Best Coach

[happy_eagle]

which of these 3 current coaches would be the best coach

sheedy
633 games
386 wins
240 losses
7 draws
4 premierships
3 runners up
0 wodden spoons
4 minor premierships
61.53% winning record
been coaching for 27 years

malthouse
559 games as coach
312 wins
243 losses
4 draws
2 premierships
3 runners up
0 wodden spoons
2 minor premierships
56.17% winning record
been coaching for 23 years


matthews
437 games as coach
257 wins
172 losses
8 draws
4 premierships
1 runner up
0 wodden spoons
4 minor premierships
59.73% winning record


people would immediately say sheedy, but i dont know

 

[Port_GW]

Probably Matthews according to premierships won but i dont rate the guy as a human being.

 

[WatWouldCyrilDo]

Probably Matthews according to premierships won but i dont rate the guy as a human being.

That you Neville?

 

[Dagless]

Probably Matthews according to premierships won but i dont rate the guy as a human being.

What the hell are you talking about??? Please explain this belief... In footy ya HAVE to be ruthless sometimes

 

[walkers a legend]

matthews

 

[Port_GW]

What the hell are you talking about??? Please explain this belief... In footy ya HAVE to be ruthless sometimes

I just dont like the guy, but heres 3 reasons why:

1) the Bruns incident

2) he ruined South Australia's greatest footballer's career back in the 70's through a thuggish hit (Barrie Robran i'm talking about)

and

3) he whinges about how Brisbane needs special treatment and in one particular instance sooked how the Lions lost Blake Caracella due to salary cap problems ("we've put all this work into him and now hes leaving the club blah blah blah", when it was Essendon's salary cap problems that forced him to leave Essendon to go to the Lions in the first place