BBL Match 43 Sydney Sixers v Perth Scorchers 1845hrs @ the SCG

Who will win?


  • Total voters
    4
  • Poll closed .

Remove this Banner Ad

Coasters7

Norm Smith Medallist
Nov 27, 2014
9,023
15,026
AFL Club
West Coast
Other Teams
Chelsea
That loss wont sting to the Scorchers but it may be the lost that they need to work on their weaknesses, which is still chasing medium targets. Im not sure where I can pinpoint where they went wrong with that chase, probably in clutch moments the key batsman needed to go a bit more longer? I would have fancied Perth to defend 145 then chase 145 tonight on that wicket. They’re a team that builds pressure on opponents with the ball (defending targets) and thats their strength. Id fancy Perth to win in a final over in Perth, just think they know their home conditions inside out. Perth batting from 7 to 11 is also not that great. Sixers bat much deeper for me down to 9 or so.
Sixers also have their entire starting XI available and have one of the most unique home grounds in the country. Tail starts to look a lot better with Richo in and Marsh/Green would help us keep the run rate up in the middle overs. Without them though we just need to avoid the slow SCG wicket
 

NYRB

Brownlow Medallist
Oct 6, 2011
28,533
9,175
Auckland, New Zealand
AFL Club
GWS
Other Teams
Patriots, Golden State, Wildcats
Sixers also have their entire starting XI available and have one of the most unique home grounds in the country. Tail starts to look a lot better with Richo in and Marsh/Green would help us keep the run rate up in the middle overs. Without them though we just need to avoid the slow SCG wicket
I think the WA state shield team beat NSW in a state game there but I think Scorchers would go OK batting first tonight. A bit of a weird decision for me tonight by Scorchers to win the toss and bowl first. I sense they wont do that same mistake again in a Final. I feel like maybe they were even trying different tactics given they are already 1st on the Standings.

Id actually fancy Perth to beat the Sixers on any ground in Australia now bar the SCG. Gotta remember this Perth lineup beat Sixers last year on neutral ground at the Marvel.

Also noticed the next game for the Sixers is up on Coffs Harbour on Tuesday. I agree that the Sixers too have a unique advantage playing at the SCG. And maybe from a Sixers standpoint you look to bring in Todd Murphy instead of playing Lyon.
 

4Seasons

All Australian
Apr 29, 2022
804
1,023
AFL Club
Western Bulldogs
Not to fussed by the loss. Our batting always freaks me out, and I’m not sold yet on the Eski loving guy, but he’s making runs.
We need to sign up our players that are playing everywhere else though. It seems every team has 3 West Australians?
That’s a quarter of a side.

Great comp though. The Shield is obviously great even though people refuse to attend. The BBL is where it’s at.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

largebus

Norm Smith Medallist
Apr 22, 2017
7,990
7,438
AFL Club
Fremantle
Other Teams
Liverpool, Nationals, Pelicans
Not to fussed by the loss. Our batting always freaks me out, and I’m not sold yet on the Eski loving guy, but he’s making runs.
We need to sign up our players that are playing everywhere else though. It seems every team has 3 West Australians?
That’s a quarter of a side.

Great comp though. The Shield is obviously great even though people refuse to attend. The BBL is where it’s at.
The West Aussies in other teams are the guys who aren't good enough to get into the Scorchers lineup. It just shows the relative strength and depth of WA cricket.
It cuts both ways, Adam Gilchrist couldn't get in the NSW team so he moved west. Now he's universally known as a WA player.
 

NYRB

Brownlow Medallist
Oct 6, 2011
28,533
9,175
Auckland, New Zealand
AFL Club
GWS
Other Teams
Patriots, Golden State, Wildcats
I reckon of all players, Perth Scorchers should look to chase Tim David back to his Perth Scorchers roots. Not sure what his contract situation with the Hobart Hurricanes is. But he is the kind of player, that would fit perfectly as a power hitter coming in at 5 or 6 which the Scorchers badly need.

Marsh is too injury prone for me but if fit you could have M Marsh at 3, Inglis 4, Turner 5, Tim David 6.

I mean l can think of a Freo footy player that left the Dockers to an eastern states team than came back looking to build on that success. (eg Peter Bell ). There is a saying if your a WA sportsperson , you leave WA shores to better yourself in life. Tim David has IPL experience is a much better player than when he was at the Scorchers in his younger years.

You would be pretty filthy though if you were a Hobart Hurricane fan, and saw a player like Tim David to go home and chase more glory. My thinking is Tim David would gladly accept any role to be closer to his family and locals. Im pretty sure if Tim David came back to the Scorchers now, he would have at least another good 7-8 years provided he didn't get swayed to other leagues or international commitments didn't interfere. He would be first choice- as he is unlikely to get into the Test team.
 

Tugga27

Brownlow Medallist
Jun 19, 2017
11,838
17,620
AFL Club
West Coast
I think the WA state shield team beat NSW in a state game there but I think Scorchers would go OK batting first tonight. A bit of a weird decision for me tonight by Scorchers to win the toss and bowl first. I sense they wont do that same mistake again in a Final. I feel like maybe they were even trying different tactics given they are already 1st on the Standings.

Id actually fancy Perth to beat the Sixers on any ground in Australia now bar the SCG. Gotta remember this Perth lineup beat Sixers last year on neutral ground at the Marvel.

Also noticed the next game for the Sixers is up on Coffs Harbour on Tuesday. I agree that the Sixers too have a unique advantage playing at the SCG. And maybe from a Sixers standpoint you look to bring in Todd Murphy instead of playing Lyon.
Can't see them dropping Lyon.

They wiil lose Lyon and Smith whilst the Scorchers will lose Agar and Morris.

Hopefully Richardson is fit.
 

Tugga27

Brownlow Medallist
Jun 19, 2017
11,838
17,620
AFL Club
West Coast
I reckon of all players, Perth Scorchers should look to chase Tim David back to his Perth Scorchers roots. Not sure what his contract situation with the Hobart Hurricanes is. But he is the kind of player, that would fit perfectly as a power hitter coming in at 5 or 6 which the Scorchers badly need.

Marsh is too injury prone for me but if fit you could have M Marsh at 3, Inglis 4, Turner 5, Tim David 6.

I mean l can think of a Freo footy player that left the Dockers to an eastern states team than came back looking to build on that success. (eg Peter Bell ). There is a saying if your a WA sportsperson , you leave WA shores to better yourself in life. Tim David has IPL experience is a much better player than when he was at the Scorchers in his younger years.

You would be pretty filthy though if you were a Hobart Hurricane fan, and saw a player like Tim David to go home and chase more glory. My thinking is Tim David would gladly accept any role to be closer to his family and locals. Im pretty sure if Tim David came back to the Scorchers now, he would have at least another good 7-8 years provided he didn't get swayed to other leagues or international commitments didn't interfere. He would be first choice- as he is unlikely to get into the Test team.
Tim David has another year to go.

He'd be nice, but getting Marsh and a few international bats should do the trick.

The Scorchers biggest problem will be holding into to guys like Kelly, Bancroft and even Hatzoglou IMO.
 

Blue Arrow

Club Legend
Feb 22, 2019
1,415
1,471
AFL Club
St Kilda
Other Teams
The Renegades, Vics
Should Lyon even be in the best Sixers side? Always been behind O'Keefe & Murphy looks a better white ball bowler. Lyon isn't up to it at international level & when a grade cricketer hits you for the biggest six of the tournament you are not an automatic pick even in the BBL.
 

DEVO

Are We Not Men? We Are...
Sep 8, 2000
18,585
18,011
Tuggeranong
AFL Club
North Melbourne
Other Teams
Eels, Cumbrians, Staggies & Braves
Should Lyon even be in the best Sixers side? Always been behind O'Keefe & Murphy looks a better white ball bowler. Lyon isn't up to it at international level & when a grade cricketer hits you for the biggest six of the tournament you are not an automatic pick even in the BBL.
Jesus, it’s his first game back and he doesn’t even get a game to acclimatise. There are some real arseholes on this board who just want to complain or tear into players without any real reason or thought. Pathetic.

And anyone who doesn’t rate Silk needs their heads read as well, 2000 runs at a strike rate of 125 as well as being one of, if not the best fielders in the BBL. Sixers love and most other clubs would love to have him, he can change a game with one magical play.
 

juss

Hall of Famer
Feb 23, 2009
31,464
44,625
Melbourne
AFL Club
Richmond
Other Teams
New York Jets
That Christian over was the matchwinner for the Sixers. 2-7, he dragged Perth right down at the time they could have easily hit a few more for the win. Still very clutch.

I did tip the Sixers. It's very hard to win all the time in this league with so many variables. I dont think Perth would worry too much sitting clear at the top.

This tournament is really only going to be won by Perth, Sixers, or Hobart/Adelaide on their day the batting lineups can post monster scores but they are both very inconsistent.

In all probability its a Perth/Sixers final.
 

Tugga27

Brownlow Medallist
Jun 19, 2017
11,838
17,620
AFL Club
West Coast
That Christian over was the matchwinner for the Sixers. 2-7, he dragged Perth right down at the time they could have easily hit a few more for the win. Still very clutch.

I did tip the Sixers. It's very hard to win all the time in this league with so many variables. I dont think Perth would worry too much sitting clear at the top.

This tournament is really only going to be won by Perth, Sixers, or Hobart/Adelaide on their day the batting lineups can post monster scores but they are both very inconsistent.

In all probability its a Perth/Sixers final.
Perth only a point on top.

Sixers and Scorchers have a similar run him so it will be tight I think.

Whoever finished on top gets a massive home ground advantage.

Not sure about the Strikers without Head and Carey but it only takes one or two to get away.

Hurricanes are the biggest Smokey IMO.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)