Best 22 Discards/Walkouts/Trades

[Mikevk123]

Best 22 from 2010-2019 for Every club

 

[BF Tiger]

You start!

 

[iGNITER]

Did a best 18 off the top of my head.

B - Howe Dunn Russell
HB - Murray Roughead Crisp
C - Greenwood Treloar Aish
HF - Beams White WHE
F - Krakouer Tarrant Varcoe
R - Jolly Ball Adams

Not a bad midfield.

 

[HairyO]

B Hill, M Suckling, L Hodge, B Franklin, J Kennedy, T Duryea, S Savage, S Mitchell, J Lewis, J Anderson, S Menegola?, R Burton, K Cheney, and... who have I missed ?

Coaches: Bevo, Dimmer, Fagan, Bolton

 

[Johnny Bananas]

Let's be clear. Are these players joining the club, or leaving it due to the reasons in the title?

 

[scoman]

Docherty Patfull Crisp
Hanley Brennan Aish
Polec Beams Yeo
Power Bradshaw Mayes
Sherman Schache Green

Luenberger Rockliff Redden

Karnezis Longer Banfield Riscatellee

Probs missing someone but a fairly reasonable side there.

 

[craffles]

Essendon haven’t lost a lot over recent years, probably because we’ve been so s**t but since 2000 the side if all players were fit and at their peak would be pretty good. A bit slim on midfielders though but that backline is tough as nails.

B: D. Hardwick , T. Richards, D. Solomon
HB: M. Johnson, J. Carlisle, M. Hibberd
C: A. Lovett, B. Caracella, A. McPhee
HF: J. Melksham , S. Gumbleton, S. Crameri
FF: A. Monfries, J. Jenkins, P. Barnard
R: P. Ryder, C. Heffernan, J. Blumfield

B: D. Jacobs, G. Moorcroft, K. Bradley, S. Lonergan

 

[M Malice]

Brisbane Lions era only-

Sam Docherty, Mal Michael, Jed Adcock.
Jack Crisp, Joel Patfull, Pearce Hanley.

Matthew Leuenberger, Jack Redden, Dayne Beams.
Tom Rockliff, Elliott Yeo, Jason Akermanis.

Des Headland, Lachie Henderson, Luke Power.
Blake Caracella, Daniel Bradshaw, Mitch Clark.

Adrian Fletcher, Craig Bolton, Jared Polec, Jason Gram.

 

[HairyO]

Let's be clear. Are these players joining the club, or leaving it due to the reasons in the title?

I took it as who left us. A fair bit of talent out, but we have done well over the years bringing in talent.

Scrimshaw is probably our most exciting, given the unknowns.

 

[buddy2fernando]

Ricky Henderson (c)

 

[Mikevk123]

Doing every team now !

 

[Senor M]

I'm sure I've missed a few players-- but this is an example on wha a Richmond discards/trades team would look like.
Looks like Richmond has had a fair few players leave, but not many of them were stars (Lids being the main exception)

B: Dean Polo Luke McGuane Ty Zantuck
HB: Brett Deledio Adam Pattinson Corey Ellis
C: Richard Tambling Anthony Miles Andrew Krakouer
HF: David Rodan Jay Schulz Robin Nahas
F: Mitch Morton Brad Ottens Ty Vickery
Foll: Angus Graham Andrew Raines Reece Conca
INT: Sam Lloyd, Matt White, Tyson Stengle, Aaron Fiora
EMG: Tom Derickx, Andrew Collins, Danny Myer

 

[Suitcase]

Brisbane Lions era only-

Sam Docherty, Mal Michael, Jed Adcock.
Jack Crisp, Joel Patfull, Pearce Hanley.

Matthew Leuenberger, Jack Redden, Dayne Beams.
Tom Rockliff, Elliott Yeo, Jason Akermanis.

Des Headland, Lachie Henderson, Luke Power.
Blake Caracella, Daniel Bradshaw, Mitch Clark.

Adrian Fletcher, Craig Bolton, Jared Polec, Jason Gram.

That's a very strong team!
What about Buckley? Or was he a Bear when he left?

 

[Pykie]

AFL era:

FB: Cam Pederson - Mick Martyn - David Teague
HB: Byron Pickett - Josh Gibson - Brad Scholl
C: Wayne Schwass - Peter Bell - Daniel Wells
Hf: Daniel Motlop - Wayne Carey - Scott Welsh
FF: Cameron Mooney - Corey McKernan - Adrian McAdam
R: Hamish McIntosh - Levi Greenwood - Alistair Clarkson
I.C: David Hale - Lindsay Thomas - Liam Pickering - Leigh Tudor - Peter Mann - Mark Stephens - Kent Kingsley

 

[Power Raid]

a decade I'd prefer to forget, for PAFC

 

[Mikevk123]

First half

Adelaide


B K.Cheney J.Lever S.Shaw


HB B.Vince P.Davis B.Martin


C R.Henderson P.Dangerfield S.Kerridge


HF M.Wright J.Gunston C.Cameron


F J.Petrenko K.Tippett I.Callinan


Foll: I.Maric J.Lyons M.Grigg


Inter: S.Mckernan, B.Symes,M.McGovern, C.Knights





Brisbane


B J.Adcock J.Patful S.Docherty


HB P.Hanley J.Brennan J.Crisp


C M.Rischitelli T.Rockliff J.Polec


HF L.Power M.Clarke J.Sherman


F J.Green B.Fevola T.Bainfield


Foll M.Leuenberger E.Yeo D.Beams


Inter J.Redden, J.Aish,A.Raines, R.Bewick





Carlton


B J.Russell L.Henderson J.Laidler


HB C.Yarran B.Thornton Z.Tuohy


C B.McLean B.Gibbs K.Lucas


HF M.Robinson J.Waite T.Bell


F E.Betts B.Fevola J.Garlett


Foll S.Jacobs S.Grigg N.Graham


Inter A.Joseph, S.Rowe, A.Everitt, J.Lamb





Collingwood


B H.Shaw N.Brown M.Williams


HB H.Lumumba J.Frost M.Clarke


C P.Seedsman D.Thomas J.Smith


HF A.Fasolo T.Cloke B.Kennedy


F A.Didak C.Dawes J.Blair


Foll J.Witts S.Dwyer S.Wellingham


Inter J.Ceglar, A.Oxley, J.Marsh, B.Dick





Essendon


B M.Hibberd J.Carlisle R.Dyson


HB C.Dempsey J.Gwilt B.Houli


C S.Lonergan B.Goddard B.Howlett


HF L.Jetta S.Crameri T.Colyer


F A.Monfries J.Jenkins A.Davey


Foll P.Ryder J.Melksham J.Merrett


Inter: S.Gumbleton,H.Hocking, J.Green, K.Hardingham





Fremantle


B G.Broughton C.Tarrant D.Roberton


HB T.Mzungu A.Silvagni H.Crozier


C N.Suban R.Crowley L.Weller


HF S.Menegola C.Mayne M.De Boer


F A.Morabito M.Apeness C.Pearce


Foll Z.Clarke M.Barlow L.Neale


Inter: R.Palmer, T.Sheridan, C.Sutcliffe. S.Collins





Geelong


B J.Kelly J.Hamling J.Hunt


HB T.Varcoe J.Walker J.Thurlow


C T.Hunt J.Caddy J.Murdoch


HF S.Johnson M.Clarke A.Christensen


F D.Menzel J.Podsiadly P.Chapman


Foll N.Vardy S.Motlop J.Simpkin


Inter B.Smedts, S.Brynes, L.McCarthy, T.West





Gold Coast


B M.Shaw S.May C.Brown


HB K.Koldashjini H.Scahde T.Mckenzie


C D.Prestia G.Ablett A.Saad


HF J.Caddy C.Dixon H.Bennell


F B.Matera T.Lynch M.Weller


Foll T.Hickey J’O’Meara A.Hall


Inter: Z.Smith, D.Stanley, J.Lonergan, J.Scrimshaw





GWS


B C.Hampton C.Marchbank L.Plowman


HB N.Wilson S.Frost T.Bugg


C D.Shiel A.Treloar T.Scully


HF W.Hoskin-Elliot J.Stewart P.Ahern


F J.Townsend J.Bruce C.McCarthy


Foll R.Lobb J.Steele A.Miles


Inter D.Tyson,M.Kennedy, D.Smith, A.Phillips





Hawthorn


B C.Young S.Gilham M.Suckling


HB R.Burton T.Murphy S.Savage


C X.Ellis S.Mitchell B.Hill


HF J.Anderson L.Franklin B.Whitecross


F C.Brown L.Hodge T.Duryea


Foll B.Renouf J.Lewis S.Menegola


Inter K.Cheney, R.Burton, R.Ladson, J.Simpkin

 

[Mikevk123]

Chuck coaches in to why not lol

 

[kaiserchief13]

I'm sure I've missed a few players-- but this is an example on wha a Richmond discards/trades team would look like.
Looks like Richmond has had a fair few players leave, but not many of them were stars (Lids being the main exception)

B: Dean Polo Luke McGuane Ty Zantuck
HB: Brett Deledio Adam Pattinson Corey Ellis
C: Richard Tambling Anthony Miles Andrew Krakouer
HF: David Rodan Jay Schulz Robin Nahas
F: Mitch Morton Brad Ottens Ty Vickery
Foll: Angus Graham Andrew Raines Reece Conca
INT: Sam Lloyd, Matt White, Tyson Stengle, Aaron Fiora
EMG: Tom Derickx, Andrew Collins, Danny Myer

Wow that's a s**t side

 

[Senor M]

Wow that's a s**t side

Richmond don’t really ‘reject’ or trade much quality by the looks of it.

 

[HTT]

Richmond don’t really ‘reject’ or trade much quality by the looks of it.

For a long time that was mainly because we didn’t draft much of it

 

[juss]

Can't decide if it's a credit to retention or an indictment on drafting that our trade away team generally sucks bad....

 

[The Old Dark Navy's]

A lot of people going further back than 2010.

Also, surely someone being delisted but not being picked up again by another team shouldn't be counted e.g Brock McLean

 

[PAFC_1870]

Not many huge losses, Burgoyne, Impey, Polec are the notable. Trengove an honourable mention. Hombsch and Young are well liked.

Pearce and Pittard ok. Austin, Lobbe, Jacobs.

Chaplin, meh. Moore... Probably missing some.

I guess we can include Brogan and Cornes but they were as good as finished.

 

[Schauermann]

Fremantle


B G.Broughton C.Tarrant D.Roberton


HB T.Mzungu A.Silvagni H.Crozier


C N.Suban R.Crowley L.Weller


HF S.Menegola C.Mayne M.De Boer


F A.Morabito M.Apeness C.Pearce


Foll Z.Clarke M.Barlow L.Neale


Inter: R.Palmer, T.Sheridan, C.Sutcliffe. S.Collins

Looks better then I expected. Only missing real goalkickers...

 

[Golden_6]

Harbrow Lake Adams
Higgins Hamling Ray
Stevens Ward Griffen
Dahlhaus Jones Crameri
Hrovat Stringer Hill
Roughead Cooney Cross
Talia Everitt Campbell Tutt


That’s a pretty handy team. A lot of guns there with Griffen, Cooney, Lake, Dahlhaus, Stringer, Cross, Ward, Higgins, Harbrow. The first 6 player their best footy with us though.