Opinion Answer a question ask a question

[Superstar swan]

Who will be the first big name player we lose to a Melbourne-based club, if any?

Not melb based but lewis jetta to wce.

Will sam Reid spend the majority if his career up forward or down back?

 

[robbieando]

He'll swing

Do we end up developing one of the current ruckmen, do we trade for one or both?

 

[Number37]

History suggests we will develop our current ruckmen until we find someone better elswhere.

Will we ever see a player give Macca a spray on the field?

 

[robbieando]

I think Malceski has it in him to do so

Will we see AJ back to his 2012 form?

 

[swansfan51]

Yes, but it will take a long time.

Will Dean Towers play an AFL game in 2014?

 

[Swansujelly]

Yes, no point leaving him in the 2's all year, need to see if he is up tp it.

Do we have a spare 800,000 to sign Frawley?

 

[Jack Lord]

Yes, no point leaving him in the 2's all year, need to see if he is up tp it.

Do we have a spare 800,000 to sign Frawley?

No. Who's our best mid right now?

 

[DeadlyAkkuret]

No. Who's our best mid right now?

Best or in the best form? If it's best I still say Jack.

How many years will we get out of Buddy?

 

[SBD Gonzalez]

Will sam Reid spend the majority if his career up forward or down back?

On his current run with injuries, in the rooms, I'm sad to say.

Who is the obvious replacement for Super Ted when he retires?

 

[DeadlyAkkuret]

Totally just skipped my question lol.

 

[Ed_Gein]

Will Will Smith smith? Will Smith will smith!

 

[The King!]

Best or in the best form? If it's best I still say Jack.

How many years will we get out of Buddy?

We will play him for the whole 9

Who is the swans greatest rival/s and why

 

[DeadlyAkkuret]

We will play him for the whole 9

Who is the swans greatest rival/s and why

Carlton for trying to kill us and North for trying to steal our fanbase.

Who will be our next brownlow medalist?

 

[The King!]

Carlton for trying to kill us and North for trying to steal our fanbase.

Who will be our next brownlow medalist?

Goodsey?

I thought kennedy could snag one, but i will go with daniel hannebery

If you were in charge of the afl for a day what rule change would you bring in or take back if you hate one

 

[GotTheGoodes]

Goodsey?

I thought kennedy could snag one, but i will go with daniel hannebery

If you were in charge of the afl for a day what rule change would you bring in or take back if you hate one

Haha - Goodesy... Ahem, Great idea btw.

I'd bring back the bump. It's a required and important part of the game IMO. We can't just rely on tackling every time and to punish someone for going in hard and putting their body on the line is ridiculous.

Who is the most exciting prospects (in order) out of X.Richards, B.Jack, L.Perris, J.Dunkley?

 

[strauchanie59]

Haha - Goodesy... Ahem, Great idea btw.

I'd bring back the bump. It's a required and important part of the game IMO. We can't just rely on tackling every time and to punish someone for going in hard and putting their body on the line is ridiculous.

Who is the most exciting prospects (in order) out of X.Richards, B.Jack, L.Perris, J.Dunkley?

At the moment B.Jack, followed by Perris then Richards. Haven't seen Dunkley play so I wouldn't know.

Will we be able to play a tall forward line when Tippett and Reid come back, with LRT in there as well?

 

[MF]

At the moment B.Jack, followed by Perris then Richards. Haven't seen Dunkley play so I wouldn't know.

Will we be able to play a tall forward line when Tippett and Reid come back, with LRT in there as well?

I don't think we can but I reckon Horse will give it a crack.

Who are our top 5 most important players this season?

 

[swansfan51]

I don't think we can but I reckon Horse will give it a crack.

Who are our top 5 most important players this season?

1) Pyke (****ed if he's injured, no other ruckmen)
2) Kennedy (****ed if he's injured, no other very big clearance midfielders)
3) Tippett (much better key forward than anything else we have)
4) Jack
5) Franklin

On a scale of 1 to Melbourne, how screwed are we if Pyke is out of the team?

 

[The King!]

1) Pyke (****ed if he's injured, no other ruckmen)
2) Kennedy (****ed if he's injured, no other very big clearance midfielders)
3) Tippett (much better key forward than anything else we have)
4) Jack
5) Franklin

On a scale of 1 to Melbourne, how screwed are we if Pyke is out of the team?

Melbourne because if pyke got injured today then derricxz is ruck probably with lrt in support

Pyke should be the most looked after bloke at training right now

Which players on the 2014 swans list do you think will end up in the afl hall of fame

 

[Bonz]

Melbourne because if pyke got injured today then derricxz is ruck probably with lrt in support

Pyke should be the most looked after bloke at training right now

Which players on the 2014 swans list do you think will end up in the afl hall of fame

Lance Franklin, Adam Goodes, Luke Parker


What ideal position do you see Rohan playing for the rest of his career? Rebounding Defender, Winger or Leading Forward?

 

[S120]

Lance Franklin, Adam Goodes, Luke Parker


What ideal position do you see Rohan playing for the rest of his career? Rebounding Defender, Winger or Leading Forward?

Wingman. I think playing him as a forward for now while he is still getting back to his best after his injury is the right move, but he should be moved further up the ground over the next 18 months or so to, in an ideal world, be a Brendan Goddard/Nat Fyfe or, on a different scope, Isaac Smith kind of running midfielder. Both of those are glass half full options and as such I think they could be the possible uses for him.

Will Nick Smith end up as a midfielder at some stage in his career or will he be left to be the best pure small defender in the AFL for the next 5 years?

 

[swansfan51]

Will Nick Smith end up as a midfielder at some stage in his career or will he be left to be the best pure small defender in the AFL for the next 5 years?

Yes he will (and should) stay as one of the better small defenders and not play as a midfielder.

Will Gary Rohan achieve what he has never done at any level of football and average 15 disposals?

 

[S120]

Yes he will (and should) stay as one of the better small defenders and not play as a midfielder.

Will Gary Rohan achieve what he has never done at any level of football and average 15 disposals?

A good question. I think he will but not by much. I think he will get to the point of having consecutive seasons averaging around the Lewis Jetta number of 15-17 touches per game. I expect that to come in around 3 years from now. So I think he will but I'm not at all confident he will ever get to the 18-20 area.

Who retires first, older, funnier Ted Richards or younger, rickety-knees Nick Malceski?

 

[Superstar swan]

Yes he will (and should) stay as one of the better small defenders and not play as a midfielder.

Will Gary Rohan achieve what he has never done at any level of football and average 15 disposals?

Yes, I think one year he will have a break out season and tear it apart. IMO, the flashes he is showing right now are better than what we has seen pre leg break. Really is proving to be a versatile player. Has very strong hands for his size and is capable of playing out of the goal square if required.his development may have been stalled for 12-18 months but he will get there.

Do yiu think the scg suits buddy's game style . Obviously very dangerous anywhere forward of the centre but is there enough room for him to use his pace, agility and strength without being swarmed??

 

[Bonz]

A good question. I think he will but not by much. I think he will get to the point of having consecutive seasons averaging around the Lewis Jetta number of 15-17 touches per game. I expect that to come in around 3 years from now. So I think it will but I'm not at all confident he will ever get to 18-20 area. 15-17, I am confident.

Who retires first, Ted Richards or Nick Malceski?

Think Ted Richards will retire first if Malceski's knee's hold up.

Would you like to see the implementation of an league wide reserves competition? Or do you believe the reserves are best served by staying in the NEAFL?