Andrew Walker upset...

[Jezza U Beauty]

I really doubt Walks will be going anywhere.

Trading him now would be like selling your investment property during a market slump, and there's no indication he's out of favour at the club.

 

[C4[2]Yo`DooR]

Walker for Josh Kennedy.

 

[pumped]

Walker for Josh Kennedy.

As much as I think Walker is well worth keeping if we could get Josh as a straight swap would go for it.

 

[Artie Bucco]

I know we need a KPP but come on what would be the point in trading him now?

The guy is 'supposed' to explode this season. As far as we all know he's not out of favour, he loves the club, puts in 100% everytime and hates losing more than just about anyone.

It would be like Bulldog's trading Cooney last year because they needed a CHF, stupid imo.

 

[Bluebear]

As much as I think Walker is well worth keeping if we could get Josh as a straight swap would go for it.

No way.

Kennedy is a battler, and was never going to be more than "good".

Last year Walker shows patches or brilliance. Has huge upside still.

I'd love to get JK back, or McKinley, but we won't give up what is required to do it.

 

[The Grover]

I know we need a KPP but come on what would be the point in trading him now?

The guy is 'supposed' to explode this season. As far as we all know he's not out of favour, he loves the club, puts in 100% everytime and hates losing more than just about anyone.

It would be like Bulldog's trading Cooney last year because they needed a CHF, stupid imo.

Don't compare Walker to Cooney, like comparing apples & oranges.

 

[Artie Bucco]

Don't compare Walker to Cooney, like comparing apples & oranges.

They are very similar in the fact that this season was their breakout season....form leading up to it would indicate true for both. Unfortunately only one has made it out on the park this season.

 

[Pamam]

They are very similar in the fact that this season was their breakout season....form leading up to it would indicate true for both. Unfortunately only one has made it out on the park this season.

Cooney broke out last year!!!

 

[Artie Bucco]

Cooney broke out last year!!!

True, so did Walker when he was given an opportunity not playing negating roles.

Point is Walker was having a good year aside from decision making and injury. As was Cooney. Both drafted same year, both expected to tear it up..

Cooney is so far exceeding expectation...

The whole trading Walker idea, just seems stupid. I would trade Fev before I traded Walker