Opinion Answer a question ask a question

[Superstar swan]

Think Ted Richards will retire first if Malceski's knee's hold up.

Would you like to see the implementation of an league wide reserves competition? Or do you believe the reserves are best served by staying in the NEAFL?

I would like a league wide reserves comp. I don't think our young players get enough exposure to quality competition and I think they would be better developed playing against high calibre competition.

If you are completely honest, how do you expect aj's career to pan out now??

 

[Punts]

Yes he will (and should) stay as one of the better small defenders and not play as a midfielder.

Will Gary Rohan achieve what he has never done at any level of football and average 15 disposals?

Every chance you get you take a shot a Rohan , u said the same shit in another thread the other week. He has just come back from a huge injury and has not even played 30 games yet so get of his back for once mate.

 

[DeadlyAkkuret]

I would like a league wide reserves comp. I don't think our young players get enough exposure to quality competition and I think they would be better developed playing against high calibre competition.

If you are completely honest, how do you expect aj's career to pan out now??

No reason to think he won't recover and still have a great career. 150 gamer and AA imo.

Will we win another grand final before 2018?

 

[The King!]

No reason to think he won't recover and still have a great career. 150 gamer and AA imo.

Will we win another grand final before 2018?

I think we need too and should be able to this year at full strength, i firmly believe we can


Did you hate lance franklin before 2014?

 

[Bonz]

I think we need too and should be able to this year at full strength, i firmly believe we can


Did you hate lance franklin before 2014?

Used to thoroughly enjoy watching him screw up when he attempted something fancy.


Your wifes pregnant on Grand Final Day, you have a ticket to watch the game at the MCG, What do you do?

 

[MarkP]

Used to thoroughly enjoy watching him screw up when he attempted something fancy.


Your wifes pregnant on Grand Final Day, you have a ticket to watch the game at the MCG, What do you do?

Go and watch the game regardless of who is in it. I would wave to her on the way out though.

Will Horse adjust the gameplan with Reid/Tippett/Goodes/Franklin all in the side (making the assumption they will all get on the paddock together).

 

[robbieando]

You would think he has had a game plan for the thought of them all playing together at once and now with the injuries it has forced a quick change that has seen the early results we saw.

Is it really important for factual details regarding injuries for can we be happy we rough timelines as long as they don't blowout?

 

[Bonz]

You would think he has had a game plan for the thought of them all playing together at once and now with the injuries it has forced a quick change that has seen the early results we saw.

Is it really important for factual details regarding injuries for can we be happy we rough timelines as long as they don't blowout?

Personally I am not fussed, if it can keep the opposition guessing then all the better.

Can you see any players at the Swans (Besides Pyke at Union) succeeding in another sport?

 

[robbieando]

Personally I am not fussed, if it can keep the opposition guessing then all the better.

Can you see any players at the Swans (Besides Pyke at Union) succeeding in another sport?

Hanners in motor racing

But seriously, Goodes at Soccer because he played it at a high level as a junior and maybe Rohan, Jetta and AJ in Athletics - Rohan and Jetta in the sprints and AJ in the long distance.

What home and away match not involving the Swans would you pay to go and see if given the money to do so?

 

[RW]

What home and away match not involving the Swans would you pay to go and see if given the money to do so?

Anzac Day at the MCG

From the 2012 premiership team, who do you think will be the last to retire?

 

[GotTheGoodes]

Anzac Day at the MCG

From the 2012 premiership team, who do you think will be the last to retire?

Goodes? Lol. No seriously, Parker (if his mirror image Jude Bolton was anything to go by anyway).

What is you game day ritual (if you have one) before heading in to town to see a game? If you don't have one, what would your match day ritual be if you could be assed?

 

[Lazar Goz]

Goodes? Lol. No seriously, Parker (if his mirror image Jude Bolton was anything to go by anyway).

What is you game day ritual (if you have one) before heading in to town to see a game? If you don't have one, what would your match day ritual be if you could be assed?

Clean the house, put on some swans gear, set up the electronic devices and pray.

Who will end up being a better player, Cunningham or Rohan

 

[The King!]

Clean the house, put on some swans gear, set up the electronic devices and pray.

Who will end up being a better player, Cunningham or Rohan

I think rohan will be if he gets his body right.


Is rodney eade ignored too much in the success of the swans?

 

[GotTheGoodes]

I think rohan will be if he gets his body right.


Is rodney eade ignored too much in the success of the swans?

To a certain extent I think he is. However player disharmony and discontent is never a trait that will win you a premiership. Without Roos stepping in I don't think we'd have achieved the level of success we have since enjoyed. But yes, basically Eade is not credited enough with his efforts dragging us from bottom of the ladder to finals (and a GF).

What is your first ever memory of the Swans &/or South Melbourne?

 

[robbieando]

Beating Carlton at Waverley in 88. Happy Day. Last win I saw at the ground by the club until 95. Not so happy

Is there a club everyone hates on here(North, Essendon, Hawthorn, St Kilda, West Coast etc) that you enjoy watching because of family and friends?

 

[Bonz]

Beating Carlton at Waverley in 88. Happy Day. Last win I saw at the ground by the club until 95. Not so happy

Is there a club everyone hates on here(North, Essendon, Hawthorn, St Kilda, West Coast etc) that you enjoy watching because of family and friends?

I don't hate Collingwood or Essendon because of a few of my friends.

If Sydney were to ever (Let's hope it doesn't) die off as a club, could you bring yourself to support another team?

 

[Swansujelly]

Nope.

What are our list holes going forward, what position should we target next draft, or continue on the best available policy?

 

[Punts]

Nope.

What are our list holes going forward, what position should we target next draft, or continue on the best available policy?

Mature KPD is a must I think with LRT ( may retire ), Ted ( getting on ) , AJ ( unknown ) , Walsh ( going home ).

IF Longmire cant work out a forward structure with Tippett , Franklin , Reid and use them to there advantage and the high bomb continues etc etc and doesn't take this side to the Finals this year is he under the pump

 

[robbieando]

No. Nor should he be either.

Pick a Swans game you wish you could been at since you started supporting them

 

[The King!]

No. Nor should he be either.

Pick a Swans game you wish you could been at since you started supporting them

2005 grand final

if adam goodes misses the season but says he i want to play in 2015, and it is up to you, does he get to stay?

 

[scaryness]

if adam goodes misses the season but says he i want to play in 2015, and it is up to you, does he get to stay?

Yes, but he would be a specialist sub. At least for the first few rounds...

Who has the most underrated performance in either premiership?

 

[Bonz]

Yes, but he would be a specialist sub. At least for the first few rounds...

Who has the most underrated performance in either premiership?

Sean Dempster in the 2005 Grand Final.

If you could watch one player from South Melbourne play in our current era who would it be?

 

[swansRgunBRUH!]

Great idea SR

Jordan Lockyer purely because of his position, size and the length of time spent on the list already. Would like to be proven wrong though.

Draft wise (and forget where we would be picking) what would be the number area to target - ruck, key position defender or midfielder?

all i know is we're likely to use our 1st on heeney. Hes been compared to a steele sidebottom player with his electrifying atmosphere and can play an in/out side mid position aswell

 

[The King!]

Sean Dempster in the 2005 Grand Final.

If you could watch one player from South Melbourne play in our current era who would it be?

Skilton is the obvious one i guess but id like to see laurie nash play

Which coach is better paul roos or john longmire and why

 

[Number37]

Impossible to split them.

Should the club keep going hard at free agents? [I'm thinking Frawley]