BlueYoss
Norm Smith Medallist
I am all for developing our kids but there has to be a time where we, not necessarily halt the progress of the youth but do bring one or two older players despite the baggage. There has to be an equilibirium of the two that the club could see and work things out like that. I do like to liken this situation to Dew last year. They had such a young list last year and Al Clarkson decided to bring in Dew who at 28 was not in much physical shape and had a year out of the game. Look at Ben. He's in as good as shape as he's been throughout his playing days.
There is another delicate equilibrium that we can ill afford to to risk disturbing.
When Juddy first arrived at WC, Cousins was his role model. All the extra gut running in pre-season that Juddy now sets the example at Carlton with, came from his original training mentor and Captain in Ben. When Cousins had to have the captaincy stripped of him at WC Juddy reluctantly took the the position for lack of other options, but it was obvious that he was captain only by name and Ben was still the spiritual leader.
Since coming over to Carlton, Juddy has matured as a leader and really embraced the captaincy, more so than he ever did at WC, as recognised by his All Australian Captaincy this year.
Bringing his old leader and mentor back into the fold could well see Juddy instinctively go back into his shell, to a role so familiar (being captain only by name, with Ben being the spiritual leader). Even if Ben doens't assert himself as a leader, his presence in the playing group alone could be enough to stifle Juddy's development as our leader, and that is the risk that we can't afford to take.
Murph, Gibbs, Kreuze etc have their heads screwed on right, they're big enough to distinguish which examples should be followed for their benefit and which ones would be to their detriment.




