Ask a random question thread.

[G-Mo77]

Leon Davis or Colin Sylvia, that is the question I want answered......

 

[Double the Fist]

I J Selwood carrying an injury. 68% Game time av this year and well down on SC points. Cheers.

 

[bbco49]

Silvagni and Davis.

Who would everyone start, I need 2 of the following 4 on the field at F6 and F7:
Medhurst v Blues, Podsiadly v Tigers, Ballantyne v WC and Gumbleton v Hawks.
Im leaning towards jPod and Balla.

cheers mate

agreed on jpod and balla!

 

[SJ]

I J Selwood carrying an injury. 68% Game time av this year and well down on SC points. Cheers.

68% time on ground, is that legit?

 

[GUMBLETRON]

Freako says 79%.

 

[SJ]

Anyone got this week's SuperCoach PDF? Can't find it.

 

[Bomber4ever]

Anyone got this week's SuperCoach PDF? Can't find it.

Is this what you want?

Found it on the SuperCoach Insider blog.

 

[SJ]

Is this what you want?

Found it on the SuperCoach Insider blog.

Bingo.

 

[Double the Fist]

68% time on ground, is that legit?

Hmmm. It is 79%. Sorry. The drugs are taking a while to get through. LOL

 

[ClarkeM]

Question: How the hell will Supercoach work next year with the introduction of GCFC meaning that there will be a bye every week?

 

[thomas_m18]

Question: How the hell will Supercoach work next year with the introduction of GCFC meaning that there will be a bye every week?

I've asked this one, I'll see what I can dig up from this thread.

Random as question, but anyway.

So... the Gold Coast next year. 17 teams.

How do you THINK it will affect Supercoach?

I hope it'll just mean you have to plan for byes, but I expect enough numpties will whine in the off-season that they'll bring in some silly rule.

I could see them giving out free trades for the week to trade the players out that aren't playing or something else stupid like that.

I'm hoping for extra bench players (maybe one per slot), and you've got to plan around not having too many out in one position for a given week. It'd definitely add a tactical element to it.

More trades maybe. Not that I think its really needed. You know when the byes are and can plan around it

Nah well, they arnt going to have 32 rounds so some teams will have 1 bye while 6-8 teams will have 2 (bassed on 22-24 round season). It will be unfair, the have to do something, I think extra subs will be the go. Im gunna hate the bye so much next season, especially if the tigers have 2.

Uhh, what? All teams will have the same number of byes, no two ways about it. And they don't have to do anything. Nothing in SC is 'unfair' when it applies equally to everyone and the rules are known from day 1.

Do you mean AFL teams or SC teams? They'll have to run it so every team gets two byes, otherwise it's even more blatantly unfair than usual. You'll just see some rounds have only seven games with three teams having a bye that round.

I do think something will be done, only because of leagues and stuff. There will be enough people out there angry and whingy about it.

Just wait and see, I guess.

I think they could leave it all the same for SuperCoach with 17 teams, as everyone is in the same boat at the start of the year. The only down side would be that you would be a lot less likely to select players, especially keepers, whose teams have the bye during SC finals time.

 

[bestin]

Question: How the hell will Supercoach work next year with the introduction of GCFC meaning that there will be a bye every week?

I reckon maybe they should make a supercoach league 17 people as well then there can be a bye for supercoach teams as well

 

[thomas_m18]

I reckon maybe they should make a supercoach league 17 people as well then there can be a bye for supercoach teams as well

Hmmm...

What bearing would that have on anything though?

 

[ClarkeM]

Hmmm...

What bearing would that have on anything though?

Replicate the AFL I guess. Also would help save trades when it comes around to a certain AFL team's bye as the SuperCoach team that gets the bye might have players from the team affected. Didn't word that great but you should get the idea.

 

[jinny1]

I J Selwood carrying an injury. 68% Game time av this year and well down on SC points. Cheers.

you sire are a bum....

had selwood as captain all week and changed to goddard after reading this false statement...

Selwood : 140
Goddard: 98

 

[thomas_m18]

Replicate the AFL I guess. Also would help save trades when it comes around to a certain AFL team's bye as the SuperCoach team that gets the bye might have players from the team affected. Didn't word that great but you should get the idea.

Fair enough, makes complete sense.

Wouldn't make a heap of a difference in the overall scheme of SC, and is definately feasible.

 

[ClarkeM]

Sir*

 

[thomas_m18]

you sire are a bum....

had selwood as captain all week and changed to goddard after reading this false statement...

Selwood : 140
Goddard: 98

You can't blame him. He was speculating. Besides, who knew Goddard wouldn't crack 100? Seemed like a solid enough pick.

 

[Daniels]

Anyone else having problems with TooSerious.net? i.e once logged in cant bring up first squad and bench etc

 

[Walesy]

We had a database glitch last week mate, hit the Upload button again and it'll grab your team again.

 

[Daniels]

We had a database glitch last week mate, hit the Upload button again and it'll grab your team again.

Cheers Walesy! Sorted, thanks mate!

EDIT: Oh no!? I uploaded the wrong team!?

 

[Walesy]

Just get the right number in there and hit upload again.

 

[blewhismindout]

Trading Seaby out for a ruckman under 94k
Can someone tell me who's the most likely to play out of:

Vardy
Grimely
Craig
Prato
Bass
McCauley
McNamara

 

[GUMBLETRON]

None of the above? If you want a possible starter, find a few more pennies and look at Trengove, Lobbe, Roughead or Simpson.

 

[blewhismindout]

None of the above? If you want a possible starter, find a few more pennies and look at Trengove, Lobbe, Roughead or Simpson.

Yeah I thought as much... I just need some cash for an upgrade, if they played it would be a bonus.
cheers