Best First Nations Guernsey (2025)?

[Dirty Bird]

Now that they're all out, what are peoples thoughts?
Below is all that are currently available on the shop. What is everyone's favourite?

Adelaide

Brisbane

Carlton

Collingwood

Essendon

Fremantle

Geelong
.
Gold Coast

Greater Western Sydney

Hawthorn

Melbourne

North Melbourne

Port Adelaide

Richmond

St Kilda

Sydney

West Coast

Western Bulldogs

 

[Dirty Bird]

My thoughts

I like Brisbane, Fremantle, Gold Coast and Greater Western Sydney (Voted Brisbane)

I'm not big on Carlton.
Nor am I Essendon or Richmond.

Trying to decide Melbourne myself.

Also, was there a white Port Adelaide one? I thought I saw it somewhere and it looked good, but I couldn't find it on their online shop to steal a photo from.

 

[Clark G]

Freo. I like bringing back the green and red.

 

[Cold Ghost]

Adelaide
Fremantle
West Coast

 

[Cleavy]

all of them, except Carlton

 

[tiger_tough]

Brisbane's and Geelongs are woeful

 

[Dee Train]

Awful x 18

 

[Better Loosen Up]

Why have Richmond and St. Kilda got a bird on their guernsey's?

Not a fan of the North one. Needs to stick with the blue and white stripes.

Eagles is too busy. Looks like a kid's coloring in competition.

Geelong is awful.

Brisbane, Collingwood and Gold Coast are my preferred 3.

 

[bzparkes]

Crows the best.

 

[Black Panther]

Vancouver Canucks for mine. Honorable mention to the Winnipeg Jets and Calgary Flames

 

[Johnny Bananas]

I thought Adelaide's and Hawthorn's were both absolute fire. Went with Adelaide's red guernsey but it was a close run, all four were in contention for me.

 

[Orange crush]

I think I prefer the charcoal version for gws

 

[Johnny Bananas]

Why have Richmond and St. Kilda got a bird on their guernsey's?

Could be the totem animal of whoever designed them.

 

[troybe]

My thoughts

I like Brisbane, Fremantle, Gold Coast and Greater Western Sydney (Voted Brisbane)

I'm not big on Carlton.
Nor am I Essendon or Richmond.

Trying to decide Melbourne myself.

Also, was there a white Port Adelaide one? I thought I saw it somewhere and it looked good, but I couldn't find it on their online shop to steal a photo from.

Port Adelaide ⚡ on Instagram: "can’t wait to see both of these guernseys in action across the two weeks of Sir Doug Nicholls Round 😍"

6,697 likes, 29 comments - pafc on May 12, 2025: "can’t wait to see both of these guernseys in action across the two weeks of Sir Doug Nicholls Round 😍".

www.instagram.com

 

[Uncle_Leo]

North one not as good as previous year

Hawthorn brown the best one, should add it as a clash jumper

 

[PorkPieHat]

I genuinely think Hawthorn’s (brown) is the best, but in the interests of objectivity cast a vote for Adelaide - both their blue and red guernsey’s are works of art. Special mention to West Coast’s.
Some strong bird work this year.

 

[CURVE]

All of them have standout features (except Calton, Essendon and Richmond) mixed in with a few things that don't quite work as well. I think the Eagle on the front of West Coast jersey is a stunner and perhaps should be adopted by the club, whereas the Crow on the front of the Adelaide jersey doesn't work as well.

I like North Melbourne's but I don't think it's our best Indigenous jersey.

I'll give it to West Coast, the more I see it the more I like Eagle.