Barry Hall vs Warren Tredrea

[almost_04]

not being biased but Treadrea.. only the fact Hall has only really started to step up this year, but then again ive never really seen him play much

 

[Sedition]

Hall - he gives as many goals to other team members as he kicks.

 

[outback jack]

OBJ

Tredrea > Pavlich

It's blatantly obvious the AA selectors went with Pav for a bit of a change. It really coulda gone either way.

yep 'a bit of a change' must be the reason.

Thats why he couldnt get a AA HFF or bench spot either i suppose.

poor port supporters, take the 'teal' glasses off guys.

 

[outback jack]

not being biased but Treadrea.. only the fact Hall has only really started to step up this year, but then again ive never really seen him play much

1. yes you are.

2. why comment then?

 

[Ten Ton Hammer]

will they're are not ahead of pav, thats why he got the AA spot. I think brown and pav have more complete games hall and tredrea. In terms of who's greater atm its pav followed by hall imo



Agree, tredders is yet to discover the art of contested marking really. Leading is his way. Hall has added contested marking to his game in the last couple of yrs.

Hall got AA this year as well!

 

[demon_dave]

brown's better than both but Hall is better than Tredrea simply because he's a team player

 

[rgauci]

At the moment you could throw a blanket over Hall, Tredrea, Pavlich, Brown and Riewoldt. They all have their strong points and weak points.

At the moment Hall and Tredrea must be considered top 2 because they are the oldest and have done it for the longest.

In reality Brown had a standout 2003, Riewoldt a standout 2004 and Pavlich a standout 2005. If these 3 players replicate their best form over 5 or more years then they can be considered in the same light as Hall and Tredrea. Possibly better.

But at the moment all 5 are champions of their club and depending on form in a season are deserving of the AA jumper. Not that it holds much esteem after some of the stupid selections in recent times.

 

[celtic_pride]

Hall - If the Saints still had him, they may have won a flag by now

 

[Carolyn]

Barry Hall...for sure

 

[Locky]

In 2005 Barry Hall was better
In their entire Career i think Tredders just beats Hall.

 

[F/D]

Hall >> Tredrea IMO.

Leading = Hall
Strength = Hall
Creating goals = Hall
Kicking = Hall
Team orientated = Hall.



Carey >>>>>>>>>>>>>> Hall >>>> Tredrea.

 

[Cassius_Clay]

Tredrea by a mile. Doesnt crack in big games like big Bazza

 

[Ten Ton Hammer]

Tredrea by a mile. Doesnt crack in big games like big Bazza

He certainly cracked when kicked that goal from 50m out in the gf!

 

[Big Al]

Tredrea by a mile. Doesnt crack in big games like big Bazza

So you were in China during the Prelim and Grand Final.

 

[Cassius_Clay]

So you were in China during the Prelim and Grand Final.

No he sucked.

 

[Ten Ton Hammer]

No he sucked.

lol Mate your lot have no big time players apart from buckley!

Enjoy more success in 2006.