round 16, 2019LeaguePerth107174500100
Round 14, 2019ReservesSubiaco177246200101
Round 13, 2019ReservesSouth Fremantle1682471400101
Round 12, 2019ReservesEast Fremantle146205603020

My pick from the bunch is the GF best player Jack Cooley-
LAST 10 MATCHES
ROUNDGRADEOPPOSITIONKHDMTHOFFFAGB
Grand Final, 2019ColtsPeel Thunder1716335702100
Preliminary Final, 2019ColtsWest Perth156214301000
Finals Week 2, 2019ColtsPeel Thunder148224300100
Finals Week 1, 2019ColtsWest Perth1511261601100
Round 20, 2019ColtsSwan Districts910191201110
Round 19, 2019ColtsSouth Fremantle1117282700120
Round 18, 2019ColtsWest Perth1410241500000
Round 17, 2019ColtsPeel Thunder1613295100000
Round 16, 2019ColtsPerth0000000010
Round 14, 2019ColtsSubiaco1815335501000
 

jesterwester

Premiership Player
May 1, 2007
3,687
6,592
Australind
AFL Club
West Coast
Wouldn't surprise me if MAllen finds his way back onto an AFL list. Still young and in a half decent SANFL side will stand out.
You’d think if not at the draft this year he’d be a fairly strong chance to go on the mid season draft if he has a good start to next year.

He’s been on our list 4 years and couldn’t break in- he probably finds himself a little unlucky our midfield has stayed relatively injury free the last 2 years he’s been playing as a midfielder. I could have seen him playing a role similar to Redden.

Also a little unlucky that both SA clubs have an influx of bigger inside midfielders. He’d find himself in the same boat at those clubs as he does with us; that is, behind established best 22 midfielders.

I imagine a big bodied mid like him would appeal to a few clubs. Essendon, being one.
 
Anyone good?
Cooley over O’Conner both rookie at best.

Jye Clark is not eligible this year, will be in next years cohort. Dead Set gun he is the younger brother of Jordan who the Gellong Dick Eaters drafted last year.

Clark will be a player ... watch out for him in 2020.

Claremont’s Callum Jamieson is someone I would be rapt if we picked up as a rookie.... may not last that long as chance to go late in the main draft.
So we may need to pull the trigger with our last pick , 46 is way to early for him.
 

The Stid

Club Legend
Mar 16, 2011
2,395
6,701
Perth
AFL Club
West Coast
Other Teams
Boston Bruins
What’s happened with Harry Schoenberg? I seem to recall a fair bit of talk about him earlier in the year, rating him fairly highly and likening him to Shuey (IIRC). I’ve noticed in some phantoms he’s not in the top 30 but someone did have him at in the late 20’s. If we could get into the 30’s, from what I’ve read he would be a good get if he’s still there on the day. I like what I’ve read of Philp as well.
 
Oct 17, 2018
1,651
3,021
AFL Club
West Coast
Cooley over O’Conner both rookie at best.

Jye Clark is not eligible this year, will be in next years cohort. Dead Set gun he is the younger brother of Jordan who the Gellong Dick Eaters drafted last year.

Clark will be a player ... watch out for him in 2020.

Claremont’s Callum Jamieson is someone I would be rapt if we picked up as a rookie.... may not last that long as chance to go late in the main draft.
So we may need to pull the trigger with our last pick , 46 is way to early for him.
Cheers Monocle i'm just basing of numbers and what looks like consistency
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back