Best forward 6 of all time

Remove this Banner Ad

Forward Press

Forward Press

Hall of Famer
Fallout Fan Veteran Sweet F.A Sikh Volunteers Charity Match 10k Posts 30k Posts Wordler A Star Wars Fan Pokemon is Life
Jul 5, 2011
40,895
65,063
Perth
AFL Club
West Coast
Other Teams
Man Utd
Yes I know it's based on the one about the best back 6 of all time and Hawthorn probably win this one, but since it's season over for 12 teams may as well...

The Eagles one is probably fairly weak but quite competitive.

Darling Kennedy Embley
Ph Matera Sumich LeCras

Post yours - or not.
 
Carey CHF
Blight FF
Harvey on a flank
Jim Krakouer in a pocket

Probably throw in Grant as a forward flanker & one of Longmire, Petrie or P.Krakouer.

Definitely weak at the 5th & 6th spot for an all time 6 - but first 4 hold up real well.
 
Essendon:

Hird Salmon Mercuri
Bewick Lloyd Watson

Probably forgetting someone...
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Hird - T Daniher - Hutchison
Lloyd - Coleman - Bewick
 
Franklin Roughead Brereton
Breust Dunstall Matthews

Am I stiff leaving out Hudson/Rioli... I dunno I like the above team
 
Craig McRae, Alistair Lynch, Luke Power.
Jason Akermanis, Jonathan Brown, Daniel Bradshaw.
 
NetworkNerd said:
Franklin Roughead Brereton
Breust Dunstall Matthews

Am I stiff leaving out Hudson/Rioli... I dunno I like the above team
Click to expand...

Yeah, you don't leave Hudson out

Brereton Matthews Franklin
Rioli Hudson Dunstall

Rough, Breust, Peck (on of few players to win the Coleman three years in a row), Buckenarra, Jarman, all unlucky

And you could argue that Gary Ablett could be included too, which would make it ridiculous
 
This is the forward 6 from an All Australian team I picked from the period 1975 until now made up of players from the VFL/AFL, SANFL and the WAFL:

Ross Glendinning Royce Hart Wayne Johnston
Tony Lockett Jason Dunstall Lance 'Buddy' Franklin
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

HF: J.Cameron Hawkins G.Ablett Snr.
FF: Chapman Wade S.Johnson

2012 jumpin', leapin' Hawkins before the back issues.

Senior in that roaming role '84 through '89, interchangeable with the smalls in the pocket.

Wade the target man.

Chapman and Johnson fairly self explanatory as mobile pockets/flankers who push up the ground as well.

Cameron was poor when injured this year and is controversial based on his brief time as a Cat. But peak Cameron on a flank in this side would tear teams apart more than alternatives like Davis.

Ablett Junior played forward well before and after his peak. I have no doubt he'd have dominated on a flank 2007-2014 as well so there's your mobile forward rotation if required.
 
Geelong's 'd be up there I reckon. Not Hawks level, but probably Top 3-5.

HF: S. Johnson, Ablett Snr., Ablett Jnr.
F: D. Wade, T. Hawkins, P. Chapman

Doug Wade (1057 goals)
Ablett Snr. (1031 goals)
Hawkins (781 goals - current)
Steve Johnson (516 goals)
Ablett Jnr. (445 goals)
Paul Chapman (388 goals)

Combined 4000+ goals there. Ablett Jnr. slightly controversial, but he was a goal kicking forward for 7 years before he became a mid, so would be criminal to have guys like Brownless or Jez Cameron who has only been with us for 3 years, ahead of him.

Love the balance of that forward line too, and salivate at the the thought of those champs all playing together in a hypothetical universe, haha.
 
Roby said:
Yeah, you don't leave Hudson out

Brereton Matthews Franklin
Rioli Hudson Dunstall

Rough, Breust, Peck (on of few players to win the Coleman three years in a row), Buckenarra, Jarman, all unlucky

And you could argue that Gary Ablett could be included too, which would make it ridiculous
Click to expand...

Ablett kicked 10 of his 1031 goals with you, lol. Not sure you could argue that with a straight face. You already have more than enough quality to win this outright, so no need to include Ablett when he'd never be remembered as a Hawk anyway.
 
The Hawthorn forwards are absurd (cannot really include Ablett imo but you don't need him). Four can make legitimate claims to be in an all time AFL team and whoever you pick in the last two will be Hall of Fame level or close to it.

Probably a better debate is who is second - Geelong? Richmond? Essendon? Any other teams in contention?
 
Shadow89 said:
Ablett kicked 10 of his 1031 goals with you, lol. Not sure you could argue that with a straight face. You already have more than enough quality to win this outright, so no need to include Ablett when he'd never be remembered as a Hawk anyway.
Click to expand...

Obviously I didn't include him but on a technicality you could. He's listed in the AFL team of the century as (Geelong, Hawthorn)

By the way if you did, this is what it would look like:

Ablett Matthews Franklin
Rioli Hudson Dunstall

Probably the best forward line period, minus Lockett.
 
Pies:
HF: Fothergill, Carman, Daicos
FF: Rose, G Coventry, Condon

Fothergill was a fat arsed HFF who was an unstoppable goal machine, old timers say he was better than Daicos. Phil Carman played the best football anyone ever saw albeit for short periods. P Daicos you should know, if you don't, watch some footy. Bob Rose was a murderous hard rover and perhaps the best Magpie of all. Dick Condon was another smart arse genius, invented the stab pass and tore sides apart before WWI. We have probably 3 forward 6s as good as anyones.
 
Darren Jarman, Tony Modra, Eddie Betts
Mark Ricciuto, Taylor Walker, Brett Burton
 
Roby said:
Obviously I didn't include him but on a technicality you could. He's listed in the AFL team of the century as (Geelong, Hawthorn)

By the way if you did, this is what it would look like:

Ablett Matthews Franklin
Rioli Hudson Dunstall

Probably the best forward line period, minus Lockett.
Click to expand...
The best forward 6 that played together in my time (late 1970s onwards) was Hawthorn 1988. Witman Brereton Kennedy Abbott Dunstall Morrissey. Dismantled and humiliated the brutal Melbourne defence like they weren't there. Underrated and several lesser known but that year and that day, they have no peer.

People talk about Hudson and Matthews, fair enough they were brilliant but they were selfish players who made their team mates worse.

Dunstall is second only to Lockett for effectiveness as a pure FF and a superb team mate and brilliant defensive forward too: he didnt eat himself into a worse player like Plugger. GOAT Hawk in my view. Shame he's so unlikeable.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Best forward 6 of all time

Similar threads

Cleansweep17
Opinion Best AFL ad of all time?
Replies
23
Views
788
Woolly Mammoth
Woolly Mammoth
Lingsface
Best Back 6 All Time
2 3 4 5
Replies
120
Views
5K
peetoo
peetoo
Cleric
  • Poll
Prediction Who will be the best key position tall forward in the game?
2 3 4
Replies
80
Views
3K
Strapping Young Lad
Strapping Young Lad
Lingsface
All time State of Origin sides
2 3
Replies
70
Views
2K
Lingsface
Lingsface
iameviljez
Who of the last 20 years actually makes the AFL/VFL/SANFL/WAFL Best 23 of All Time?
Replies
20
Views
830
Wallaby
Wallaby
B
New Best Young Key Forwards (21 and under)
2 3 4 5 6
Replies
128
Views
8K
fnerd
F
BigVic
Best prelim finals of all time
3 4 5 6 7
Replies
163
Views
9K
timokane
T

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top