Ask a random question thread.

[Judd_Magic]

That's what I was thinking though. Will he come back, and for how long?

I usually have a 4 week wait rule.

If they aren't back by then then get rid of them.

 

[alternatevista]

Probably Pods and Rockliff for mine, but I can't split em a heap.

My Question:

Is it worth blowing a trade to replace Hitchcock for Pods/Rockliff? Already used 16

I assume you have 16 trades left

I'm in same position with Gumby as my forward bench who is likely to play most games but not score well. I'm thinking Hitchcock to Pods because he's 30k cheaper. Some people say that Pods could get dropped as he's 3rd tall forward but who really knows? Certainly seems to be flavour of the week that's for sure.

 

[m8rix]

Anyone know how to find out what Dean Cox average is at SCG?

 

[peteshep]

Anyone know how to find out what Dean Cox average is at SCG?

According to tooserious his average at the SCG is a measley 55.5!! Very promising for those of us looking to bring him in next week or the week after for Hille

Source: http://tooserious.net/?page=player_calc&id=167&pcid=12343

 

[Walesy]

Funny story on that, Cox has only played at the SCG twice.

Once in 2005 where he scored a 111, once in 2003 where the lack of SuperCoach stats means it dug up a 0 - averaged it out to 55.

All his other games up there have been at ANZ stadium.

 

[peteshep]

Funny story on that, Cox has only played at the SCG twice.

Once in 2005 where he scored a 111, once in 2003 where the lack of SuperCoach stats means it dug up a 0 - averaged it out to 55.

All his other games up there have been at ANZ stadium.

haha really?! Wow, I can't believe he's only played their twice!

Ah well. Here's to hoping he doesn't quite reach his break even this week!

Love your work walesy, keep up the good stuff mate

 

[m8rix]

According to tooserious his average at the SCG is a measley 55.5!! Very promising for those of us looking to bring him in next week or the week after for Hille

Source: http://tooserious.net/?page=player_calc&id=167&pcid=12343

Thanks peteshep.

I suspected a low ave there as SCG is not that kind to the ruck men. But on what Walesy pointed out we'll just have to wait and see.

The week after he is up against big Sandi so looking good for a straigh swap in a few weeks!

 

[LiverpoolRed]

Thanks peteshep.

I suspected a low ave there as SCG is not that kind to the ruck men. But on what Walesy pointed out we'll just have to wait and see.

The week after he is up against big Sandi so looking good for a straigh swap in a few weeks!

Thats not right. He has played at the SCG twice, averages 13 touches, 6 marks, 20 HOs, 2 goals a game, .5 tackles and 1.5 frees. There was no Supercoach in 2003 thats y his avg is not right. He scored 111 in a loss back in 05, kicking 4 of just 9 goals.

SCG is a great grown for ruckmen with such high stopages, the syd game plan also helps.

 

[russea]

Okay bit the bullet rockliff in, Hitchcock out
Now the questions continue
Who to start Jpod or Rocklobster

thoughts??

 

[Cool Cat]

thoughts??

I've got the same problem mate. I might have to start both of em ahead of either hall or medhurst - just don't know who. For your problem i'd probably go the safe option of a small over a tall.

 

[russea]

I've got the same problem mate. I might have to start both of em ahead of either hall or medhurst - just don't know who. For your problem i'd probably go the safe option of a small over a tall.

Hmm think im gonna start with rockliff but start medders hes a must this week but do it quick cause of lockout

 

[bestin]

is judd the next jesus?

 

[IDIG]

anyone lost that shortcut menu to all the forums thats usually on the left hand side???

 

[Axe]

LOL. Sure have! Thought it was just me.

 

[Daniels]

Oh yeah, WTF!?

 

[dlanod]

I've noticed a few comments recently saying someone's forward/back/midfield is weak and they should improve that before looking at the other parts of the team. I would've thought you'd be better off concentrating on your worst individual spot, e.g. your forward line are all scoring sixties but your seventh defender is scoring 20s - upgrade your defence even though your forward line is weaker than your defence over all.

So... am I missing something obvious here?

 

[GUMBLETRON]

So... am I missing something obvious here?

Only that most people here habitually miss the obvious.

 

[Giggy]

would love to know why Waite isnt playing....surely there is a spot for him..

and who to pick out of gumby and rockliff in the forward line! arghhhhhh

 

[LiverpoolRed]

would love to know why Waite isnt playing....surely there is a spot for him..

and who to pick out of gumby and rockliff in the forward line! arghhhhhh

He will be selected this week due to Walker's injury, he was just dropped due to form. If you mean on the field? Rockliff, I think he can do better in wat is still a tough game, Dons in for a lesson this week.

 

[IDIG]

Only that most people here habitually miss the obvious.

lolllll too funny


Giggy id probably say Gumby v Hawthorn. The brissy selectors might make it easy for you tonight though by dropping Rock with Power, Sherman, Buchanan and Adcock to possibly return.

 

[thomas_m18]

Giggy, your hand has been forced.

Gumbleton it is.

 

[russea]

Who to start Cunnington or JKT

 

[thomas_m18]

Who to start Cunnington or JKT

You must've made the Goodwin/Bastinac > Goddard/Cunnington trade.

I'd personally start Cunnington over JKT, but that's only because he's more expensive. I don't like having that much sitting on the pine.

Well, think of it this way. You're a Dons supporter. If you start JKT, you want him to do well, and it will distract you from supporting Essendon on Saturday night. If you start Cunnington, you won't have to worry about the opposition.

But that's probably BS.

 

[bbco49]

Which two to start out of
Maguire vs Syd
Ladson vs Ess
Silvagni vs WCE
Davis vs PA
?

 

[LiverpoolRed]

Which two to start out of
Maguire vs Syd
Ladson vs Ess
Silvagni vs WCE
Davis vs PA
?

Silvagni and Davis.

Who would everyone start, I need 2 of the following 4 on the field at F6 and F7:
Medhurst v Blues, Podsiadly v Tigers, Ballantyne v WC and Gumbleton v Hawks.
Im leaning towards jPod and Balla.