So what's the definition of a key forward? FF & CHF, or are they footballers whose key focus is on kicking goals? The game has changed. We don't have ruck rovers or wingers any more. Arguably the CHF has gone the same way. Menzel's key focus is kicking goals as is Eddie Betts. Two weeks ago when Dangerfield was plonked at FF, Hawkins was instructed to clear the area and act as a decoy
Eddie Betts is a small forward and the best small forward as well. A small forward like Betts or a midfielder such as Dangerfield and Martin resting forward often are better forwards and kick more goals than tall contested mark forwards.
Yes positions in the AFL are much less rigid than the old days and I agree the true CHF often isn't used. However, playing multiple tall big bodied forwards often considered as key forwards that are played on by equally tall big bodied backman still exist.
These tall contested mark forwards do exactly that they take contested marks inside forward 50 or try to bring the ball to ground so smaller forwards can get the loose ball and goal.
Harry Taylor wouldn't be playing forward this year if Menzel (a medium forward) could play as a key contested mark forward.
Harry Taylor contested marks in 2017: 26. Daniel Menzel contested marks in 2017: 13.
Are their certain exceptions especially when it comes down to size? yes with Tim Membrey being the most notable case.
Tim Membrey is only 188cm but by taking 31 contested marks as a primary forward and often taking the best or 2nd best opposition key/big bodied tall defender he makes the list.
Simply making a list of the 2nd highest goal kickers at each club doesn't narrow it down the roles they play, just their effectiveness.
Also the list i have made has no correlation or real impact on ladder position as many sides score via small and medium forwards and resting midfielders.