Banger9798
All Australian
- Joined
- Jul 28, 2023
- Posts
- 986
- Reaction score
- 3,357
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
still a bargainThat is absolutely the role he has been brought in to play and why we gave up 7 for him.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

still a bargainThat is absolutely the role he has been brought in to play and why we gave up 7 for him.
The need for two distributors out of the backline is one reason why Tauru might get squeezed out of the backline at the start of 2026 as his ball use, including decision making, is not good., and that we could just have two rebounders in Clark and Sinclair, as JSOS and Wilkie can play small
Not a bad effort...Butler doubtful best 23An updated Best 23
B. Travaglia Howard Wilkie
H.B. Hastie Jsos Sinclair
C. Flanders Pou Windhager
H.F. Ryan Marshall Wilson
F. Higgins King Sharman
Foll. Tdk NWM Hall
l/C. Butler, Henry, Macrae, Owens, Wood
Can't see Butts or Trav in there TBH. Hastie l like.An updated Best 23
B. Travaglia Howard Wilkie
H.B. Hastie Jsos Sinclair
C. Flanders Pou Windhager
H.F. Ryan Marshall Wilson
F. Higgins King Sharman
Foll. Tdk NWM Hall
l/C. Butler, Henry, Macrae, Owens, Wood
Log in to remove this Banner Ad
If he keeps fit & gets a good run at it, he'd be handy still.Not a bad effort...Butler doubtful best 23
If Hastie is best 23 we are in big trouble.Can't see Butts or Trav in there TBH. Hastie l like.
B. Tauru Howard Wilkie
H.B. Hastie Jsos Sinclair
C. Flanders Pou Windhager
H.F. Ryan Marshall Wilson
F. Higgins King Sharman
Foll. Tdk NWM Hall
l/C. Garcia, Henry, Macrae, Owens, Wood
Hill, Hammer, Clarke, Stocker, Dow, Trav and Box isn't bad depth..
If Hastie is best 23 we are in big trouble.
I'm leaning towards Wilson & Windhager on the wings with both included in centre bounce rotationGotta change it to best 23 hey, but here are my locks and spots _____ up for grabs in the best side:
B: ____, Wilkie, Tauru
HB: Sinclair, Silvagni, ____
C: Wilson, Flanders, ____
HF: Hall, Sharman, ____
F: Higgins, King, Ryan
Foll: TDK, Macrae, NWM
Interchange: Marshall, Phillipou,
Owens, Windhager, ____
Lots of competition for those five spots, feels good to have some genuine depth. I love Mason Wood, and I think it's time we move past Hill so I'd slot Wood back in his best spot on the wing. I think Stocker and Hunter Clark have first dibs on the backline spots but they both need to be rock hard fit. If not Hastie slots in. Travaglia should earn a spot on the bench, backing him for a huge preseason. One spot left at half forward goes to Boxshall, he has genuine X-factor about him. Garcia, Henry, Caminiti the emergences.
I'm easy on Trav because of his age and stick body, but Hastie and LOC need some senior games to keep their growth trajectory optimal. Both showed plenty enough this year to keep the faith.Loads of potential in Hastie and Trav but I’d like to see it in the 2s consistently before best 23. They’re not there yet.
Injuries will play a part but as it stands we have better players to play.
I'd have LOC ahead of Stocker...Tobie or Hastie battling it out for another spotI'm easy on Trav because of his age and stick body, but Hastie and LOC need some senior games to keep their growth trajectory optimal. Both showed plenty enough this year to keep the faith.
Fair enough. I'd still have Stocks in front but LOC probably has the tools to pass him fairly quickly in that role.I'd have LOC ahead of Stocker...Tobie or Hastie battling it out for another spot
Like who?Loads of potential in Hastie and Trav but I’d like to see it in the 2s consistently before best 23. They’re not there yet.
Injuries will play a part but as it stands we have better players to play.
I think this is about right. I would start Flanders in the middle, move Macrae to the bench and put Wood on the wing, but other than that looks perfect to me.FB: Silvagni - Wilkie - O'Connell
HB: Sinclair - Howard - Tauru
C: Wilson - Wanganeen-Milera - Flanders
HF: Hall - King - Owens
FF: Higgins - Sharman - Ryan
R: De Koning - Macrae - Windhager
I: Marshall - Wood - Hill - Garcia - Phillipou
Feels pretty good looking at guys like Butler, Stocker, Travaglia, & Caminiti and finding it hard to get them in the team.
I think this is about right. I would start Flanders in the middle, move Macrae to the bench and put Wood on the wing, but other than that looks perfect to me.
I think Flanders and Boxshall will take Macrae’s midfield minutes. Re watching game footage. I was reminded how good Boxshall is at getting the ball out to a team mate while under a lot of pressure.Flanders was a gun half forward as a junior, moved to halfback for the Suns and racked up heaps of possessions, and has come to the Saints to play midfield.
I don't think he's a true 'wing' but I expect to see him deployed in all 3 parts of the field pretty regularly.
Wood on my bench as I think he should be getting pressured for his spot this season. Trav, Hastie & Henry should be gunning hard for that spot.
And Macrae is gonna play on ball for sure. A huge part of moving Steele on was that we can't play both of them on ball at the same time and neither really has the capacity to play another position for 60% game time.
While I expect Naz, Windy, Hall, Garcia etc to all have heaps of midfield stats, by the time the season is done I'd be backing Macrae to lead the team for CBAs.
He's gonna be THE guy on ball for at least another year or two.
I think Flanders and Boxshall will take over Macrae’s role this year. Re watching game footage. I was reminded how good Boxshall is at getting the ball out to a team mate while under a lot of pressure.
Boxshall can't 'takeover' Macrae's position next year, is because he's only a 19 y.o & we need Macrae's experience.Can't believe I forgot about Box...
Boxshall can't 'takeover' Macrae's position next year, is because he's only a 19 y.o & we need Macrae's experience.
But, could see him & Macrae rotating through the midfield.
And Box & Pou will be given every chance to be the new Steele type.
Pou is talented enough to play forward, but is abit lumbering in that position & abit short at 190cm.I see Hall and Wilson getting more time on ball leaving a big space forward for Pou to ease himself back in.
I'd love to get a 3 man swing with Pou, Naz & Owens rotating between deep forward, half forward and on ball. Three 190cm athletic freaks than can all take a mark, hit a target and play defensive if needed.
Pou is class and l just don't see him becoming bull like.Pou is talented enough to play forward, but is abit lumbering in that position & abit short at 190cm.
Hoping he becomes an inside bull.
Nas can play anywhere he likes.
Owens field kicking is shite, so only see him as a pressure forward tbh.
People say Owens is a bull.Pou is class and l just don't see him becoming bull like.