Originally posted by Kane McGoodwin
The claim was that Ben Hart was not a quality player. I was just reminding one of your learned supporters that he has an awesome record as a player & is still a very important player to the Crows. Are you suggesting too that he couldn't get a game at Port?
Originally posted by aaricho
With the possible exception of Goodwin those guys (Biglands, Welsh, Hart, Torney and Reilly) are not in the same league as the Port "outs".
Port just has better depth to cover the injured players.
Your Reply
Yeah Benny Hart is not in the same league as not to many of the Port outs are dual premiership & multiple All-Australian winners! Come back when you know something about football.
My comment
Last time I check, Carey had similar credentials....but we all know what many on this board think about him at the moment!
....Sorry Kane, but I see not where anyone said "he couldn't get a game at Port?". Once again that is clearly false. My comment is not an attempt to support aaricho, as I have not commented on what he wrote.
I simply stated that it is not enough to highlight Harts creditials from 6-7 years ago as an automatic retort to aaricho comments, and I used Carey as an example to support this. That's all, nothing else.
Personally I feel Hart is equivalently important to the Crows as nearly all of our outs (if not more) because he provides much of your rebound from defence. Luckily for Port, they have the abilty to cover much of what is missing without a "SIGNIFICANT" reduction in quality.