Votes Best and Fairest Player Award St Kilda v Western Bulldogs 2nd Elimination Final

[Kildonan]

I am not sure if this counts for our season result but I want everybody to have a place to say who they thought were our best players in our first finals win in a decade or more.

Tell us. You have 15 points to distribute among your choices

 

[puppy_dog7]

Ryder 4
Hannebery 3
Coffield 3
Clark 3
Geary 2

 

[Kildonan]

My thoughts:

4 Ryder
3 Membrey
2 Howard
2 Coffield
2 Hannebery
1 Clark
1 Geary

Edit: looks like I overlooked Hanners

Going to rewatch the match (I went to the Gabba) - reserve the right to modify the scores based on my thoughts of the replay

Yeah I reviewed it and Hanners did deserve a mention, and his great performance dropped after that crunch in the third q when he looked to have a stinger in one shoulder and some pain in the wrist of his other arm from that collision

 

[Macgruber]

4 Membrey
3 Ryder
2 Howard
2 Hanners
2 Clark
1 Coffield
1 Carlisle

 

[Saint_Dos]

4. Ryder
4. Hannebery
3. Howard
1. Geary
1. Coffield
1. Membrey
1. King

 

[Premium]

5/ Ryder
4/ Howard
3/ Hannerbery
2/ Carlisle
1/ Geary

 

[joop]

5 Ryder
4 Hannebery
3 Membrey
2 King
1 Carlisle

 

[borderbarry]

5. Ryder
3. Hannaberry
3. Howard
2. Coffield
1. Geary
1. Membrey

 

[gringo2011]

5 Hanners
4 Paddy
3 Geary
2 Howard
1 Coffield

 

[Witch1]

According to AFL website Dogs won by 40-odd points

 

[BrutThough]

4 - Ryder
3 - Hannebery
3 - Howard
2 - Geary
1 - Clark
1 - Coffield
1 - Membrey

 

[Hugh Jars]

4 Ryder
3 Hannebery
2 Geary
1 Howard
1 Clark
1 Coffield
1 Membery
1 Carlisle
1 King

 

[XhazzafootyX]

5- Ryder
4- Howard
3- Clark
2- Coffield
1- Hannebery

 

[MCG-Unit]

5 - Ryder
4 - Howard
2 - Membrey
1 - Geary
1 - Marshall
1 - Carlisle
1 - Steele

 

[PoppedCorn]

5 padd
4 doooooogs
1 hanners
1 hunter NEO clark
1 snake
1 kingy
1 skunk
1 gears

 

[George]

5. Ryder
4. Geary
3. King
2. Carlisle
1. Hannebery

 

[Tigerssaints]

5 Geary
5 Howard
5 Ryder

 

[phantom13]

Just give Ryder the full 15...

Seriously though

Ryder 5
Clark 3
Membrey 2
Howard 2
Hanners 2
Gears 1

King, Coff, Carlisle, butler all could have had claims (butler had 9 touches and I swear every one of them resulted in a score.

 

[Air King]

5 - Ryder
4 - Howard
3 - Geary
2 - Membrey
1 - King

Legendary game from Paddy.