Remove this Banner Ad

Autopsy Autopsy vs Freo - ****

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

We didn’t deserve to win last week and we were the better team this week and lost.

Having forwards that could mark the ball was the difference.

Literally Treacy was a massive difference because he gave them a marking target who took his marks.

The selection of Kallan Dawson was a massive blunder. What a ****ing potato.

A smaller LMac kept Voss quiet. He ran riot against Dawson. Tell him to clean his locker out the spud.
Put Treacy or Voss in our forward line and we win that game. Get a KP player who can take a contested mark FFS……or at least one that can halve them.
 
Great effort to compete right to the end. Nice to see Larkey lift in the last but would love to see him run at the ball carrier more often. We needed to be a little more composed and cleaner with the footy at key moments. Luke Mc played well. Hated the WA biased commentary
Larkey usually only gets the ball out the back. He needs to start playing like a key forward. A few out the back in the last doesn't make it a good game. Step up big fella.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

The only metric that matters is is wins.
I disagree.

If you’re gonna simplify it that far, it’d be more accurate to say: all that matters is silverware.

You don’t build a sustainable brand of footy capable of winning silverware by obsessing over individual wins and losses.
 
From where our bar has been for the last five years, I wouldn't too hard on us. This is the stage we've all wanted. Could have won, didn't capitalise when we should have .

But were very competitive. Someone said it was a better result than last week and it was.

Thought Fisher showed a bit and was clean.
RHJ reads the play so well, just needs to remain in the contest, made a difference when he came on.
Can see why we wanted Whitlock .

FOS - wow so cool and sees it unfold and has time, so valuable having a player who has time.
Glad that Larks got involved.
Konstanty had some great moments.

A lot to like even without the points.
Somebody call security. Dinkeses account has been hijacked.
 
I had a moment late in the game where I though, geeze McDonald has had a really cracking, solid game. I kid you not, he then handballed the ball straight to the grass. I honestly thought there were Big Brother spies in my head.
Same thing was said and happened at our place.
 
The only metric that matters is wins.

At the start of the year, many would’ve said that by this stage of the year would’ve wanted to see more wins.

“No more honourable losses”. I remember it well.

Then we played Carlton and Sydney. Lost so appallingly that many went back to just wanting to see effort. Just a four quarter effort. Just something.

And here we are. Scratching over the latest disappointing carcass. Many are happy with the progress and in some ways so am I. But we shouldn’t forget where we should be by now.

And we can’t forget how absolutely disgraceful a loss last week would’ve been. We didn’t lose. But yeah.

Our selection integrity is still awful, among many other things.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Couldn't be more impressed by the effort of the players, smashed our record for inside 50 tackles for one. That it didn't translate to a smashing on the scoreboard leads to serious concerns as to the effectiveness of the gameplan.

But my worst fears have been realised, a tiny loss from a sold home game. If that was at Docklands we win that game and keep our season alive. With the reality of a loss now we're buried for 2025.

I'm so pissed off at the club for putting money ahead of winning. Gagf.
So where does the money come from - especially when we are finished in Tassie - certainly not from game attendance in Melbourne - not ideal but get real
 
Because the performance would’ve been lucky to beat a VFL side.
Except it did. It counts as a W in the history books. It counts for 4 points on the ladder.
 
“Proud of the guys”, “great we got back in it”, “probably shouldn’t have been in that position in the firstplace though”, “there are some players that shouldn’t be in the team”, “potentially 4 or 5 that should be”, “forward line needs work”, “when is LDU going to prove he’s worth that contract”

- Me, 2031.
What does posting stuff like this do for you? Apart from make an obviously intelligent person seem like a reactionary moron who is unable to change their mind based on obvious evidence?
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Look enough about Pink , but Logue has also has his share of doubters. What he has is a big arse as is hard to move. Thought he was good.

Yep. I'm a huge Logue doubter but I gotta say, he certainly did well tonight 👏 justified his selection.

I hope we don't see Kawson again.

Played terrible last week and won, played pretty well but a terrible 5/8 mins tonight and lost. That's footy
 
Yeah well as always disappointing we couldn't snag the win...

But.....

We did a LOT right tonight, our pressure and intent especially inside 50 was 1st rate.
We didn't drop our heads when it looked like the game was heading for a blow out.
We persisted against some rough umpiring.
We competed hard right until the final siren.

It was moments, only moments that make that into a win. Mostly moments we inflicted on ourselves. Change 2 moments change the result.

I sleep tonight frustrated we couldn't get that over the line. I'd prefer that to the complete hopelessness and despair I've had earlier in the year.

Shoots of true hope from tonight, well for next year anyway.
 
I disagree.

If you’re gonna simplify it that far, it’d be more accurate to say: all that matters is silverware.

You don’t build a sustainable brand of footy capable of winning silverware by obsessing over individual wins and losses.
It’s not individual losses.

It’s a consistent theme of losses for years on end.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Autopsy Autopsy vs Freo - ****

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top