Why did lewis choose Melbourne when he could have choosen Richmond? He has wasted his final years...
Why did Tyson, hibberd, melksham, vince, garlett etc choose Melbourne when they did? Because they saw the youth Melbourne had and saw a future.
If you think carlton wont rise within the next 2 years you are well off.
We had shown substantially more than Carlton.
- Carlton wanted to move on Garlett, Melbourne simply jumped at that.
- Hibberd and Melksham wanted to move on from Essendon after the drugs saga and had a connection with Goodwin.
- Tyson wanted to return to Victoria and Melbourne offered GWS a trade they wanted.
- Vince wanted to stay at Adelaide but wasn't going to be guaranteed games and Adelaide wanted to get back into the draft after the Tippett fiasco.
- Lewis had to be talked into moving clubs and again at that stage we were far ahead of where Carlton are now.
You've shown nothing at this present time that the Blues are worth a look in, there is only one reason he would go to Carlton right now and that is an absolutely insane financial reason.