Best 22 from each team (that I have seen)

[SouthSwans]

I started watching footy around 1995-96.

 

[samFFC]

That Sydney forward line is frighteningly good.

 

[NUFC Tiger]

Fair effort SouthSwans

You could probably argue that Ottens would be eligible for Richmond's best 22 as well.

Throw him forward with Richo, Riewoldt and Brown (pre leg break) and that's a handy set of forwards.

I'd probably have to go with Brisbane overall as the toughest. Just strong everywhere on the ground.

 

[Andronicus]

While people would probably feel they could argue with lots of them, you have done really well at getting so many teams that aren't your own looking so good.

Just looking at WCE, I thought Sumich and Brennan would have made it, but perhaps they were at their peaks before you started watching.

 

[Mitchell54]

Great stuff there. The Kennett curse would have never ended if Geelong had a team like that on you showed!

 

[Bobby_]

swap Snr's position with Hawkins and it's not a bad 22

 

[matt_bas]

Great effort, wold have taken some time. Whilst I'm not trying to create an argument, I personally would have cox rucking over nic nat as he has been our best ruckman, and then sumich forward, I love nic but hard to put him into an all star tea just yet. Also woosha should be moved back in place of waters, and (I know I'll get a lot for this) waters swapped with r jones. Great work

 

[samFFC]

How about a combined GWS/GC team? Not sure how to make the fancy graphic that SouthSwans used, but here goes:

B: Bock Gilham Mohr
HB: McKenzie Thompson Murphy
C: Prestia G.Ablett(3votes) Ward
HF: Swallow Cameron Harbrow
F: C.Brown Day O'hAilpin
R: Giles Bennell O'Meara

Interchange: Scully Dixon Shiel Treloar

Others I considered:

• Davis
• Matera
• Stanley
• Gorringe
• Tape
• Greene
• Broughton
• Brennan
• Rischitelli

Hard to know whether to consider form at previous clubs.

Any thoughts?

 

[Andronicus]

How about a combined GWS/GC team?

I like the idea, and I like your efforts, but i think a little refinement could make it even stronger.

 

[SouthSwans]

How about a combined GWS/GC team?

Something like this?

 

[Bailey01]

Not sure that Sloane gets on the team and Stiffy doesnt.