Attn Jars458.....look here for timely reminder of a brilliant quote.

[Santos L Helper]

'I happen to believe Tredrea is overated'.

Well this 'overated' (sic) player just tore the heart from your pathetic team again. I'd say he's well and truly living up to his potential as a dominating force at CHF right now!

Six goals up and you still couldn't work up enough passion to win the game. Too many players dropped their heads too quickly. I know you came back, but hey, it's time to gloat.

 

[Macca19]

Originally posted by Santos L Helper
'I happen to believe Tredrea is overated'.

Well this 'overated' (sic) player just tore the heart from your pathetic team again. I'd say he's well and truly living up to his potential as a dominating force at CHF right now!

Six goals up and you still couldn't work up enough passion to win the game. Too many players dropped their heads too quickly. I know you came back, but hey, it's time to gloat.

Jars - that is the most ridiculous comment ive ever read!
You wouldnt happen to be the clown that rang up 5AA and stated that Tredrea wouldnt get a game in any other AFL side and that Robran was twice the player Tredrea was??
Sounds like something youd say!

And your right Santos - Tredrea is probably the best CHF in the game at the moment on current form

 

[Crow54]

Yeah, he's great, let's give him the Brownlow.

But personally I think he deserves the FIGJAM award

 

[Santos L Helper]

Originally posted by Crow54
Yeah, he's great, let's give him the Brownlow.

But personally I think he deserves the FIGJAM award

Nice comeback mate.
Now tell the truth and own up to the fact that you'd love to see him running around at CHF for your team, marking just about everything that comes his way and feeding other forwards the ball all day.
It's just plain stupid to say, 'Yeah, he's great, let's give him the Brownlow', because that's not what I'm suggesting. What I am saying is that he is not overrated, and only appears so to people who are too blind to admit to his obvious talent.

 

[Jars458]

Winners are grinners that's for sure.

We were beaten by the better side no doubt about that.

ANOTHER unacceptable loss where our team leaders were nowhere to be seen when Port went balistic kicking 12 of 13 goals in the middle part of the match.

As for Tredrea - he did quite well but with the service he was getting from the midfield - any forward would have been loving it.

Macca you are a tool. I don't ring up 5AA - I have a life. You obviousyl don't if you spend half your time listening to it.

Clearly I would prefer Tredrea to Robran. Robran is not rated that's why he's not overated. There was a post early in the year on this topic where I made the same comments

Tredrea has had a BETTER year this year, but I still think needs to prove himself before we can safely call him a key player. His kicking is still less than good.


All in all a crap weekend for me with Eagles losing as well.

The team I coach won though (soccer) and therefore there is always some solace.


Congrats to Port on making the finals as they deserve to be there.

Only questions now is, can they WIN a final, as that in the end, is what its all about.

 

[Macca19]

Originally posted by Jars458

Macca you are a tool. I don't ring up 5AA - I have a life. You obviousyl don't if you spend half your time listening to it.

Tredrea has had a BETTER year this year, but I still think needs to prove himself before we can safely call him a key player. His kicking is still less than good.

Congrats to Port on making the finals as they deserve to be there.

Only questions now is, can they WIN a final, as that in the end, is what its all about.

What else is to listen to in the car in the carpark for 30 minutes on teh way home??

Treadrea has had a TOP year this year. Is 5th in marking and hsa kicked 34 goals as well playing up field. His kicking is still less than good? Strange comment seeming he has improved his kicking about 800% since last year. Has kicked 34.23 this year, while last year at this point he had about 21.30. Not to mention the fact he is playing a lot more upfield this season.

He just cant win though. Gerald Healy inparticular is a plain fukwit. In his first game back against Essendon he was mainly in the goalsquare cos of his knee, and all the critics said "he doesnt do enough work up the field he needs to get up there more"....so he starts to play upfield more and the same critics say "he is playing too much upfield and isnt kicking enough goals". Strange that.

I reckon we can win a final. Do you Jars?

 

[Jars458]

Originally posted by Macca19



I reckon we can win a final. Do you Jars?

A home final absolutely. Iwould have to say that after Port has only lost one game at FP this year I believe (to Carlton).

A final away from home though I am not sure.

Against a Richmond or a Hawthorn you would be a chance.

If I had to lay down money now I wold back the Lions for the flag.

 

[Port01]

Originally posted by Jars458

I don't ring up 5AA - I have a life. You obviousyl don't if you spend half your time listening to it.

Now that is a blatant lie -- need I recount the Tregenza episode?

 

[Jars458]

Originally posted by Port01


Now that is a blatant lie -- need I recount the Tregenza episode?

That was eight years ago. I think saying "i dont" is consistent wiht not having done something for eight years

eg I don't wet the bed. This would be fine for a ten year old to say who has not done it since they were two.

I have also won the sports quiz twice, which doesn't count as it is not talking to them about sports.

There - I have owned up to my three misdemeanours. Do you think a fine and no conviction would be warranted??