Opinion Best 18 With 1 Player Per Age

[txbyhull]

In honour of Scotty P breaking the record next week at a billion years old, I thought it was a fun thought experiment to:

Make the best starting 18 you possibly can, with only 1 player per age.

This is the list of players by age that I have used

I ended up with this, trying to play as nice with true positioning, role, balance, etc:

B | Worrel, Weitering, Uwland
HB | Whitfield, Andrews, Blakey
M | W. Duursma, Bontempelli, Wilson
HF | M. Reid, Cameron, Bolton
F | Watson, Thilthorpe, Gunston
R | Jackson, Neale, Pendlebury

Curious what other people's are?

35, 36, and 37 are the only ages of active players not used.

 

[Freomaniac]

Well this is harder than I thought. If it was just one AFL player per team regardless of age, this would be way easier

 

[txbyhull]

Well this is harder than I thought. If it was just one AFL player per team regardless of age, this would be way easier

Way harder than I expected, especially trying to go with proper positions

 

[Generalissimo]

In honour of Scotty P breaking the record next week at a billion years old, I thought it was a fun thought experiment to:

Make the best starting 18 you possibly can, with only 1 player per age.

This is the list of players by age that I have used

I ended up with this, trying to play as nice with true positioning, role, balance, etc:

B | Worrel, Weitering, Uwland
HB | Whitfield, Andrews, Blakey
M | W. Duursma, Bontempelli, Wilson
HF | M. Reid, Cameron, Bolton
F | Watson, Thilthorpe, Gunston
R | Jackson, Neale, Pendlebury

Curious what other people's are?

35, 36, and 37 are the only ages of active players not used.

Blicavs, Dangerfield, and Zorko on the bench are the clear picks for 35, 36, 37

 

[txbyhull]

Blicavs, Dangerfield, and Zorko on the bench are the clear picks for 35, 36, 37

Totally, I thought it was more fun to go 18 so that you can have the freedom to skip a few ages